Telegraph Flux Noise Induced Beating Ramsey Fringe in Transmon Qubits

Zhihao Wu, Lihua Lei, Xinfang Zhang, Suqin Xue, Shun Hu, Cong Li, Xiang Fu, Ping-Xing Chen, Lu Kai, Mingtang Deng, Jun‐Jie Wu

In the world of superconducting quantum computing, the Ramsey fringe is a bread-and-butter diagnostic. It’s the standard way to measure how long a qubit can hold onto its quantum state before environmental noise washes it away. Usually, we expect these oscillations to fade out in a smooth, exponential decay.

However, experimentalists often run into a "beating" pattern—where the signal pulses in and out like a mistuned guitar string. For years, the community has largely blamed this on charge noise. But a new paper by Zhi-Hao Wu and colleagues suggests we’ve been looking at the wrong culprit in frequency-tunable transmons. They demonstrate that Random Telegraph Noise (RTN) in the magnetic flux is a much more likely suspect.

TL;DR

While "beating" patterns in qubit Ramsey fringes are usually attributed to charge noise, this study proves they can be caused by strong, telegraph-like flux noise from lab electronics. By modeling this as Random Telegraph Noise (RTN), the researchers matched simulations to experimental data, showing how external electromagnetic interference can mimic internal qubit defects.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Qubit decoherence is the primary hurdle to scaling quantum computers. We use Ramsey interferometry to characterize this decoherence. In an ideal world, the signal decays exponentially as the qubit loses "phase" information. But in reality, we often see non-monotonic "beating" envelopes.

Historically, researchers attributed this beating to charge noise—fluctuations in the electrical environment or quasiparticles tunneling across junctions. However, modern "transmon" qubits are designed specifically to be insensitive to charge noise. If the qubit is immune to charge, why is it still beating? The authors investigate whether flux noise (fluctuations in the magnetic field threading the qubit) is the true origin, especially in frequency-tunable qubits that are highly sensitive to magnetic environments.

Methods

The team combined theoretical modeling with "noisy" experimental validation:

  1. The Decoherence Model: They developed a model for transmon qubits that treats low-frequency noise as an adiabatic modulation of the qubit's frequency. Instead of a simple decay constant, they used a stochastic process $\delta\Phi(t)$ to represent flux fluctuations.
  2. The RTN Model: They modeled the noise as Random Telegraph Noise. While a massive sum of many weak RTN sources creates the standard $1/f$ noise we see everywhere, they hypothesized that a few strong RTN sources (switching between two discrete states) create the beating.
  3. Numerical Simulation: They generated 3,000 sample noise functions to simulate the "multi-shot" nature of quantum experiments, averaging the results to see if the beating emerged.
  4. Experimental Setup: They tested five transmon qubits on a superconducting chip. Crucially, they intentionally moved their lab's DC-current sources (used for HEMT amplifiers) to different locations to see how external electromagnetic radiation affected the Ramsey fringes.

Datasets

The study relies on two primary data sources:

  • Experimental Ramsey Data: Measurements from five frequency-tunable transmon qubits. The researchers compared data from "quiet" spots vs. "noisy" spots (determined by the physical proximity of electronic instrumentation).
  • Simulated Noise Samples: A generated dataset of 3,000 RTN sample functions used to validate the mathematical model against the experimental fringes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Frequency Doublet: A strong RTN source causes the qubit to jump between two distinct transition frequencies. These two frequencies interfere with each other, creating the classic interference "beat" in the time domain.
  • Flux Sensitivity is Key: The beating frequency was found to be proportional to the qubit's flux sensitivity ($df_{01}/d\Phi_b$). This is the "smoking gun" that proves the noise is flux-based rather than charge-based.
  • The "Weak-but-Many" Limit: The authors show a fascinating transition: if you have only 1 or 2 strong noise sources, you get clear beating. As you add more sources ($N > 100$), the complex interference patterns average out, and you return to a standard, smooth exponential decay.
  • Lab Hardware as a Noise Source: The beating wasn't intrinsic to the qubit chip itself. It was traced to electromagnetic radiation from the DC power supplies in the lab being picked up by the cryostat's wiring.

Key Results

  • Excellent Agreement: The RTN-based simulations showed a near-perfect match with the experimental beating patterns observed in the qubits.
  • Eliminating the Ghost: By simply moving the DC-current source away from the "plugboard" of the dilution refrigerator, the researchers were able to eliminate the beating and restore standard exponential decay.
  • Quantified Noise: They identified the specific parameters of the offending noise: a switching frequency ($\lambda$) of roughly 50 Hz and an amplitude ($b$) of approximately $4.2 \times 10^{-5} \Phi_0$.
  • Rule Out Charge Noise: The results effectively rule out charge noise or coherently coupled two-level systems (TLS) as the cause of the beating in these specific frequency-tunable devices.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while they identified a macroscopic source of RTN (lab electronics), RTN can also be microscopic (e.g., a single stray electron spin flipping near the SQUID loop).

Future work could involve:

  • Using this model to identify and "fingerprint" microscopic noise sources that are intrinsic to the materials.
  • Developing better shielding or filtering for the "plugboard" areas of dilution refrigerators to prevent external RTN from reaching the qubits.
  • Exploring how these telegraph-like fluctuations impact gate fidelities in multi-qubit processors.

Paper Citation: Wu, Z.-H., et al. (2025). Telegraph flux noise induced beating Ramsey fringe in transmon qubits. arXiv:2502.05499v1 [quant-ph].

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Ramsey oscillations typically exhibit an exponential decay envelope due to environmental noise. However, recent experiments have observed nonmonotonic Ramsey fringes characterized by beating patterns, which deviate from the standard behavior. These beating patterns have primarily been attributed to charge-noise fluctuations. In this paper, we have experimentally observed Ramsey fringe with beating pattern for transmon qubits, and traced the origin to electric instruments induced flux noise. We developed a random telegraph noise (RTN) model to simulate the impact of telegraph-like flux-noise sources on Ramsey oscillations. Our simulations demonstrate that strong flux-RTN sources can induce beating patterns in the Ramsey fringes, showing excellent agreement with experimental observations in transmon qubits influenced by electronic environment-induced flux-noise. Our findings provide valuable insights into the role of flux-noise in qubit decoherence and underscore the importance of considering flux-noise RTN when analyzing nonmonotonic Ramsey fringes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2025telegraph,
  author = {Zhihao Wu and Lihua Lei and Xinfang Zhang and Suqin Xue and Shun Hu and Cong Li and Xiang Fu and Ping-Xing Chen and Lu Kai and Mingtang Deng and Jun‐Jie Wu},
  title = {{Telegraph Flux Noise Induced Beating Ramsey Fringe in Transmon Qubits}},
  booktitle = {Chinese},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1088/0256-307x/42/4/040501},
}

Loading related content...

Figure