Developing potential adaptations to climate change for farming systems in Western Australia’s Northern Agricultural Region using the economic analysis tool STEP

Megan Abrahams, Chad Reynolds, Dennis van Gool, Kari-Lee Falconer, Caroline Peek, Ian Foster, Daniel Gardiner, Abrahams, Megan, Reynolds, Chad, Van Gool, Dennis, Falconer, Kari-Lee, Peek, Caroline, Foster, Ian, Gardiner, DanielAgEcon 2012 · DOI

Abstract

Climate change is projected to significantly impact agricultural production, yet its specific consequences for farm business viability remain less understood. This study utilizes the Simulated Transitional Economic Planning (STEP) model to conduct an economic analysis of broadacre farming systems in Western Australia’s Northern Agricultural Region (NAR) over a 50-year horizon. By integrating future climate scenarios into crop and pasture production models, the research assesses the financial risks to the whole farming system. The findings suggest that current farming practices may become financially unviable due to a combination of declining crop yields and worsening terms of trade. However, strategic adaptations—including carbon sequestration, genetically modified (GM) crops, and perennial pastures—offer pathways to maintain profitability even under severe climate projections.

The Challenge: Economic Survival in a Changing Climate

While much research focuses on the biological impacts of climate change on crop yields, there is a critical need to translate these impacts into long-term business profitability. Farmers in Western Australia (WA) face a "double whammy": shorter, drier growing seasons and a persistent decline in terms of trade (where input costs rise faster than commodity prices). This paper addresses whether current broadacre systems can survive the next half-century and identifies specific economic adaptations required for financial resilience in the NAR, an area already at the environmental margins of production.

Methodology

The researchers employed a multi-stage modeling framework to capture the complexity of the farm business:

  1. Representative Model Farms: Three farms were developed based on distinct rainfall zones: Low (<325 mm), Medium (325–450 mm), and High (450–750 mm).
  2. Climate and Yield Projections: Using the OzClim program, scenarios were generated from CSIRO and Hadley climate models. Yields were predicted using a modified French-Schultz equation and the APSIM-Wheat model, accounting for atmospheric $CO_2$ levels.
  3. The STEP Model: The core of the analysis is the Simulated Transitional Economic Planning (STEP) tool. This Excel-based framework tracks whole-farm cash flow over a 50-year transition, accounting for capital, fixed/variable costs, and shifting terms of trade.
  4. Sensitivity Analysis: The model tested resilience against fluctuations in grain prices, fertilizer costs, and livestock numbers.

Key Insights: Beyond Biology

The Terms of Trade Trap

A pivotal finding is that climate change is not the sole driver of potential insolvency. The historical trend of declining terms of trade makes current systems precarious even under stable climates; climate change acts as an accelerator, pushing farms toward financial unviability sooner than expected.

Flexibility and Diversification

In low-rainfall zones, the traditional crop-dominant model is increasingly risky. The study suggests that opportunistic cropping—planting only when seasonal breaks are favorable—combined with carbon-sequestering oil mallee trees and trade cattle, creates a more resilient and diversified income stream.

Soil-Specific Management

In high-rainfall zones, profitability is maximized through surgical land-use changes rather than blanket shifts. Moving crops to the most productive soils while converting poor, sandy soils to perennial pastures for livestock proved to be a highly effective strategy.

Regional Results and Adaptations

  • Low Rainfall Zone: Under severe (CSIRO Mk2) scenarios, traditional systems could fail within 20 years. An integrated system of trade cattle and carbon trading was the only path to sustained profitability.
  • Medium Rainfall Zone: Transitioning to GM technology and expanding crop areas could significantly boost average annual surpluses, potentially increasing them from $36,000 to $100,000.
  • High Rainfall Zone: Strategic soil management (perennials on poor soil, crops on good soil) resulted in a projected average annual surplus of $286,000, a stark contrast to the deficits predicted under traditional methods.
  • Livestock Resilience: Livestock emerged as more climate-resilient than crops due to their mobility and the relative stability of pasture growth compared to the high sensitivity of grain yields to heat stress.

Conclusion and Policy Implications

The STEP model demonstrates that while the threat to WA's northern wheatbelt is severe, innovation and adaptation can mitigate these impacts. The study highlights that "wait and see" strategies are costly, particularly in medium-rainfall zones where immediate technological adoption is far more profitable than delayed action.

However, these findings are sensitive to future carbon policies and grain price volatility. Further research is needed to explore intensive horticulture in high-rainfall zones near urban centers and to refine the establishment costs of perennial systems before broad policy decisions are finalized.

Summary updated

Abstract

Climate change is expected to have a significant effect on agricultural production but less is known about its projected impact on the farm business. This paper provides a first attempt at an economic analysis of the impacts of climate change for broadacre farming systems and provides an insight into agricultural production areas in Western Australia at risk over the next 50 years. These risks have been assessed using the Simulated Transitional Economic Planning (STEP) model to investigate the impact on the farm business. Modelled future climate scenarios were incorporated into crop and pasture production models to examine the economic impact on the whole farming system. Uncertainties associated with climate and production projections were captured through the development of scenarios and sensitivity analyses were performed to encompass a range of potential outcomes for the impact of climate change on the farming systems of the northern wheat-belt. Testing of this process showed that the current farming systems of the region may decline in profitability under climate change to a point where some become financially unviable in the long term. This decline in profitability is driven not only by the decline in crop yields from climate change but also from a continuation in the trend of declining terms of trade. With innovation and adaptation it may be possible to overcome these impacts on the region‘s farming systems even under severe (CSIRO Mk2) climate change projections. Potential profitable adaptations under climate change included a combination farming system of trade cattle, opportunistic cropping and carbon sequestration from oil mallee trees in the low rainfall area; investment in technology and genetically modified crops in the medium rainfall area; and in the high rainfall area a combination of increased crop area on the better soil types and the use of perennial pastures on the poor soil types. The findings are dependent on the accuracy and validity of future climate projections, crop yield estimates and the economic conditions used in the STEP model. Use of this process has improved understanding of the potential impacts of climate change and facilitated regional planning, decision making and the setting of research and investment priorities. However, additional fine-tuning of the analysis and further exploration of alternatives is necessary before policy decisions are made on the future of agriculture in Western Australia‘s northern wheatbelt.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{abrahams2012developing,
  author = {Megan Abrahams and Chad Reynolds and Dennis van Gool and Kari-Lee Falconer and Caroline Peek and Ian Foster and Daniel Gardiner and Abrahams, Megan and Reynolds, Chad and Van Gool, Dennis and Falconer, Kari-Lee and Peek, Caroline and Foster, Ian and Gardiner, Daniel},
  title = {{Developing potential adaptations to climate change for farming systems in Western Australia’s Northern Agricultural Region using the economic analysis tool STEP}},
  booktitle = {AgEcon},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.22004/ag.econ.131749},
}
Figure