Technique, Feasibility, Utility, Limitations, and Future Perspectives of a New Technique of Applying Direct In-Scope Suction to Improve Outcomes of Retrograde Intrarenal Surgery for Stones

Vineet Gauhar, Bhaskar Somani, Chin Tiong Heng, Vishesh Gauhar, Ben H. Chew, Kemal Sarıca, Jeremy Yuen‐Chun Teoh, Daniele Castellani, Mohammed Saleem, Olivier TraxerJournal of Clinical Medicine 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel, low-cost "Direct In-Scope Suction" (DISS) technique for Retrograde Intrarenal Surgery (RIRS) to improve stone fragment removal. By integrating suction directly into the ureteroscope, DISS aims to overcome the "snow-globe effect" and enhance stone-free rates, particularly for larger or multiple stones, showing promising feasibility and reduced hospital stays.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Retrograde Intrarenal Surgery (RIRS) is a standard treatment for kidney stones up to 2 cm. However, for larger stones (over 2 cm), RIRS faces limitations. The primary challenge is the "snow-globe effect," where fragmented stone particles obscure the surgeon's view, making it difficult to visualize and remove all fragments. This can lead to persistent residual fragments, requiring further interventions and potentially impacting patient outcomes. Existing solutions like suction ureteral access sheaths (SUAS) help but have their own limitations, such as requiring fragments to be moved to the sheath for removal. This paper addresses the need for a simpler, more integrated method to actively clear stone fragments during RIRS, especially for complex cases.

Methods

The core innovation is the Direct In-Scope Suction (DISS) technique. This involves a simple, cost-effective modification: attaching two 3-way stoppers to the ureteroscope's working channel. One inlet is connected to suction tubing, and the other to irrigation. This setup allows for simultaneous or alternating suction and aspiration of stone fragments and dust directly through the scope during or after laser lithotripsy.

The study was a retrospective audit comparing 30 patients who underwent RIRS with the DISS technique against 28 patients who had RIRS with a standard 11Fr/13Fr suction ureteral access sheath (SUAS). Laser lithotripsy was performed using a thulium fiber laser for the DISS group and a Holmium:YAG laser for the SUAS group. The primary outcome was the difference in stone-free rate (SFR), with secondary outcomes including surgical time, hospital stay, and complications.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study involved a prospective collection of data from two centers, which was then analyzed retrospectively.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Integrated Suction for Enhanced Visualization: The DISS technique directly tackles the "snow-globe effect" by actively removing fragments and dust, thereby improving the surgeon's view and enabling more thorough stone clearance.
  • Simplicity and Cost-Effectiveness: The modification is described as simple and cost-effective, utilizing readily available components (3-way stoppers), making it potentially accessible to a wider range of surgical settings.
  • Versatility for Complex Cases: The DISS technique proved effective even for patients with larger stone sizes and multiple stones, areas where traditional RIRS can be more challenging.
  • Potential to Reduce Retreatment: While the immediate residual fragment rate was similar to SUAS, the DISS group showed a trend towards requiring fewer repeat RIRS procedures compared to the SUAS group needing subsequent treatments.

Key Results

  • Stone Size and Location: The DISS group had significantly larger median stone sizes (22.0 mm vs. 13.0 mm) and a higher incidence of stones in the middle renal pole.
  • Surgical Time: The DISS procedure took longer, with a median surgical time of 80.0 minutes compared to 47.5 minutes for SUAS. This is attributed to the time needed for meticulous inspection and aspiration of each calyx.
  • Hospital Stay: Patients undergoing DISS had a significantly shorter hospital stay (1.00 day vs. 1.00-2.00 days).
  • Residual Fragments: The incidence of residual fragments was similar between the groups (33.3% for DISS vs. 35.7% for SUAS). However, 33.3% of DISS patients required further RIRS for residual fragments, compared to only 3.6% of SUAS patients needing subsequent shock wave lithotripsy.
  • Complications: Postoperative complications were minor and not significantly different between the groups. No intraoperative complications were reported for either technique.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study was an audit, not a randomized controlled trial, and was conducted at only two centers.
  • One center lacked access to SUAS, limiting the ability to conduct a fully randomized study.
  • The learning curve for the DISS technique was noted, with approximately five cases needed to become proficient, potentially explaining the higher retreatment rate in the DISS group.
  • The study relied on X-ray or CT scans for follow-up, and the timing and modality of imaging for residual fragments could be a factor.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors plan a randomized trial comparing DISS with traditional RIRS and other commercially available SUAS.
  • Further research into optimizing the design module for DISS, focusing on ergonomics and user-friendliness, is suggested.
  • Investigating the ideal vacuum pressure and the best suction device for RIRS is recommended.
  • Exploring whether DISS can eliminate the need for postoperative ureteral stents, unnecessary imaging, and repeat procedures is a key future direction.
  • The authors believe DISS could potentially minimize the need for ureteral access sheaths, especially for smaller scopes, and increase first-pass RIRS success rates.
  • External multicenter validation is crucial to confirm the feasibility, utility, and limitations of the DISS technique.

Summary updated

Abstract

Retrograde intrarenal surgery (RIRS) is accepted as a primary modality for the management of renal stones up to 2 cm. The limitations of RIRS in larger volume stones include limited visualization due to the snow-globe effect and persistence of fragments that cannot be removed. We describe a new, simple, cost-effective modification that can be attached to any flexible ureteroscope which allows simultaneous/alternating suction and aspiration during/after laser lithotripsy using the scope as a conduit to remove the fragments or dust from the pelvicalyceal system called direct in-scope suction (DISS) technique. Between September 2020 and September 2021, 30 patients with kidney stones underwent RIRS with the DISS technique. They were compared with 28 patients who underwent RIRS with a 11Fr/13Fr suction ureteral access sheaths (SUASs) in the same period. RIRS and laser lithotripsy were carried out traditionally with a Holmium laser for the SUAS group or a thulium fiber laser for the DISS group. There was no difference in age, gender, and history of renal lithiasis between the two groups. Ten (40%) patients had multiple stones in the DISS groups, whilst there were no patients with multiple stones in the SUAS group. Median stone size was significantly higher in the DISS group [22.0 (18.0−28.8) vs. 13.0 (11.8−15.0) millimeters, p < 0.001]. Median surgical time was significantly longer in the DISS group [80.0 (60.0−100) minutes] as compared to the SUAS group [47.5 (41.5−60.3) minutes, p < 0.001]. Hospital stay was significantly shorter in the DISS group [1.00 (0.667−1.00) vs. 1.00 (1.00−2.00) days, p = 0.02]. Postoperative complications were minor, and there was no significant difference between the two groups. The incidence of residual fragments did not significantly differ between the two groups [10 (33.3%) in the DISS group vs. 10 (35.7%) in the SUAS group, p = 0.99] but 10 (33.3%) patients required a further RIRS for residual fragments in the DISS group, whilst only one (3.6%) patient in the SUAS group required a subsequent shock wave lithotripsy treatment. Our audit study highlighted that RIRS with DISS technique was feasible with an acceptable rate of retreatment as compared to RIRS with SUAS.
BibTeX
@article{gauhar2022technique,
  author = {Vineet Gauhar and Bhaskar Somani and Chin Tiong Heng and Vishesh Gauhar and Ben H. Chew and Kemal Sarıca and Jeremy Yuen‐Chun Teoh and Daniele Castellani and Mohammed Saleem and Olivier Traxer},
  title = {{Technique, Feasibility, Utility, Limitations, and Future Perspectives of a New Technique of Applying Direct In-Scope Suction to Improve Outcomes of Retrograde Intrarenal Surgery for Stones}},
  journal = {Journal of Clinical Medicine},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/jcm11195710},
}
Figure