Abstract
Objectives: It is critical to review pediatric mortality and identify preventable/potentially preventable death (PD). We sought to characterize mortality in pediatric trauma patients at our center and identify causes of PD.
Introduction
In pediatric trauma care, low overall mortality rates can mask underlying quality issues. "Total deaths" is often an insufficient metric for evaluating trauma center performance because many fatalities result from non-survivable injuries, such as massive blunt head trauma. To drive meaningful improvements in care, researchers must distinguish these from Preventable Deaths (PD)—cases where a patient might have survived had optimal clinical or systemic care been delivered. This study examines mortality at a mature Level 1/2 trauma center to identify specific clinical gaps and systemic hurdles that still lead to avoidable fatalities.
Methods
A retrospective review was conducted of all pediatric trauma deaths (age <14) at an ACS-verified Level 1 adult/Level 2 pediatric trauma center over a 10-year period (2006–2016). The study utilized the Injury Severity Score (ISS) and the Trauma & Injury Severity Score (TRISS) to evaluate injury depth and survival probability.
A multidisciplinary panel reviewed every death against a "gold standard" definition of preventability: the injury was survivable, care was suboptimal, and errors contributed to the outcome. Notably, researchers integrated autopsy reports to recalculate ISS and TRISS, ensuring the data reflected internal injuries that may have been missed during initial resuscitation.
Results
Out of 3,065 pediatric trauma admissions, the overall mortality rate was 1.6% (49 deaths). Of these, the Preventable Death Rate (PDR) was determined to be 6% (3/49). Blunt trauma was the primary mechanism of injury (85%), and 31% of deaths were attributed to Non-Accidental Trauma (NAT).
A critical finding was the utility of the TRISS score as a screening tool. Every identified preventable death occurred in patients with a TRISS score greater than 50%, indicating a better-than-even chance of survival at admission. This correlation was statistically significant (p=0.019).
The specific clinical causes of preventable death involved classic trauma pitfalls: failure to control hemorrhage and failure to secure an airway. Detailed review of these cases highlighted both clinical and systemic deficiencies.
Discussion
The "TRISS > 50%" threshold provides an actionable metric for Quality Improvement (QI) programs. By focusing deep-dive reviews on high-TRISS mortalities, centers can more efficiently identify systemic and clinical failures.
The study also highlighted the "data lag" inherent in trauma registries. Autopsy reports led to an increase in ISS and a decrease in TRISS in 55% of cases where they were available, suggesting that without post-mortem data, the severity of injuries is often underestimated. Furthermore, the preventable cases revealed that both clinical errors (e.g., airway management) and systemic delays (e.g., a 7-hour transfer delay from a non-trauma center) remain significant barriers to achieving zero preventable deaths.
Conclusion
While mortality at mature trauma centers is low, preventable deaths still occur due to failures in hemorrhage control and airway management. Future work should involve multi-center collaborations to increase the sample size of preventable deaths and the prospective monitoring of new clinical protocols to eliminate these avoidable tragedies.
Summary updated