Differential occupational risks to healthcare workers from SARS-CoV-2: A prospective observational study

David W. Eyre, Sheila Lumley, Denise O’Donnell, Mark Campbell, Elizabeth Sims, Elaine Lawson, Fiona C Warren, Tim James, Stuart Cox, Alison Howarth, George Doherty, Stephanie B. Hatch, James Kavanagh, Kevin Chau, Philip W. Fowler, Jeremy Swann, Denis Volk, Fan Yang-Turner, Nicole Stoesser, Philippa C. Matthews, Maria Dudareva, T. J. Davies, R. H. Shaw, Leon Peto, Louise Downs, Alexander Vogt, Ali Amini, Bernadette Young, Philip G. Drennan, Alexander J. Mentzer, Donal Skelly, Fredrik Karpe, Matt J. Neville, Monique Andersson, Andrew Brent, Nicola Jones, Lucas Martins Ferreira, Thomas Christott, Brian D. Marsden, Sarah Hoosdally, Richard J. Cornall, Derrick W. Crook, David I. Stuart, Gavin Screaton, Tim Peto, Bruno Holthof, Colm P. O’Donnell, Daniel Ebner, Christopher P. Conlon, Katie Jeffery, A Sarah WalkermedRxiv 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Background: Personal protective equipment (PPE) and social distancing are designed to mitigate risk of occupational SARS-CoV-2 infection in hospitals. Why healthcare workers nevertheless remain at increased risk is uncertain.

Methods: We conducted voluntary Covid-19 testing programmes for symptomatic and asymptomatic staff at a UK teaching hospital using nasopharyngeal PCR testing and immunoassays for IgG antibodies. A positive result by either modality determined a composite outcome. Risk-factors for Covid-19 were investigated using multivariable logistic regression.

Results: 1083/9809 (11.0%) staff had evidence of Covid-19 at some time and provided data on potential risk-factors. Staff with a confirmed household contact were at greatest risk (adjusted odds ratio [aOR] 4.63 [95%CI 3.30-6.50]). Higher rates of Covid-19 were seen in staff working in Covid-19-facing areas (21.2% vs. 8.2% elsewhere) (aOR 2.49 [2.00-3.12]). Controlling for Covid-19-facing status, risks were heterogenous across the hospital, with higher rates in acute medicine (1.50 [1.05-2.15]) and sporadic outbreaks in areas with few or no Covid-19 patients. Covid-19 intensive care unit (ICU) staff were relatively protected (0.46 [0.29-0.72]). Positive results were more likely in Black (1.61 [1.20-2.16]) and Asian (1.58 [1.34-1.86]) staff, independent of role or working location, and in porters and cleaners (1.93 [1.25-2.97]). Contact tracing around asymptomatic staff did not lead to enhanced case identification. 24% of staff/patients remained PCR-positive at ≥6 weeks post-diagnosis.

Conclusions: Increased Covid-19 risk was seen in acute medicine, among Black and Asian staff, and porters and cleaners. A bundle of PPE-related interventions protected staff in ICU.

Introduction

Early in the COVID-19 pandemic, it was established that healthcare workers (HCWs) were at significantly higher risk of infection than the general population. However, the specific drivers of this risk—whether from direct patient contact, peer-to-peer interactions, or household transmission—remained unclear. Furthermore, the effectiveness of different PPE protocols across various hospital departments was not fully understood. This study aimed to untangle these variables by analyzing a large cohort of staff at a major UK teaching hospital (Oxford University Hospitals) during the first wave of the pandemic (March–June 2020).

Methods

The researchers implemented a voluntary testing program for 13,800 staff members. Infection was defined using a dual-modality "composite outcome" combining PCR testing (nasopharyngeal swabs for active viral RNA) and serology (immunoassays for IgG antibodies indicating past infection).

Data from 9,809 staff members were linked with patient admission data via the Infections in Oxfordshire Research Database (IORD). This allowed the calculation of "infectious pressure" on specific wards based on 636 COVID-19 patient admissions. Multivariable logistic regression was applied to adjust for confounding factors such as age, gender, ethnicity, job role, and specific hospital location, isolating the independent impact of each variable.

Results

The study found that 11.0% of the staff cohort had evidence of COVID-19. The strongest predictor of infection was living with a confirmed COVID-19 case (aOR 4.63). Working in COVID-facing areas carried an aOR of 2.49 compared to non-facing areas.

The ICU Protection Paradox

A key finding was that staff in COVID-19 Intensive Care Units (ICUs) were significantly less likely to be infected than staff in non-COVID areas (aOR 0.46). This "protection paradox" is attributed to a "bundle" of interventions: Level-2 PPE (including FFP3 masks), dedicated donning/doffing spaces, and rigorous supervision. In contrast, staff in acute medicine wards faced higher risks (aOR 1.50), where PPE standards were lower (surgical masks) and patients were often admitted before their COVID status was confirmed.

Occupational and Demographic Risks

Occupational roles influenced risk significantly, with porters and cleaners showing the highest risk among staff groups (aOR 1.93). Notably, ethnicity remained a significant independent risk factor; Black (aOR 1.61) and Asian (aOR 1.58) staff were at higher risk regardless of their job role, department, or home exposure. Additionally, the study observed that 24% of individuals remained PCR-positive for six weeks or longer, a finding with important implications for return-to-work policies.

Discussion

These results suggest that COVID-19 risk for HCWs is highly heterogeneous and influenced by a combination of workplace protocols, job roles, and demographic factors. The relative safety of the ICU environment highlights the effectiveness of high-level PPE and specialized training. Conversely, the increased risk in acute medicine and among specific ethnic groups points to vulnerabilities in standard PPE protocols and potential structural inequalities or community transmission factors not captured by job role.

Limitations include the observational and cross-sectional nature of the study, which relies on self-reported data subject to recall bias. As the study was conducted at a single hospital trust, the results may not be universally applicable to regions with different protocols.

Conclusion

The study demonstrates that while healthcare work increases COVID-19 risk, this risk can be mitigated through rigorous PPE bundles. Protecting staff requires addressing risks in non-ICU clinical areas and understanding the broader social determinants of health that contribute to infection disparities. Future research using viral genome sequencing is needed to definitively map transmission pathways.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background Personal protective equipment (PPE) and social distancing are designed to mitigate risk of occupational SARS-CoV-2 infection in hospitals. Why healthcare workers nevertheless remain at increased risk is uncertain. Methods We conducted voluntary Covid-19 testing programmes for symptomatic and asymptomatic staff at a UK teaching hospital using nasopharyngeal PCR testing and immunoassays for IgG antibodies. A positive result by either modality determined a composite outcome. Risk-factors for Covid-19 were investigated using multivariable logistic regression. Results 1083/9809(11.0%) staff had evidence of Covid-19 at some time and provided data on potential risk-factors. Staff with a confirmed household contact were at greatest risk (adjusted odds ratio [aOR] 4.63 [95%CI 3.30-6.50]). Higher rates of Covid-19 were seen in staff working in Covid-19-facing areas (21.2% vs. 8.2% elsewhere) (aOR 2.49 [2.00-3.12]). Controlling for Covid-19-facing status, risks were heterogenous across the hospital, with higher rates in acute medicine (1.50 [1.05-2.15]) and sporadic outbreaks in areas with few or no Covid-19 patients. Covid-19 intensive care unit (ICU) staff were relatively protected (0.46 [0.29-0.72]). Positive results were more likely in Black (1.61 [1.20-2.16]) and Asian (1.58 [1.34-1.86]) staff, independent of role or working location, and in porters and cleaners (1.93 [1.25-2.97]). Contact tracing around asymptomatic staff did not lead to enhanced case identification. 24% of staff/patients remained PCR-positive at ≥6 weeks post-diagnosis. Conclusions Increased Covid-19 risk was seen in acute medicine, among Black and Asian staff, and porters and cleaners. A bundle of PPE-related interventions protected staff in ICU.
BibTeX
@misc{eyre2020differential,
  author = {David W. Eyre and Sheila Lumley and Denise O’Donnell and Mark Campbell and Elizabeth Sims and Elaine Lawson and Fiona C Warren and Tim James and Stuart Cox and Alison Howarth and George Doherty and Stephanie B. Hatch and James Kavanagh and Kevin Chau and Philip W. Fowler and Jeremy Swann and Denis Volk and Fan Yang-Turner and Nicole Stoesser and Philippa C. Matthews and Maria Dudareva and T. J. Davies and R. H. Shaw and Leon Peto and Louise Downs and Alexander Vogt and Ali Amini and Bernadette Young and Philip G. Drennan and Alexander J. Mentzer and Donal Skelly and Fredrik Karpe and Matt J. Neville and Monique Andersson and Andrew Brent and Nicola Jones and Lucas Martins Ferreira and Thomas Christott and Brian D. Marsden and Sarah Hoosdally and Richard J. Cornall and Derrick W. Crook and David I. Stuart and Gavin Screaton and Tim Peto and Bruno Holthof and Colm P. O’Donnell and Daniel Ebner and Christopher P. Conlon and Katie Jeffery and A Sarah Walker},
  title = {{Differential occupational risks to healthcare workers from SARS-CoV-2: A prospective observational study}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.06.24.20135038},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure