The Comparison of Paper Textbook Class and Electronic Textbook Class in Technology Rich Classroom

Ruby Yu-Nien Huang, Guang Chen, Junfeng Yang, Yanyan LiInternational Conference on Computers in Education 2013 · DOI

Abstract

Electronic textbooks have significant potential to transform traditional teaching and learning. This research examines the transition from paper textbook classes in Technology Rich Classrooms (pTRC) to electronic textbook classes (eTRC) from the perspective of effective learning. Using a mixed-methods design involving 209 students and 12 teachers across 48 sessions, the study compared class activity capacity, classroom behaviors, and technology roles. Findings indicate that eTRC environments lead to higher activity completion rates, significantly improved Learner Engagement Indicators (LEI), and a shift from teacher-led transmission to student-centered cooperative learning. Students in eTRC settings also reported significantly higher satisfaction and more positive attitudes toward technology.

Introduction

While many modern classrooms are now "Technology Rich" (TRC)—equipped with projectors, whiteboards, and internet access—the underlying pedagogical model often remains a traditional "stand-and-deliver" approach. This study addresses the gap in understanding how the medium of the textbook itself (paper vs. electronic) influences classroom dynamics and "activity capacity," which is the ability to effectively complete planned learning tasks. The goal is to determine if eTextbooks can better align instruction with the learning preferences of "digital native" students.

Methodology

The researchers employed a mixed-methods approach, including on-site observations, interviews, and questionnaires, to compare pTRC and eTRC settings. The study involved Grade 4 students from two primary schools in Beijing, comparing 24 sessions of each textbook type.

Conceptual framework comparing pTRC and eTRC environments and data collection methods.

To quantify classroom dynamics, the team utilized a specific coding scheme for classroom behaviors (CB). This framework categorized interactions into teacher-led transmission, directing, and dialogue, as well as student-led individual and cooperative learning.

Coding scheme for classroom behaviors used to analyze teacher and student interactions.

Key Results and Analysis

The quantitative analysis revealed statistically significant improvements ($p < 0.01$) in the eTRC environment across several key metrics:

  • Class Activity Capacity (CAC): The percentage of classes that successfully completed all planned learning activities rose from 50% in pTRC to 71% in eTRC. Furthermore, the Learner Engagement Indicator (LEI) jumped from 0.56 to 0.87.
  • Behavioral Shifts: There was a marked reduction in teacher "transmission" time (lecturing), which dropped from 10.47 minutes to 6.07 minutes. Simultaneously, student time spent in cooperative learning increased from 6.92 minutes to 11.20 minutes.
  • Technology Roles: Using the SMART model, the study found that iPads in the eTRC served as integral tools for real-time interaction and tracking the learning process, rather than just digital mirrors of paper content.
  • Student Satisfaction: Students reported high levels of satisfaction (4.20/5.0) and positive attitudes toward technology (4.21/5.0) in the eTextbook sessions.

Conclusion

The transition from paper to electronic textbooks in a technology-rich environment facilitates a meaningful shift toward student-centered learning. By reducing the time spent on passive lecturing and increasing opportunities for cooperative engagement, eTextbooks enhance the overall activity capacity of the classroom. While technical barriers and the "novelty effect" remain areas for future longitudinal study, these results suggest that eTextbooks are a vital component in modernizing primary education pedagogy.

Summary updated

Abstract

Electronic textbook has significantly potential to change the traditional ways of teaching and learning. In this paper, we conducted a research to examine the change from paper textbook class in Technology Rich Classroom (pTRC) to electronic textbook class in Technology Rich Classroom (eTRC) from the perspective of effective learning, by using a mix-method design of interview, questionnaire and on-site observation. There were 209 students and 12 teachers from six classes equipped with iPads from two primary schools were taken part in the study, and each class conducted 4 eTextbook sessions and 4 paper textbook sessions. We compared the 24 eTextbook sessions and 24 paper textbook sessions by analyzing class activity capacity, classroom behaviors and technology roles. The comparison shows: (1) There are significant differences in class activity capacity between eTRC and pTRC. The ratio of class es which effectively completed the learning activities as planed in eTRC is higher than in pTRC, and Learner Engagement Indicator (LEI) in eTRC is significantly higher than in pTRC . (2)There are significant changes in classroom behaviors between eTRC and pTRC. The allocated time for teachers in eTRC is significantly lower than in pTRC and engaged time for students in eTRC is significantly higher than in pTRC. Students participate in classroom learning activities significantly initiatively and positively in eTRC compared to in pTRC. (3) Students attitudes to technology and satisfaction in eTRC are significantly higher than in pTRC.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2013comparison,
  author = {Ruby Yu-Nien Huang and Guang Chen and Junfeng Yang and Yanyan Li},
  title = {{The Comparison of Paper Textbook Class and Electronic Textbook Class in Technology Rich Classroom}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Computers in Education},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.58459/icce.2013.1250},
}
Figure