Generalized Tonnetze

Michael J. CatanzaroJournal of Mathematics and Music 2011 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: We study a generalization of the classical Riemannian Tonnetz to N-tone equally tempered scales (for all N) and arbitrary triads. We classify all the spaces that result. The torus turns out to be the most common possibility, especially as N grows. Other spaces include 2-simplices, tetrahedra boundaries, and the harmonic strip (in both its cylinder and Möbius band variants). The final and most exotic space we find is something we call a ‘circle of tetrahedra boundaries’. These are the Tonnetze for spaces of triads which contain a tritone. They are closely related to Peck's Klein bottle Tonnetz.

Introduction

In music theory, the Tonnetz (tone-network) is a conceptual grid used to visualize the relationships between notes and chords. Traditionally, the neo-Riemannian Tonnetz represents major and minor triads in a 12-tone system as a tiling on a torus. This research addresses a fundamental gap in musical geometry: determining the possible global shapes of these chord spaces when the number of notes in the scale ($N$) or the internal structure of the chords is varied.

Methodology: Simplicial Modeling

The author employs the tools of algebraic topology and simplicial complexes to categorize these spaces. A three-note chord (triad) is treated as a 2-simplex (a triangle), where individual notes are 0-simplices (vertices) and the intervals between them are 1-simplices (edges). The set of all chords is generated using the $T/I$ group (transpositions and inversions) acting on a base triad in the universe of integers modulo $N$ ($\mathbb{Z}/N$).

Figure 5: A triangular tiling of the plane representing a generalized Tonnetz. The periodicity of the labels indicates how the plane is mathematically wrapped to form a torus.

To classify the resulting spaces, the author calculates topological invariants such as the Euler characteristic ($\chi = V - E + F$) and uses simplicial homology to determine connectedness. A Tonnetz is a single, connected object if and only if the greatest common divisor of its internal intervals is 1.

Key Insights: Symmetry and Topology

The global shape of a chord space is dictated by the symmetry of the triads and the parity of $N$:

  • The Torus as the Generic Case: For most chord shapes, especially as $N$ increases, the Tonnetz naturally forms a torus.
  • Symmetry Dictates Topology: If two intervals are equal (isosceles triads), the space often forms a "harmonic strip"—either a cylinder or a Möbius band. The author proves that Möbius bands can only occur in musical scales with an odd number of notes.
  • The Tritone Pinch: When a chord contains a tritone (an interval of $N/2$), the space ceases to be a manifold. Because the tritone is its own inversion, four different triangles meet at a single edge, creating a "circle of tetrahedra boundaries."
Figure 6: The process of gluing triangles along shared edges. This identification is central to constructing the global topology of non-manifold spaces like the circle of tetrahedra boundaries.

Results and Classification

The paper culminates in a complete topological classification for any generalized Tonnetz $C(n_1, n_2, n_3)$:

Chord Relation Resulting Topology
$n_1 = n_2 = n_3$ Disjoint 2-simplices
$n_1 = n_2 < n_3 = N/2$ Tetrahedron boundaries (Spheres)
$n_1 = n_2 < n_3 \neq N/2$ (N even) Cylinders
$n_1 = n_2 < n_3 \neq N/2$ (N odd) Möbius bands
$n_1 + n_2 = n_3 = N/2$ Circle of tetrahedra boundaries
$n_1 < n_2 < n_3$ Torus

Conclusion and Future Work

This work provides a rigorous mathematical foundation for musical geometry, moving beyond the standard 12-tone major/minor map. Future research may extend these methods to higher-order chords (tetrachords or pentachords), which would require 3-dimensional or higher simplicial complexes, significantly increasing topological complexity.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study a generalization of the classical Riemannian Tonnetz to N-tone equally tempered scales (for all N) and arbitrary triads. We classify all the spaces that result. The torus turns out to be the most common possibility, especially as N grows. Other spaces include 2-simplices, tetrahedra boundaries, and the harmonic strip (in both its cylinder and Möbius band variants). The final and most exotic space we find is something we call a ‘circle of tetrahedra boundaries’. These are the Tonnetze for spaces of triads which contain a tritone. They are closely related to Peck's Klein bottle Tonnetz.
BibTeX
@article{catanzaro2011generalized,
  author = {Michael J. Catanzaro},
  title = {{Generalized <i>Tonnetze</i>}},
  journal = {Journal of Mathematics and Music},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1080/17459737.2011.614448},
}
Figure