Temporal and Spectral Properties of the Persistent Radio Source Associated with FRB 20190520B with the VLA

Xian Zhang, Wenfei Yu, Casey Law, Di Li, Shami Chatterjee, Paul Demorest, Zhen Yan, Chenhui Niu, K.k. Aggarwal, Reshma Anna-Thomas, Sarah Burke-Spolaor, Liam Connor, Chao‐Wei Tsai, Weiwei Zhu, Gan Luo

TL;DR

Researchers using the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array (VLA) have detected a ~20% decrease in the radio flux of the persistent radio source (PRS) associated with the repeating fast radio burst FRB 20190520B. This evidence of yearly evolution and sub-parsec size constraints suggests the PRS may originate from an accreting compact object, such as an intermediate-mass black hole or a young magnetar nebula.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Fast Radio Bursts (FRBs) are intense, millisecond-long flashes of radio waves from deep space. While we have cataloged hundreds of them, only two—FRB 20121102A and FRB 20190520B—are known to be associated with a "Persistent Radio Source" (PRS), a steady "glow" that remains active even when the FRB isn't bursting.

The nature of these PRSs is a major missing piece in the FRB puzzle. Are they caused by star formation in the host galaxy, a nebula powered by a young magnetar (a Pulsar Wind Nebula), or perhaps jets from an accreting black hole? By studying how a PRS changes over time (its temporal variability) and its energy distribution across frequencies (its spectrum), astronomers can constrain the size and physical environment of the FRB's "engine."

Methods

The authors analyzed multi-epoch observations of FRB 20190520B taken with the VLA in 2020 and 2021.

  • Observations: They looked at four frequency bands: L (1.5 GHz), S (3 GHz), C (5.5 GHz), and X (10 GHz).
  • Variability Analysis: They used statistical metrics—the flux variation coefficient ($V$) and a weighted reduced $\chi^2$ statistic ($\eta$)—to determine if changes in brightness were statistically significant or just noise.
  • Scintillation Modeling: They calculated whether the observed "twinkling" could be caused by the Earth's interstellar medium (refractive scintillation) or if it was intrinsic to the source itself.
  • Physical Constraints: By assuming the source is in "equipartition" (where magnetic field energy equals particle energy) and looking for signs of "self-absorption" (where the source becomes opaque to its own radiation), they derived limits on the source's physical size and magnetic field strength.

Datasets

The study primarily utilized:

  • VLA 2020 Data: Observations from July to November 2020 (previously reported in Niu et al. 2022).
  • VLA 2021 Data: New observations taken in October and November 2021 (Project ID: 21B-127).
  • Ancillary Data: Redshift and localization data from the TNS (Transient Name Server) and previous FAST telescope surveys.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The PRS is Evolving: The most significant finding is a likely ~20% broadband flux decrease between 2020 and 2021. This suggests the PRS is not a static feature (like a standard star-forming region) but a dynamic system evolving on a human timescale.
  • A "Radio Flare" in 2020: The 3 GHz data from 2020 showed a rise in flux over 63 days. If this was an intrinsic flare, the emission region must be tiny—roughly 0.14 parsecs (about 5.4 light-months) across.
  • Size Discrepancy: There is a tension between size estimates. Variability suggests a sub-parsec size, while spectral modeling (equipartition) suggests a size $\gtrsim 0.22$ pc. This might imply the PRS has multiple components: a steady, larger nebula and a smaller, variable core.
  • The Accretion Hypothesis: The high luminosity and fading nature make it unlikely that the PRS is a standard Supernova Remnant. Instead, the authors suggest it could be a relativistic jet from an accreting compact object, such as an Intermediate-Mass Black Hole (IMBH) or a high-mass X-ray binary.

Key Results

  • Flux Decrease: At 3 GHz, the flux density dropped from $193.5 \pm 10.1$ $\mu$Jy in 2020 to $111.5 \pm 23.7$ $\mu$Jy in 2021—a $3.2\sigma$ significance level.
  • Broadband Trend: Assuming a constant spectral index ($\alpha \approx -0.4$), the overall normalization of the radio emission decreased by ~20% over one year.
  • Magnetic Field: The magnetic field strength was estimated to be $B_{eq} \lesssim 0.9$ Gauss, assuming equipartition.
  • Scintillation: The authors concluded that the 3 GHz variability is likely intrinsic to the source, as the observed flux changes exceeded what would be expected from Galactic scintillation alone.

Limitations and Future Work

  • RFI Contamination: Observations in the P-band (0.35 GHz) were heavily corrupted by Radio Frequency Interference (RFI), preventing the team from pinning down the low-frequency "turnover" of the spectrum, which is crucial for more precise size measurements.
  • Scintillation Ambiguity: While the authors argue for intrinsic variability, they acknowledge that more frequent monitoring is needed to definitively separate intrinsic source evolution from "twinkling" caused by the interstellar medium.
  • Future Monitoring: Long-term, multi-year monitoring is essential to see if the flux continues to decline or if it fluctuates, which would help distinguish between a fading explosion (like a magnetar birth) and a flickering accretion process (like a black hole jet).

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Among more than 800 known fast radio bursts (FRBs), only two, namely FRB 20121102A and FRB 20190520B, are confirmed to be associated with persistent radio sources (PRSs). Here, we report evidence of apparent temporal variability in the PRS associated with the bursting FRB 20190520B based on Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array observations taken in 2020 and 2021. Based on the analysis of the epoch-to-epoch variability of the PRS at the L , S , C , and X bands (1–12 GHz), we detected not only overall marginal variability, but also a likely radio flux decrease ( σ ∼ 3.2) between the observations taken in 2020 and 2021 at 3 GHz. Assuming no spectral variation in the PRS during these observations, we found evidence for an overall broadband radio flux decrease by about 20% between the 2020 and the 2021 observations, suggesting that the PRS probably evolves on a yearly timescale. If we attribute the marginal variability at 3 GHz as intrinsic or due to scintillation, the size of the potential variable component of the PRS is constrained to be subparsec. On the other hand, the size of the PRS can be also constrained to ≳0.22 pc from the time-averaged radio spectrum and the integrated radio luminosity in the 1–12 GHz band, based on equipartition and self-absorption arguments. We discuss the potential origins of the PRS and suggest that an accreting compact object origin might be able to explain the PRS’s temporal and spectral properties. Confirmation of the variability or flux decline of the PRS will be critical for our understanding of the PRS and its relation to the bursting source.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2023temporal,
  author = {Xian Zhang and Wenfei Yu and Casey Law and Di Li and Shami Chatterjee and Paul Demorest and Zhen Yan and Chenhui Niu and K.K. Aggarwal and Reshma Anna-Thomas and Sarah Burke-Spolaor and Liam Connor and Chao‐Wei Tsai and Weiwei Zhu and Gan Luo},
  title = {{Temporal and Spectral Properties of the Persistent Radio Source Associated with FRB 20190520B with the VLA}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3847/1538-4357/ad0545},
}

Loading related content...

Figure