Taller staff occupationally exposed to less radiation to the temple in cardiac procedures, but risk higher doses during vascular cases

Kelly Wilson‐Stewart, Davide Fontanarosa, Dan Li, Christopher Drovandi, Rebecca Anderson, Jamie TrappScientific 2020 · DOI

Abstract

This study investigated the impact of clinician height on occupational radiation exposure to the temple during fluoroscopically guided cardiovascular procedures. While taller staff generally benefit from the inverse square law—being further from the X-ray scatter source—clinical variables like table height and shielding placement create complex outcomes. Analyzing 1,585 cardiac and 294 vascular procedures, researchers found that while taller staff receive less radiation during cardiac cases, taller nurses actually face higher doses during vascular studies. This suggests that ergonomic adjustments and shielding configurations can negate the physical advantage of height.

Introduction

Interventional cardiology and vascular surgery rely heavily on fluoroscopy, exposing medical staff to chronic, low-dose scatter radiation. Long-term risks include oncogenesis and subscapular cataracts. While the "primary operator" (doctor) is often the focus of radiation safety studies, the risks to scrub and scout nurses are less understood. This study explores whether staff height serves as a reliable predictor of head dose across different procedural environments.

Methods

A prospective, single-center observational study was conducted at Greenslopes Private Hospital, Australia, involving 25 doctors, 28 scrub nurses, and 29 scout nurses. Staff wore Philips DoseAware active personal dosimeters at the temple level to estimate cranial dose.

Figure 4: Schematic of the procedural environment showing top-down (a) and side-view (b) layouts, including the positioning of staff, shielding (CMLS, TMLS), and the X-ray source.

The researchers analyzed 1,585 cardiac procedures and 294 vascular procedures. Linear regression models were used to assess the relationship between staff height (ranging from 155 cm to 192 cm) and log-transformed temple dose, controlling for patient BMI, contrast volume, and procedure type.

Key Insights: The "Vascular Paradox"

The study revealed that the protective effect of height is context-dependent. In cardiac cases, the expected inverse relationship held: taller staff received less radiation. However, in vascular cases, this trend reversed for nurses.

The authors hypothesize that this "Vascular Paradox" is due to the ceiling-mounted lead shield (CMLS). Shorter nurses may be entirely shielded by the lead glass, whereas taller nurses' heads might extend above the protective "shadow" of the shield, especially if it is positioned lower to accommodate the doctor's comfort. Furthermore, taller doctors often raise the operating table for better ergonomics. While their height moves their head further from the scatter source, raising the table moves that source closer. These competing factors determine the final dose, though height remains a net benefit for doctors in most cardiac scenarios.

Results

The analysis confirmed a statistically significant inverse relationship between height and temple dose for all staff during cardiac procedures. Conversely, during vascular procedures, scrub and scout nurses showed a positive correlation between height and dose—taller nurses received more radiation.

Figure 6: Regression plots showing the relationship between staff height and log temple dose for scrub nurses (b) and doctors (d) across different procedural categories.

Mean doses also varied by specialty: cardiologists averaged 3.14 μSv per procedure, while vascular surgeons received 6.6 μSv, reflecting the higher-intensity imaging required for vascular interventions.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that physical stature significantly influences occupational radiation risk, but its effects are mediated by the clinical environment. While being taller is generally protective in cardiac suites, it can be a disadvantage for nursing staff in vascular settings due to shielding geometry. Future work should focus on optimizing adjustable-height shielding and protocols to ensure all staff, regardless of height, are adequately protected from scatter radiation.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study aimed to evaluate the effect of nurse and doctor height on occupational dose to the temple during fluoroscopically guided cardiovascular procedures. Additionally, an evaluation of the relationship between doctor height and table height was performed. Staff exposed during fluoroscopic procedures may be at elevated risk of cardiovascular damage or oncogenesis and have demonstrated a higher incidence of subscapular cataracts. The heads of taller staff may be exposed to reduced levels of radiation due to the increased distance from the area of highest intensity X-ray scatter. Limited research has been performed investigating height as a predictor of head dose to nursing staff. The level of radiation dose at the level of the temple to the doctor (n = 25), scrub (n = 28), and scout nurse (n = 29) was measured in a prospective single-center, observational study using Philips DoseAware badges. Procedural characteristics were recorded for vascular and cardiac cases performed in three dedicated angiography suites. Data were also collected to investigate relationships between doctor height and table height. Data were collected for 1585 cardiac and 294 vascular procedures. Staff height was a statistically significant predictor of temple dose for doctors, scrub, and scout nurses when considering the full data sample. The log temple dose demonstrated an inverse relationship to staff height during cardiac procedures, but a positive relationship for scrub and scout nurses during vascular studies. This observational study has demonstrated that taller staff are exposed to less cranial exposure dose during fluoroscopically guided cardiac examinations but has revealed a positive correlation between height and temple dose during vascular procedures. It was also determined that doctor height was correlated with average procedural table height and that vascular access point influences the choice of table elevation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wilsonstewart2020taller,
  author = {Kelly Wilson‐Stewart and Davide Fontanarosa and Dan Li and Christopher Drovandi and Rebecca Anderson and Jamie Trapp},
  title = {{Taller staff occupationally exposed to less radiation to the temple in cardiac procedures, but risk higher doses during vascular cases}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-020-73101-4},
}
Figure