Racial and Ethnic Disparities Among COVID-19 Cases in Workplace Outbreaks by Industry Sector — Utah, March 6–June 5, 2020

David Bui, Keegan McCaffrey, Michael Friedrichs, Nathan LaCross, Nathaniel M. Lewis, Kylie Sage, Bree Barbeau, Dede Vilven, Carolyn Penstein Rosé, Sara Braby, Sarah Willardson, Amy Carter, Christopher Smoot, Andrea Winquist, Angela DunnMMWR 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Improved understanding of the distribution of workplace COVID-19 outbreaks by industry sector is critical for directing public health action. The Utah Department of Health (UDOH) analyzed surveillance data from March 6 to June 5, 2020, identifying 210 workplace outbreaks (76% of all outbreaks) involving 1,389 cases. Nearly half of these outbreaks occurred in the Manufacturing, Construction, and Wholesale Trade sectors. A significant racial disparity was found: while Hispanic and nonwhite workers comprised only 24% of the workforce in affected sectors, they accounted for 73% of workplace outbreak-associated cases. These findings highlight how systemic social inequities place frontline workers at disproportionate risk.

Introduction

Early in the COVID-19 pandemic, workplace outbreaks in Utah were a primary driver of infection. While it was known that the virus spread in occupational settings, public health officials lacked granular data on which specific industry sectors were most vulnerable and how the burden of disease was distributed across different demographic groups. This study fills that gap by identifying high-risk sectors and quantifying racial and ethnic disparities to provide a roadmap for more targeted, equitable, and effective public health interventions.

Methods

Researchers conducted a retrospective analysis of COVID-19 surveillance data in Utah. A "workplace outbreak" was defined as two or more laboratory-confirmed cases occurring within a 14-day period among coworkers in a common non-healthcare, non-educational, and non-congregate-living setting. Workplaces were categorized using the North American Industry Classification System (NAICS). Outbreak incidence (cases per 100,000 workers) was calculated using 2019 Census Quarterly Workforce Indicators as the denominator.

Key Results

Out of 277 total outbreaks in Utah during the study period, 210 (76%) occurred in workplaces. Nearly half of all workplace outbreaks were concentrated in just three sectors: Manufacturing (20%), Construction (15%), and Wholesale Trade (14%). These three sectors accounted for 58% of all workplace outbreak-associated cases.

Table 1: COVID-19 workplace outbreaks, associated cases, and worker characteristics, by industry sector — Utah, March 6–June 5, 2020

The highest incidence rates were found in Wholesale Trade (377 per 100,000 workers) and Manufacturing (339 per 100,000 workers). Interestingly, the proportion of patients hospitalized was lower among workplace-associated cases (6.1%) than non-outbreak cases (7.6%), possibly due to a "healthy worker effect" or the younger median age of the workforce.

Racial and Ethnic Disparities

A staggering racial disparity was observed across all 15 affected sectors. Hispanic and nonwhite workers represented 73% of workplace-associated cases but only 24% of the workforce. This "disparity gap" was particularly pronounced in sectors like Wholesale Trade, where the difference between the percentage of Hispanic/nonwhite workers in the workforce and their percentage among outbreak cases was 58 percentage points.

Figure 1: Percentage of Hispanic/Latino and nonwhite workers in the overall industry workforce compared with workplace outbreak-associated cases, by industry sector — Utah, March 6–June 5, 2020

Discussion and Limitations

The concentration of cases in Manufacturing, Construction, and Wholesale Trade highlights the risk inherent in "frontline" occupations that involve physical proximity and limited telework options. These disparities are systemic; Hispanic and nonwhite workers are overrepresented in essential roles with less job flexibility and often face punitive sick leave policies that discourage staying home when ill.

Limitations of the study include potential detection bias (missing smaller outbreaks or asymptomatic cases) and the use of broad industry sectors rather than specific occupation data. Future public health efforts must focus on providing culturally and linguistically responsive mitigation strategies and advocating for nonpunitive sick leave to protect vulnerable frontline populations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Improved understanding of the overall distribution of workplace coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) outbreaks by industry sector could help direct targeted public health action; however, this has not been described. The Utah Department of Health (UDOH) analyzed COVID-19 surveillance data to describe workplace outbreaks by industry sectors. In this report, workplaces refer to non-health care, noncongregate-living, and noneducational settings. As of June 5, 2020, UDOH reported 277 COVID-19 outbreaks, 210 (76%) of which occurred in workplaces. Approximately 12% (1,389 of 11,448) of confirmed COVID-19 cases in Utah were associated with workplace outbreaks. The 210 workplace outbreaks occurred in 15 of 20 industry sectors;* nearly one half of all workplace outbreaks occurred in three sectors: Manufacturing (43; 20%), Construction (32; 15%) and Wholesale Trade (29; 14%); 58% (806 of 1,389) of workplace outbreak-associated cases occurred in these three sectors. Although 24% of Utah's workforce in all 15 affected sectors identified as Hispanic or Latino (Hispanic) or a race other than non-Hispanic white (nonwhite<sup>†</sup>) (1), 73% (970 of 1,335) of workplace outbreak-associated COVID-19 cases were in persons who identified as Hispanic or nonwhite. Systemic social inequities have resulted in the overrepresentation of Hispanic and nonwhite workers in frontline occupations where exposure to SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, might be higher (2); extra vigilance in these sectors is needed to ensure prevention and mitigation strategies are applied equitably and effectively to workers of racial and ethnic groups disproportionately affected by COVID-19. Health departments can adapt workplace guidance to each industry sector affected by COVID-19 to account for different production processes and working conditions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bui2020racial,
  author = {David Bui and Keegan McCaffrey and Michael Friedrichs and Nathan LaCross and Nathaniel M. Lewis and Kylie Sage and Bree Barbeau and Dede Vilven and Carolyn Penstein Rosé and Sara Braby and Sarah Willardson and Amy Carter and Christopher Smoot and Andrea Winquist and Angela Dunn},
  title = {{Racial and Ethnic Disparities Among COVID-19 Cases in Workplace Outbreaks by Industry Sector — Utah, March 6–June 5, 2020}},
  booktitle = {MMWR},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.15585/mmwr.mm6933e3},
}
Figure