TL;DR
This paper introduces the "Contract Net" protocol, a novel approach to controlling distributed problem-solving in a network of independent processors. It formalizes how these processors can dynamically form task-specific coalitions by announcing tasks as "contracts," allowing other processors to "bid" on them, and awarding them to the most suitable contractor. This decentralized control mechanism offers flexibility and reliability for complex, spatially distributed computations.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The paper tackles the challenge of coordinating computation in distributed processing environments, particularly those composed of many independent, "loosely-coupled" processor nodes. As hardware advances lead to networks of single-chip processors, effectively managing these distributed resources for complex tasks becomes crucial. Traditional centralized control mechanisms struggle with scalability and fault tolerance in such environments. The authors aim to provide a flexible and robust control framework that emphasizes "coarse-grain parallelism," where individual nodes focus on substantial computations and communicate only when necessary, rather than relying on a single point of control or extensive shared resources.
Methods
The core of the paper is the Contract Net protocol. This protocol defines a dynamic, decentralized mechanism for task allocation and execution among distributed processors. The key steps involve:
- Contract Announcement: A node with a task broadcasts its existence as a "contract manager," announcing the task to the network.
- Bidding: Other nodes, acting as potential "contractors," evaluate the announced contract based on their capabilities and local knowledge, and submit "bids."
- Awarding: The contract manager selects the best bid and awards the contract to the chosen contractor.
- Execution and Reporting: The contractor executes the task and reports the results back to the manager.
The protocol also supports subcontracting, allowing contractors to delegate parts of a task if specialized expertise or data is required. The system is designed to be fault-tolerant; if a contractor fails, the manager can simply re-announce the contract. The paper also touches upon the concept of priority for contracts, suggesting it needs to be a generalized description encompassing both application-specific and architectural information.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Decentralized Control is Key: The Contract Net protocol demonstrates that effective control in distributed systems can be achieved through a decentralized, market-like mechanism rather than a centralized manager.
- Dynamic Coalition Formation: Processors can dynamically form task-specific groups (coalitions) based on their immediate needs and capabilities, leading to flexible and adaptable problem-solving.
- Fault Tolerance through Redundancy: The bid-award mechanism inherently provides fault tolerance. If one processor fails, the task can be re-assigned to another, preventing system-wide failure.
- Importance of Local Knowledge: Bidding and contract awarding are based on local knowledge, making the system efficient by avoiding unnecessary global communication.
- Generalized Priority: The concept of "priority" for contracts is not a simple number but a rich description that can include application-specific needs and hardware capabilities, allowing for more intelligent resource allocation.
Key Results
The paper describes a SAIL simulation constructed to test the Contract Net formalism. This simulation maps application programs onto a simulated distributed processor with a variable number of nodes. The simulation is used to evaluate:
- The costs associated with the formalism, specifically processor and communication overhead.
- The decrease in computation time achievable for various applications.
The paper specifically mentions that distributed heuristic search is being examined using this simulation, with plans to explore distributed deduction in the future. Quantitative results from the simulation are not detailed in this excerpt.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that the Contract Net formalism is being tested via simulation. Future work suggested includes:
- Further exploration of the simulation to quantify costs and performance gains for different applications.
- Examining alternatives in distributed deduction in addition to heuristic search.
- Investigating how to pass global context when needed, or how to let further contracts to obtain it.
- Exploring the implications of the priority description for more sophisticated resource allocation.
Summary updated