Targeted endomyocardial biopsy guided by real-time cardiovascular magnetic resonance

Christina Unterberg‐Buchwald, Christian Ritter, Verena Reupke, Robin N. Wilke, Christine Stadelmann, Michael Steinmetz, Andreas Schuster, Gerd Hasenfuß, Joachim Lotz, Martin UeckerJournal of Cardiovascular Magnetic Resonance 2016 · DOI

Abstract

Focal lesions induced by radiofrequency ablation in a minipig model are a useful tool for cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR)-guided biopsy studies. In contrast to traditional fluoroscopy, CMR provides excellent visualization of myocardial lesions. Interactive real-time CMR allows for effective passive tracking of instruments, and endomyocardial biopsy (EMB) guided by this method provides significantly superior sampling accuracy compared to fluoroscopy-guided biopsies. Nonetheless, further improvements of MR-compatible bioptomes and guiding catheters are essential before applying this method in a clinical setting.

Introduction: The Challenge of "Blind" Biopsy

Endomyocardial biopsy (EMB) is a critical diagnostic tool for myocarditis and infiltrative heart diseases. However, the current clinical standard—guidance via fluoroscopy (X-ray)—suffers from a major flaw: X-rays visualize the bioptome and the heart's silhouette, but they cannot see the actual diseased tissue. Because the procedure is essentially "blind" regarding the target pathology, clinicians typically take six or more samples to minimize sampling error. This increases procedural time, radiation exposure for both patient and staff, and the risk of complications like cardiac perforation. This study explores whether the high-resolution, radiation-free, soft-tissue imaging of CMR can turn EMB into a truly targeted procedure.

Methods and Materials

The researchers used a preclinical model consisting of seven Goettingen minipigs. Focal myocardial lesions were induced using radiofrequency (RF) ablation in the left ventricle to mimic localized disease.

Real-Time CMR Guidance

The animals were moved to a 3T clinical MR scanner where late gadolinium enhancement (LGE) was used to locate the ablation lesions. To navigate the bioptome in a beating heart, the team used a radial FLASH sequence combined with nonlinear inverse reconstruction (NLINV). This allowed for a temporal resolution of 42 ms, providing a low-latency video feed to an in-room monitor.

Hardware Requirements

The study utilized MR-conditional bioptomes made of titanium and plastic to prevent heating and artifacts, along with steerable catheters with passive markers for tracking.

MR-conditional bioptomes used in the study, showing the specialized construction required for the MR environment.

Key Results: Precision Through Visualization

The most significant advancement of this approach is the transition from silhouette-based navigation to pathology-based navigation. CMR allowed the operator to see the lesion core and the bioptome simultaneously in real-time.

  • Visualization: CMR successfully visualized 100% of the induced lesions (7/7 pigs).
  • Sampling Accuracy: At the individual sample level, CMR-guided biopsies hit the target 40% (6/15) of the time, nearly doubling the 23.5% (4/17) hit rate of fluoroscopy.
  • Animal-Level Success: Targeted CMR guidance achieved a successful lesion biopsy in 80% (4/5) of the animals where it was attempted, compared to only 50% (3/6) for conventional fluoroscopy.
Real-time CMR image demonstrating the bioptome tip (white arrow) accurately positioned at the site of a myocardial lesion.

Discussion and Future Directions

While CMR guidance is superior for navigation, current MR-conditional bioptomes are mechanically inferior to their steel counterparts, possessing less cutting force and a smaller opening angle (50–70° vs. 90°). Additionally, the MR-conditional guiding catheters were noted to be more rigid and less flexible than standard ones, making navigation through the aortic arch more challenging.

Future iterations should focus on:

  1. Instrument Refinement: Developing thinner, more flexible MR-safe catheters and bioptomes with improved mechanical "bite."
  2. Workflow Automation: Integrating automated slice-following to keep the bioptome tip in the imaging plane automatically.
  3. Clinical Adoption: Streamlining the specialized environment (i-CMR suite) and coordination between cardiologists and MR technicians.

By enabling direct visualization of diseased tissue, real-time CMR-guided biopsy represents a significant step toward safer and more accurate cardiac diagnostics.

Summary updated

Abstract

Focal lesions induced by radiofrequency ablation in a minipig model are a useful tool for CMR-guided biopsy studies. In contrast to fluoroscopy, CMR provides excellent visualization of lesions. Interactive real-time CMR allows excellent passive tracking of the instruments and EMB provides significantly superior sampling accuracy compared to fluoroscopy-guided biopsies. Nonetheless, further improvements of MR-compatible bioptomes and guiding catheters are essential before applying this method in a clinical setting.
BibTeX
@article{unterbergbuchwald2016targeted,
  author = {Christina Unterberg‐Buchwald and Christian Ritter and Verena Reupke and Robin N. Wilke and Christine Stadelmann and Michael Steinmetz and Andreas Schuster and Gerd Hasenfuß and Joachim Lotz and Martin Uecker},
  title = {{Targeted endomyocardial biopsy guided by real-time cardiovascular magnetic resonance}},
  journal = {Journal of Cardiovascular Magnetic Resonance},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1186/s12968-017-0357-3},
}
Figure