The Complex of Non-Chromatic Scales

Kathlén Kohn, Ernst Ulrich DeukerarXiv 2017 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We consider the space of all musical scales with the ambition to systematize it. To do this, we pursue the idea to view certain scales as basic constituents and to "mix" all remaining scales from these. This research applies the tools of algebraic topology to music theory, modeling the space of "non-chromatic" scales as a simplicial complex.

Introduction

Music theory often categorizes scales through historical or aesthetic lenses, but lacks a unified mathematical framework to systematize the "space of all possible scales." This paper addresses this gap by focusing on non-chromatic scales: those that do not contain three consecutive semitones (e.g., C, C#, D). By treating the 12 pitch classes of Western music as a ground set, we explore why certain scales are more "maximal" or "fundamental" than others using the language of simplicial complexes.

Methodology: Simplicial Complexes and Homology

The authors define a complex $K_{NC}$ where every "simplex" is a non-chromatic scale. Because removing a note from a non-chromatic scale always results in another non-chromatic scale, the set of all such scales satisfies the mathematical definition of a simplicial complex.

Key analytical steps included:

  1. Combinatorial Analysis: Calculating the $f$-vector, which counts non-chromatic scales for every possible number of notes (0 through 12).
  2. Facet Identification: Identifying the facets—maximal scales where adding another note would violate the non-chromatic rule.
  3. Homology Calculations: Using software like polymake to identify "holes" in different dimensions, describing the "shape" of the musical space.

Key Results: The Facets of Western Music

The distribution of non-chromatic scales (the $f$-vector) is $(1, 12, 66, 208, 399, 456, 282, 72, 3)$. This reveals that there are no non-chromatic scales with 9 or more notes, and exactly three with 8 notes.

Crucially, the 57 maximal non-chromatic scales (facets) correspond exactly to the most widely used scales in Western music. These are categorized into seven distinct interval sequences, as shown in the table below.

Table 1: The seven interval sequences of the 57 maximal non-chromatic scales.

Topological Structure and the "Three Holes"

The complex is "not pure," meaning its maximal scales have different numbers of notes (6, 7, or 8). The topology of $K_{NC}$ is characterized by three 5-dimensional holes ($H_5(K_{NC}) \cong \mathbb{Q}^3$). These holes are formed by hexatonic (6-note) scales and are linked to the nine-note scales used by composer Olivier Messiaen.

The three 8-note scales identified in the $f$-vector are the diminished scales, which represent the highest-dimensional simplices in the complex.

Figure 1: The three diminished scales, which are the only non-chromatic scales with 8 pitch classes.

Conclusion

This topological framework reveals that the fundamental scales of Western music—Major, Melodic Minor, Diminished, etc.—emerge naturally as the maximal elements of a non-chromatic simplicial complex. While the model currently excludes scales with chromatic clusters (like the blues scale) and is limited to the 12-tone system, it provides a robust mathematical foundation for understanding the "primary colors" of musical texture. Future work may explore transitions between these scales as paths within the complex.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider the space of all musical scales with the ambition to systematize it. To do this, we pursue the idea to view certain scales as basic constituents and to "mix" all remaining scales from these. The German version of this article appeared in Mitteilungen der DMV, volume 25, issue 1.
BibTeX
@misc{kohn2017complex,
  author = {Kathlén Kohn and Ernst Ulrich Deuker},
  title = {{The Complex of Non-Chromatic Scales}},
  year = {2017},
  eprint = {1710.05979},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1710.05979},
}
Figure