Technoeconomic Feasibility of Bioenergy Production from Wood Sawdust

Peyman Alizadeh, Lope G. Tabil, Edmund Mupondwa, Xue Li, Duncan CreeEnergies 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study evaluates the economic viability of four different pathways for producing bioenergy from wood sawdust. The most profitable scenario involves producing torrefied pellets alongside valuable co-products like furfural and acetic acid, while a simpler approach of producing raw wood pellets offers the quickest return on investment.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wood processing generates significant amounts of sawdust, a low-value byproduct. This paper addresses the challenge of transforming this waste stream into valuable bioenergy and other products, aiming to improve the economic feasibility of bioenergy production. Specifically, it investigates how different processing technologies and product portfolios impact profitability, considering factors like capital investment, operating costs, and market prices. The study seeks to identify the most economically attractive routes for utilizing wood sawdust for energy and chemical production.

Methods

The researchers employed a technoeconomic analysis (TEA) using SuperPro Designer V.10.0 software to simulate and evaluate four distinct bioenergy production scenarios. These scenarios ranged from direct heat and electricity generation from raw sawdust to integrated biorefinery approaches producing pellets, chemicals, and energy. The TEA involved:

  • Process Simulation: Creating detailed flowsheets for each scenario to model mass and energy balances.
  • Cost Analysis: Estimating total capital investment (TCI) and operational expenditure (OPEX), including equipment costs, labor, utilities, and waste treatment.
  • Economic Index Calculation: Determining key financial indicators such as Net Present Value (NPV), Internal Rate of Return (IRR), Return on Investment (ROI), and Payback Time (PBT) to assess profitability.
  • Scenario Comparison: Evaluating the performance of each scenario based on these economic indices to identify the most favorable options.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulated data generated by the SuperPro Designer software, incorporating technical parameters and market prices.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Integrated Biorefineries Offer High Profit Potential: Combining the production of torrefied pellets with valuable co-products (furfural, acetic acid) leads to the highest Net Present Value (NPV), indicating significant long-term profitability. This highlights the importance of valorizing all biomass components.
  • Simplicity Can Mean Quick Returns: While integrated biorefineries offer the highest overall profit, a simpler process of producing raw wood pellets without combined heat and power (CHP) generation provides the fastest payback time and a strong Return on Investment (ROI). This suggests that simpler, less capital-intensive projects can be attractive for investors seeking quicker returns.
  • Pretreatment Matters, But Adds Cost: Steam explosion and torrefaction are explored as pretreatment methods to upgrade sawdust for pellet production. While these methods can improve pellet quality and enable co-product extraction, they also increase capital and operating costs.
  • CHP Integration is Crucial for Energy Production: For scenarios focused on heat and electricity generation, integrating a Combined Heat and Power (CHP) plant is essential for economic viability. Direct CHP from raw sawdust, however, proved to be the least profitable scenario.
  • Optimal Plant Size Varies: The optimal plant capacity differs depending on the scenario. For CHP plants, a larger capacity (250-300 kt) is optimal for minimizing costs, while for pellet production (treated or untreated), a capacity of 150-200 kt is more suitable.

Key Results

  • Most Profitable Scenario (NPV): Scenario 4 (torrefied pellets + co-products + CHP) achieved the highest NPV of USD 38.29 M at a 7% discount rate.
  • Fastest Payback & High ROI: Scenario 2 (raw wood pellet production without CHP) offered the shortest payback time (2.49 years) and a high ROI of 40.1%, along with a strong IRR of 49.61%.
  • Least Profitable Scenario: Scenario 1 (direct CHP from raw sawdust) consistently showed a negative NPV across all interest rates, making it economically unviable without subsidies.
  • Optimal Plant Sizes:
    • CHP plant (Scenario 1): 250-300 kt (low-pressure steam).
  • Pellet plants with CHP (Scenarios 3 & 4): 150-200 kt.
  • Pellet plant without CHP (Scenario 2): 150-200 kt.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Feedstock Price Exclusion: The study excluded feedstock price, assuming sawdust is freely available. In reality, transportation and handling costs can significantly impact economics.
  • Market Price Fluctuations: The analysis relies on assumed market prices for products. Real-world market volatility could affect profitability.
  • Environmental Assessment: While the study focuses on technoeconomic feasibility, a comprehensive environmental assessment (e.g., life cycle assessment) is needed for a complete picture, especially for the most profitable scenario.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further environmental analysis is crucial for the most promising scenarios. Additionally, exploring the impact of government subsidies and optimizing the valorization of waste streams could enhance the feasibility of these bioenergy processes.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this study, the technoeconomic feasibility of bioenergy production from sawdust under four different case scenarios is simulated and compared. These scenarios include: (1) heat and electricity generation from raw sawdust; (2) pellet production from sawdust; (3) and (4) integrated biorefinery approach for the simultaneous manufacturing of multiple products (steam-exploded and torrefied pellets) and co-products (furfural, hydroxy methyl furfural (HMF), acetic acid), along with heat and electricity generation. Economic assessments such as cost analysis, payback time (PBT), net present value (NPV) and internal rate of return (IRR) were determined for these scenarios. The results showed that the approach of producing torrefied pellets, furfural, and acetic acid, along with co-generated heat and electricity, in terms of multiproducts and profitability (NPV (at 7%): USD 38.29 M) was preferable over other alternatives. In terms of simplified technology and other economic indices (PBT: 2.49 year, IRR: 51.33%, and return on investment (ROI): 40.1%), the scenario for producing pellets from wood sawdust was more promising than others. If plant capacity was not a limiting factor, the optimal size for the combined heat and power (CHP) plant was between 250–300 kt for the main product. Additionally, untreated and treated pellet plants equipped with CHP had an optimal size of 150–200 kt of wood pellets per year.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{alizadeh2023technoeconomic,
  author = {Peyman Alizadeh and Lope G. Tabil and Edmund Mupondwa and Xue Li and Duncan Cree},
  title = {{Technoeconomic Feasibility of Bioenergy Production from Wood Sawdust}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/en16041914},
}
Figure