Symmetry-Projected Nuclear-Electronic Hartree–Fock: Eliminating Rotational Energy Contamination

Robin Feldmann, Alberto Baiardi, Markus Reiher

TL;DR

This paper introduces a symmetry projection technique for nuclear-electronic Hartree-Fock (NE-HF) theory, a method that treats both electrons and nuclei as quantum particles. By mathematically restoring rotational and parity symmetries broken by standard basis sets, the authors eliminate "rotational energy contamination" and enable the precise calculation of specific molecular rotational states.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In standard quantum chemistry, we usually rely on the Born-Oppenheimer approximation, which assumes nuclei are fixed points while electrons move around them. Nuclear-Electronic Hartree-Fock (NE-HF) goes a step further by treating nuclei and electrons on "equal footing" as quantum waves.

However, there is a catch: to solve these equations, researchers use Gaussian basis sets (GTOs) centered at specific points in space. This effectively "pins" the molecule down, breaking the natural rotational symmetry of the system. In the real world, a molecule in a vacuum doesn't care which way it’s pointing. Because the math "freezes" the molecule, the resulting wave function becomes a messy mixture of many different rotational states ($J=0, 1, 2, \dots$) rather than a pure one. This "contamination" leads to inaccurately high energy estimates and makes it impossible to target specific rotational excitations.

Methods

The authors adapt a technique from nuclear structure theory called Symmetry Projection.

  1. Projection-After-Variation (PAV): They first perform a standard NE-HF calculation to get a symmetry-broken wave function.
  2. SO(3) Projection: They apply a projection operator that extracts the component of the wave function corresponding to a specific angular momentum quantum number ($J$) and its projection ($M_J$). This involves integrating the wave function over all possible rotations in three-dimensional space (the SO(3) group).
  3. Parity Projection: They similarly project the wave function to ensure it has the correct spatial inversion symmetry (parity).
  4. Numerical Integration: Since these projections involve complex integrals, the authors use sophisticated "quadrature" rules (like Lebedev and trapezoidal grids) to discretize the rotation space, making the calculation computationally feasible.

Datasets

The study evaluates the method using two prototypical molecular systems where high-accuracy reference data exists:

  • $H_2$ (Molecular Hydrogen): Used to test energy convergence and the elimination of contamination in a simple linear system.
  • $H_3^+$ (Trihydrogen Cation): A more complex, non-linear system used to demonstrate the ability to target multiple low-lying rotational states and verify parity requirements.
  • Basis Sets: The authors used standard electronic basis sets (cc-pVDZ/TZ/QZ-mc) and specialized protonic basis sets (PB4-D, PB5-G).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Aha" Moment on Overlap: The authors found that the original, symmetry-broken NE-HF wave function for $H_2$ had an overlap of only ~0.088 with the correctly projected ground state. In quantum terms, this means the standard starting point is "qualitatively inaccurate"—it barely resembles the true physical state.
  • Automatic Spin Restoration: Interestingly, projecting for rotational symmetry also helped restore nuclear spin symmetry ($S^2$) as a byproduct, which is usually a separate, difficult task in multicomponent systems.
  • Physics-Based Filtering: The method naturally handles "Pauli-forbidden" states. If a researcher tries to project onto a state that is physically impossible due to the Pauli exclusion principle (like certain $J=0$ states in $H_3^+$), the math simply returns a null vector.

Key Results

  • Significant Energy Lowering: For the $H_2$ molecule, the symmetry projection lowered the calculated ground-state energy by approximately 21.5 mHa (about 4718 cm⁻¹). This represents a massive correction of the "contamination" error.
  • Rotational Spectra: The method successfully reproduced the correct energy ordering for the first seven rotational states of $H_3^+$.
  • Computational Efficiency: While the projection adds cost, the authors demonstrated that it parallelizes extremely well. A projection for $H_3^+$ using 13,020 quadrature points took about 75 minutes on a 64-core workstation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Missing Correlation: While the method fixes symmetry, it still operates within the Hartree-Fock framework, which ignores "correlation" (the way particles avoid each other). This led to a ~24 cm⁻¹ deviation from experimental values for $H_2$ transitions. Future work will need to combine this projection with more advanced methods like Density Functional Theory (DFT).
  • Orbital Relaxation: This study used "Projection-After-Variation." The authors note that "Variation-After-Projection" (where the orbitals are optimized while being projected) would be more accurate but is mathematically much more grueling.
  • Heavier Atoms: The current tests focused on hydrogen. Extending this to heavier nuclei will require optimizing atom-centered basis functions specifically for those elements.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present a symmetry projection technique for enforcing rotational and parity symmetries in nuclear-electronic Hartree-Fock wave functions, which treat electrons and nuclei on equal footing. The molecular Hamiltonian obeys rotational and parity inversion symmetries, which are, however, broken by expanding in Gaussian basis sets that are fixed in space. We generate a trial wave function with the correct symmetry properties by projecting the wave function onto representations of the three-dimensional rotation group, i.e., the special orthogonal group in three dimensions SO(3). As a consequence, the wave function becomes an eigenfunction of the angular momentum operator which (i) eliminates the contamination of the ground-state wave function by highly excited rotational states arising from the broken rotational symmetry and (ii) enables the targeting of specific rotational states of the molecule. We demonstrate the efficiency of the symmetry projection technique by calculating the energies of the low-lying rotational states of the H<sub>2</sub> and H<sub>3</sub><sup>+</sup> molecules.
BibTeX
@article{feldmann2023symmetry,
  author = {Robin Feldmann and Alberto Baiardi and Markus Reiher},
  title = {{Symmetry-Projected Nuclear-Electronic Hartree–Fock: Eliminating Rotational Energy Contamination}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physical Chemistry A},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.jpca.3c04822},
}

Loading related content...

Figure