Task-irrelevant stimuli reliably boost phasic pupil-linked arousal but do not affect decision formation

J. Hebisch, A.-c. Ghassemieh, E. Zhecheva, M. Brouwer, Simon van Gaal, Lars Schwabe, Tobias H. Donner, Jan Willem de Gee

TL;DR

This study investigates whether task-irrelevant auditory stimuli can reliably manipulate brainstem arousal systems, as measured by pupil dilation, to influence cognitive decision-making. While the sounds successfully evoked pupil responses that mimicked task-driven arousal, they did not alter decision bias or other behavioral metrics, suggesting that task engagement and external stimuli might recruit distinct neural pathways for arousal control.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the role of transient, or "phasic," arousal in cognitive processes like decision-making is crucial. The brainstem's locus coeruleus-noradrenaline system is known to be phasically active during challenging decisions, and this activity is reflected in pupil dilation. However, directly manipulating this arousal system in humans to study its causal impact on cognition is challenging. Researchers are looking for non-invasive methods to induce these phasic arousal responses. This paper explores whether presenting task-irrelevant auditory stimuli can serve as such a manipulation, specifically by examining if these sounds can mimic the arousal transients naturally occurring during cognitive tasks and, consequently, influence decision outcomes, particularly choice bias, which has been shown to be modulated by endogenous arousal.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of behavioral tasks and pupillometry across three experiments.

  • Behavioral Tasks: Participants performed challenging visual perceptual decision-making tasks.
  • Experiments 1 & 2: A contrast detection task where participants identified the presence or absence of a faint Gabor grating against visual noise.
  • Experiment 3: A category-level orientation averaging task involving judging the average orientation of a sequence of Gabor gratings.
  • Task-Irrelevant Stimuli: Auditory white noise stimuli were presented at varying latencies and durations. The timing and frequency of these sounds were manipulated to test their impact.
  • Pupillometry: Pupil size was continuously recorded to measure arousal responses.
  • Task-Evoked Pupil Responses: These were quantified by analyzing pupil dilation time-locked to the button press (choice) in trials without task-irrelevant sounds. Trial-to-trial variability in these responses was analyzed.
  • Task-Irrelevant Sound-Evoked Pupil Responses: These were isolated by subtracting the pupil response on "no sound" trials from the response on "sound" trials, effectively isolating the sound's specific contribution.
  • Statistical Analysis:
    • Correlations were used to examine the relationship between task-evoked pupil responses and choice bias.
  • Repeated measures ANOVAs and Bayesian t-tests were employed to compare behavioral and pupil responses between conditions with and without task-irrelevant sounds.
  • Psychophysical kernels were used in Experiment 3 to analyze how evidence samples were weighted in decision-making.

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed as "datasets" in the traditional machine learning sense. The study utilized data collected from human participants performing the described behavioral tasks. No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing tasks were adapted to incorporate the auditory stimuli.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Pupil Dilation as a Reliable Arousal Marker: The study strongly reinforces the idea that pupil dilation is a sensitive and reliable indicator of phasic arousal, both when triggered by cognitive engagement and by external, task-irrelevant auditory stimuli.
  • Dissociation of Arousal Induction and Behavioral Impact: The most striking finding is the dissociation between the reliable induction of pupil-linked arousal by auditory stimuli and the lack of any consistent behavioral effect on decision-making. This suggests that simply increasing arousal via external cues might not be sufficient to modulate complex cognitive outcomes like choice bias.
  • Distinct Neural Pathways for Arousal Control? The lack of behavioral impact, despite clear physiological responses, hints that the neural systems responsible for generating arousal during cognitive tasks might be distinct from those recruited by external auditory stimuli, even if both influence pupil size. This opens up questions about the specificity of neuromodulatory systems.
  • Task-Evoked Arousal's Causal Link: The study successfully replicates the well-established negative correlation between endogenous, task-evoked pupil responses and choice bias, reinforcing the idea that this internally generated arousal does causally influence decision-making.

Key Results

  • Reliable Sound-Evoked Pupil Responses: Task-irrelevant auditory stimuli consistently elicited robust and precisely timed pupil dilations that superimposed onto task-evoked pupil responses. These sound-evoked responses were separable from task-evoked ones using linear subtraction.
  • Replication of Arousal-Bias Correlation: The study replicated the finding that higher task-evoked pupil responses were associated with reduced choice bias (Experiment 1: r = -0.211, p = 0.001; Experiment 2: r = -0.297, p < 0.001).
  • No Behavioral Effect of Task-Irrelevant Sounds: Despite reliably evoking pupil responses, the task-irrelevant sounds did not significantly alter choice bias in any of the experiments. Bayesian analyses supported a null effect for these behavioral changes.
  • Limited Impact on Other Metrics: Task-irrelevant sounds generally did not affect sensitivity (d') or reaction time, with one exception in Experiment 1 where a specific sound condition led to faster responses and reduced sensitivity, suggesting a speed-accuracy trade-off shift.
  • No Effect on Evidence Weighting: In a more complex task (Experiment 3), task-irrelevant sounds did not alter how participants weighted evidence samples in their decisions.
  • Baseline Pupil Size Interaction: While sound-evoked pupil responses were modulated by baseline pupil size, this interaction did not translate into behavioral effects on choice bias.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Dissimilarity of Arousal Mechanisms: The authors acknowledge that the central arousal events triggered by task engagement and by task-irrelevant sounds might not be identical. This dissimilarity could explain the lack of behavioral effects. Future work should investigate the specific neural substrates and sub-populations of neurons involved in each type of arousal response.
  • Locus Coeruleus Specificity: While task-evoked arousal is strongly linked to the locus coeruleus, the precise contribution of the locus coeruleus to sound-evoked arousal, and whether it recruits the same neurons or pathways, remains an open question.
  • Unexpectedness of Stimuli: The authors suggest that the level of "unexpectedness" of a task-irrelevant sound might be crucial for its behavioral impact, a factor not fully explored here. Future studies could manipulate surprise more directly.
  • Linear Superposition Assumption: The analysis relies on a linear superposition of arousal responses. Future research could explore potential non-linear interactions between task-evoked and sound-evoked arousal.
  • Translational Potential: While task-irrelevant sounds did not prove to be a simple tool for manipulating decision-making, the study's findings are valuable for understanding the complex interplay between arousal systems and cognition, with potential implications for conditions involving arousal dysregulation. Further neuroimaging or direct recording studies are suggested to disentangle the sources of these arousal responses.

Summary updated

Abstract

The arousal systems of the brainstem, specifically the locus coeruleus-noradrenaline system, respond "phasically" during decisions. These central arousal transients are accompanied by dilations of the pupil. Mechanistic attempts to understand the impact of phasic arousal on cognition would benefit from temporally precise experimental manipulations. Here, we evaluated a non-invasive candidate approach to manipulate arousal in humans: presenting task-irrelevant auditory stimuli at different latencies during the execution of a challenging task. Task-irrelevant auditory stimuli drive responses of brainstem nuclei involved in the control of pupil size, but it is unknown whether such sound-evoked responses mimic the central arousal transients evoked during cognitive computations. A large body of evidence has implicated central arousal transients in reducing bias during challenging perceptual decisions. We thus used challenging visual decisions as a testbed, combining them with task-irrelevant sounds of varying onset latency or duration. Across three experiments, the sounds consistently elicited well-controlled pupil responses that superimposed onto task-evoked responses. While we replicated a negative correlation between task-evoked pupil responses and bias, the task-irrelevant sounds had no behavioral effect. This dissociation suggests that cognitive task engagement and task-irrelevant sounds may recruit distinct neural systems contributing to the control of pupil size.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hebisch2024task,
  author = {J. Hebisch and A.-C. Ghassemieh and E. Zhecheva and M. Brouwer and Simon van Gaal and Lars Schwabe and Tobias H. Donner and Jan Willem de Gee},
  title = {{Task-irrelevant stimuli reliably boost phasic pupil-linked arousal but do not affect decision formation}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-024-78791-8},
}
Figure