Study on economics of biochar application in cotton – maize – cowpea cropping sequence under integrated nutrient management

R. Elangovan, S.r. Shri Rangasami, R. Murugaragavan, N. Chandra SekaranINTERNATIONAL 2022 · DOI

Abstract

This study evaluates the economic feasibility of biochar application within a cotton–maize–cowpea cropping sequence under integrated nutrient management. While continuous application (two doses) of biochar @ 10 t + 100% NPK + FYM yielded the highest absolute net return (Rs. 67,928 ha⁻¹), a one-time application of biochar @ 10 t + 75% NPK + FYM was found to be more economically viable. This single-application strategy produced a net return of Rs. 62,970 ha⁻¹ and a superior benefit-cost ratio (BCR) of 1.45. The research suggests that a one-time conjoint application of biochar with reduced chemical fertilizers is the optimal management technology for enhancing profitability in Inceptisol soils.

Introduction: The Economic Challenge of Biochar

Sustainable agriculture increasingly relies on soil amendments like biochar—a carbon-rich product of biomass pyrolysis—to improve nutrient retention and crop yields. However, the high cost of biochar production and application often acts as a barrier to widespread adoption. While its physical and chemical benefits are well-documented, its economic impact over a multi-crop sequence is less understood. Farmers need to determine if the long-term residual benefits of biochar justify the initial investment and whether continuous application is necessary to maintain profitability.

Methodology

Field trials were conducted in the Coimbatore District of India on Inceptisol soil (specifically the Periyanaickenpalayam series, classified as Vertic Ustropept). The study tracked a three-crop rotation: Cotton → Maize → Cowpea.

Researchers compared several variables:

  • Application Frequency: One-time application (to the initial cotton crop) versus continuous application (to both cotton and maize).
  • Nutrient Management: Combinations of biochar (10 t/ha), Farm Yard Manure (FYM at 12.5 t/ha), and varying levels of recommended NPK fertilizers (75% vs. 100%).
  • Economic Evaluation: Performance was measured using total cultivation costs, gross returns, net returns, and the Benefit-Cost Ratio (BCR).

Key Insights

The Efficiency of Integrated Nutrient Management

The study demonstrates that biochar acts as a force multiplier for fertilizers. The most efficient treatment combined biochar with only 75% of the recommended NPK dose. This indicates that biochar improves nutrient use efficiency, allowing for a 25% reduction in synthetic fertilizer use without a significant loss in economic performance.

One-Time vs. Continuous Application

While applying biochar twice resulted in the highest absolute net return, the incremental profit over a single application was only Rs. 5,565. Given the labor and material costs associated with a second application, the marginal gain was insufficient to recommend it as a standard practice. A single application provides substantial residual benefits to subsequent crops in the sequence.

Results and Economic Viability

The economic analysis revealed clear winners:

  • Optimal Strategy: One-time application of Biochar @ 10 t/ha + 75% NPK + 12.5 t/ha FYM.
  • Benefit-Cost Ratio (BCR): 1.45 (the highest in the study).
  • Net Returns: Rs. 62,970/ha for the optimal single-application strategy, compared to Rs. 67,928/ha for the most intensive continuous strategy.

Limitations and Future Outlook

While these results are promising, they are specific to the Inceptisols of the Coimbatore region. Economic viability may shift in different soil types or climatic zones. Additionally, the study focuses on immediate crop returns; future research incorporating the economic value of carbon sequestration credits could further enhance the financial argument for biochar adoption.

Conclusion

For farmers utilizing a cotton–maize–cowpea rotation in Inceptisol soils, a single application of biochar at the start of the sequence is the most economically sound approach. By integrating biochar with organic manure and reduced chemical fertilizers, growers can achieve a high benefit-cost ratio while maintaining soil health and productivity across multiple seasons.

Summary updated

Abstract

The highest net return was found in continuous application (two times) especially in the treatment biochar @ 10 t + 100 % NPK + FYM with Rs.67,928 ha-1 followed by biochar @ 10 t + 75 % NPK + FYM treatment with Rs.67,172 ha-1. The next higher net return was registered in biochar @ 10 t + 75 % NPK + FYM treatment under one time application with Rs. 62,970/-.Comparing the studies, the two times application (biochar @ 10 t ha-1 time-1) recorded an addition of Rs. 5,565/- only over one time application. Therefore one time application (biochar @ 10 t ha-1) considered to be an economically viable management technology than two times application in the cotton – maize – cowpea cropping sequence. One time conjoint application of biochar @ 10 t ha-1 along with 75 % recommended dose of NPK fertilizers and 12.5 t ha-1 of FYM i.e., (biochar @ 10 t + 75 % NPK + FYM) to cotton and following the general recommended practices for maize and cowpea to be the best combination suited for enhancing higher benefit cost ratio of 1.45 under cotton – maize – cowpea cropping system in Inceptisol (Vertic Ustropept) of Periyanaickenpalayam series of Coimbatore District.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{elangovan2022study,
  author = {R. Elangovan and S.R. Shri Rangasami and R. Murugaragavan and N. Chandra Sekaran},
  title = {{Study on economics of biochar application in cotton – maize – cowpea cropping sequence under integrated nutrient management}},
  booktitle = {INTERNATIONAL},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.15740/has/ijps/17/ocaebgd/1-11},
}
Figure