The Association Between Inter-Hospital Transfers and the Prognosis of Pediatric Injury in the Emergency Department

D.l. Jung, Jin Hee Jung, Jin Hee Kim, Jie Hee Jue, Joong Wan Park, Do Kyun Kim, Jae Yun Jung, Eui Jun Lee, Jin Hee Lee, Dongbum Suh, Hyuksool KwonJournal of Korean Medical Science 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Among pediatric injured patients requiring hospitalization, inter-hospital transfer in the emergency department was significantly associated with increased 30-day and 72-hour mortality rates in South Korea.

Introduction

In pediatric trauma care, the speed and quality of the initial response are critical to survival. Ideally, severely injured children should be transported directly to facilities equipped with specialized pediatric trauma resources. However, due to geographical constraints or limited local resources, many children are first stabilized at local emergency departments before being transferred to higher-level centers.

While inter-hospital transfer (IHT) is a recognized risk factor in adult trauma, its impact on pediatric outcomes has been inconsistent in global literature. In South Korea, where dedicated pediatric trauma centers and standardized transport protocols are still evolving, understanding the impact of the IHT process is vital. This study sought to determine if the transfer process itself is associated with worse outcomes for children within the Korean healthcare context.

Methods

This retrospective observational study utilized data from the Emergency Department-based Injury in Depth Surveillance (EDIIS) database, a robust clinical registry managed by the Korea Disease Control and Prevention Agency. The researchers analyzed data from 2013 to 2017, focusing on hospitalized patients under the age of 18.

Flowchart of the study population selection process

As shown in the selection flowchart, the final study population consisted of 18,518 patients. These were categorized into two groups: those admitted directly to the study hospital ("direct admission") and those transferred from another facility ("inter-hospital transfer"). To ensure a fair comparison, the researchers used the EMR-ISS (Excess Mortality Ratio-adjusted Injury Severity Score) to adjust for injury severity. Statistical analysis included Cox proportional hazards regression to calculate the Hazard Ratio (HR) for mortality, adjusting for age, sex, severity, and the presence of head injuries.

Key Results and Insights

The study revealed a significant "transfer penalty" for pediatric patients that persisted even after adjusting for the severity of their injuries:

  • Mortality Gap: The overall mortality rate was 4.2% for the transfer group compared to 2.0% for the direct visit group.
  • Increased Risk: After controlling for confounders, transferred patients faced a 95.1% higher risk of 72-hour mortality (HR 1.951) and a 68.1% higher risk of 30-day mortality (HR 1.681).
  • The 72-Hour Window: The negative impact of transfer was most pronounced in the immediate aftermath of the injury, suggesting that the "danger zone" is concentrated during or shortly after the transport process.
  • Mechanism Disparity: There was a clear difference in injury types; direct visits were often related to falls and slips (41.5%), whereas transfers were predominantly linked to motor vehicle collisions (48.1%).
  • Recovery Complexity: Surviving patients in the transfer group had significantly longer hospital stays (median 9 days vs. 5 days), indicating a more complex path to recovery.

Discussion and Future Work

The findings suggest that the increased risk of death in transferred children is not solely due to higher injury severity but may be linked to the systemic gaps in the transfer process. The authors highlight the lack of specialized Pediatric Transfer Teams (PTTs) in Korea—which are common in many Western countries—as a potential driver of these results. Without specialized staff and equipment during transport, a child's physiological stability can deteriorate.

Limitations

The study is limited by the "black box" of the transport period; the EDIIS database does not record specific details such as the type of ambulance used or the qualifications of the medical staff on board. Furthermore, the use of a diagnosis-based severity score (EMR-ISS) rather than real-time physiological markers (like vital signs) may limit the precision of the severity adjustment.

Conclusion

To improve outcomes, the study calls for the development of more effective on-site triage protocols to reduce unnecessary transfers and the establishment of specialized pediatric transport teams to maintain patient stability when a transfer is unavoidable.

Summary updated

Abstract

Among the pediatric injured patients requiring hospitalization, inter-hospital transfer in the emergency department was associated with the 30-day mortality rate and 72-hour mortality rate in Korea.
BibTeX
@article{jung2023association,
  author = {D.L. Jung and Jin Hee Jung and Jin Hee Kim and Jie Hee Jue and Joong Wan Park and Do Kyun Kim and Jae Yun Jung and Eui Jun Lee and Jin Hee Lee and Dongbum Suh and Hyuksool Kwon},
  title = {{The Association Between Inter-Hospital Transfers and the Prognosis of Pediatric Injury in the Emergency Department}},
  journal = {Journal of Korean Medical Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3346/jkms.2024.39.e2},
}
Figure