Techno Economic Modeling for Agrivoltaics: Can Agrivoltaics be more profitable than Ground mounted PV?

Habeel Alam, Muhammad Ashraful Alam, Nauman Zafar ButtarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

As the global transition to renewable energy accelerates, the demand for land to host large-scale solar installations is increasing. This often leads to a direct conflict with agriculture, as both industries compete for high-quality arable land. Agrivoltaics (AV)—the simultaneous use of land for solar energy production and farming—presents a potential solution. By elevating solar panels to allow crops to grow underneath, AV aims for a "win-win" scenario. However, the economic viability of these systems is often questioned due to the higher costs associated with specialized mounting structures and potential reductions in crop yields from shading.

Methodology: The Feasibility Criterion

To address these economic complexities, researchers have developed a systematic techno-economic framework. The core of this model is a feasibility criterion defined as $κ \leq ρ$.

  • $κ$ (Land Preservation Cost): This represents the ratio of module-related costs for an AV system compared to a standard ground-mounted PV (GMPV) system. Typically, AV costs are 1.2 to 1.4 times higher due to taller structures.
  • ρ (Overall Food-Energy Profit): This metric aggregates normalized crop profit, land costs, and energy yield into a single profitability indicator.

The model utilizes a view factor simulation to analyze light distribution for two primary configurations: conventional North/South (N/S) fixed-tilt bifacial modules and vertical East/West (E/W) bifacial modules. These are evaluated across varying array densities (pitch-to-height ratio, $p/h$) and module-to-land cost ratios ($M_L$).

Profitability metric ρ as a function of module-to-land cost ratio $M_L$ for various configurations.

Key Insights: The Role of $M_L$ and Configuration

A critical finding of the study is the decisive role of the Module-to-Land cost ratio ($M_L$). In regions where land is relatively inexpensive (resulting in a high $M_L$), the additional infrastructure costs of AV are easier to absorb. As shown in Figure 5, the profitability metric ρ tends to saturate when $M_L > 20$, suggesting that AV is particularly well-suited for rural areas with low land prices but high agricultural potential.

Furthermore, the Vertical E/W configuration has emerged as a strong contender. Although it may generate slightly less energy than N/S tilted panels, it benefits from lower land preservation costs ($κ \approx 1.2$) and provides more uniform light distribution for crops. This configuration also facilitates easier movement for agricultural machinery like tractors.

Schematic of N/S and E/W configurations and the impact of array density (p/h) on economic performance.

Results and Economic Trade-offs

The research highlights several key profitability thresholds:

  • Crop Value Matters: High-value crops (e.g., tomatoes, garlic) are essential for market-driven AV profitability. For these crops, AV can match or exceed GMPV profitability when $M_L > 20$ and array density is optimized (typically at a $p/h$ ratio of 5-6).
  • Density Optimization: Reducing module density to about one-third of a standard solar farm helps minimize shading-induced crop loss while maintaining significant energy revenue.
  • Policy Support for Staples: For low-value staple crops like wheat, AV is rarely profitable without intervention. However, a modest 15% increase in Feed-in-Tariffs (FIT) can bridge this economic gap, making AV a viable option for food security.

Limitations and Future Outlook

While the model provides a robust foundation, it currently treats shading primarily as a yield detractor. Future iterations will aim to incorporate "biological synergies," such as the panels' ability to reduce water evaporation or protect crops from extreme heat in arid regions. Additionally, the study acknowledges the need for complex ownership models to manage the relationship between solar investors and farmers. Future research will also explore the integration of dynamic tracking systems to further optimize the balance between food and energy production.

Summary updated

Abstract

Agrivoltaics (AV) is a dual land-use approach to collocate solar energy generation with agriculture for preserving the terrestrial ecosystem and enabling food-energy-water synergies. Here, we present a systematic approach to model the economic performance of AV relative to standalone ground-mounted PV (GMPV) and explore how the module design configuration can affect the dual food-energy economic performance. A remarkably simple criterion for economic feasibility is quantified that relates the land preservation cost to dual food-energy profit. We explore case studies including both high and low value crops under fixed tilt bifacial modules oriented either along the conventional North/South (N/S) facings or vertical East/West (E/W) facings. For each module configuration, the array density is varied to explore an economically feasible design space relative to GMPV for a range of module to land cost ratio (M_L) - a location-specific indicator relating the module technology (hardware and installation) costs to the soft (land acquisition, tax, overheads, etc.) costs. To offset a typically higher AV module cost needed to preserve the cropland, both E/W and N/S orientated modules favor high value crops, reduced (<60%) module density, and higher M_L (>25). In contrast, higher module density and an increased feed-in-tariff (FIT) relative to GMPV are desirable at lower M_L. The economic trends vary sharply for M_L< 10 but tend to saturate for M_L> 20. For low value crops, ~15% additional FIT can enable economic equivalence to GMPV at standard module density. The proposed modeling framework can provide a valuable tool for AV stakeholders to assess, predict, and optimize the techno-economic design for AV
BibTeX
@misc{alam2022techno,
  author = {Habeel Alam and Muhammad Ashraful Alam and Nauman Zafar Butt},
  title = {{Techno Economic Modeling for Agrivoltaics: Can Agrivoltaics be more profitable than Ground mounted PV?}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2206.05964},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2206.05964},
}
Figure