Symmetry invariants and classes of quasiparticles in magnetically ordered systems having weak spin-orbit coupling

Jian Yang, Zheng-Xin Liu, Fang ChenarXiv 2021 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper identifies 218 new classes of quasiparticles that can only exist in magnetic materials where spin and spatial symmetries are decoupled due to weak spin-orbit coupling. By moving beyond traditional Magnetic Space Groups to "Spin-Space Groups," the authors reveal exotic excitations like 12-fold degenerate fermions and unique nodal-line structures that have no counterparts in high-energy physics or standard solid-state theory.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the world of condensed matter, we often look for "emergent" particles—quasiparticles like Dirac or Weyl fermions—that mimic elementary particles but exist only inside a crystal lattice. Traditionally, these are classified using Magnetic Space Groups (MSGs), which assume that an electron's spin is "locked" to its movement through the lattice (strong spin-orbit coupling).

However, many real-world materials have very weak spin-orbit coupling (SOC). In these cases, the spin and the lattice can be rotated independently, leading to a much richer set of symmetries described by Spin-Space Groups (SSGs). The challenge has been that while MSGs are well-mapped, the landscape of quasiparticles allowed by SSGs remained largely unexplored. This paper fills that gap by systematically classifying these "Wigner-type" particles that don't follow the standard rules of high-energy physics.

Methods

The authors employ group cohomology to define "symmetry invariants." These are discrete values (usually $\pm 1$) that act as labels for different "projective classes" of a symmetry group.

Key steps in their approach include:

  1. Defining Invariants: They use the second group cohomology group to identify variables that classify how a wavefunction transforms under symmetry operations.
  2. Spin-Space Group Framework: They analyze systems where SOC is negligible, allowing spin and lattice operations to be treated as a product group ($P \times Z_2^T$).
  3. The Multiplicity Theorem: They rigorously prove a theorem stating that if two quasiparticles have different symmetry invariants, they must be physically distinguishable through their degree of degeneracy, their energy dispersion (how they move), or how they react to external fields (like strain or magnetic fields).
  4. k·p Modeling: They construct effective low-energy Hamiltonians to visualize the band structures and nodal lines of these new particles.

Datasets

While this is a theoretical physics paper, the authors validated their findings by searching for real-world material candidates. They cross-referenced their classification with:

  • MAGNDATA: A database containing over 2,000 experimentally determined magnetic structures.
  • SSG Enumerations: Existing lists of all possible spin-space groups.

Through this search, they identified the material $Ce_3NIn$ as a primary candidate for hosting one of these newly discovered SSG-exclusive quasiparticles.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Wigner’s "New Types": About 60 years ago, Eugene Wigner suggested that time-reversal symmetry ($\eta_T$) and spin statistics ($(-1)^{2s}$) don't have to be linked. In a vacuum, they are; in a crystal lattice with weak SOC, they aren't. This allows for "fermionic bosons" or "bosonic fermions" in terms of their symmetry behavior.
  • The 12-Fold Fermion: The authors highlight a 12-fold degenerate fermion. In standard MSGs, such high degeneracy is unheard of. This particle is essentially a superposition of four "spin-1 double-Weyl points."
  • Quintic Dispersion: They discovered a 4-fold fermion with a band splitting proportional to $k^5$. This "quintic" splitting is unprecedented in symmetry-protected band nodes, which usually split linearly or quadratically.
  • Physical Distinguishability: The core "aha!" moment is the proof that symmetry invariants aren't just mathematical abstractions; they dictate exactly how a material will respond to a probe, such as an ultrasonic wave (strain) or a magnetic field.

Key Results

  • 218 New Classes: The study identifies 218 types of quasiparticles that are impossible in MSGs but perfectly stable in SSGs.
  • 13-Nodal-Line Nexus: They describe a unique structure where 13 Dirac nodal lines meet at a single high-symmetry point in the Brillouin zone, a configuration only possible under SSG symmetry.
  • Material Discovery: The identification of $Ce_3NIn$ provides a concrete target for experimentalists to verify these theories using techniques like Angle-Resolved Photoemission Spectroscopy (ARPES).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Scarcity: Only one material candidate was found. The authors note that while we know the crystal structures of 200,000 materials, we only know the magnetic structures of about 2,000. This "magnetic data gap" limits the immediate discovery of these particles.
  • Scope of Symmetries: The current work focuses on non-coplanar magnetic orders and specific "little co-groups." The authors suggest that extending this to collinear and coplanar systems (which have even more unlocked spin symmetries) could reveal even more exotic classes.
  • SOC Sensitivity: Since these particles rely on weak SOC, a major future challenge is determining exactly how much SOC a material can tolerate before these unique SSG properties collapse back into standard MSG behavior.

Summary updated

Abstract

Symmetry invariants of a group specify the classes of quasiparticles, namely the classes of projective irreducible co-representations in systems having that symmetry. More symmetry invariants exist in discrete point groups than the full rotation group $\mathrm{O(3)}$, leading to new quasiparticles restricted to lattices that do not have any counterpart in a vacuum. We focus on the fermionic quasiparticle excitations under ``spin-space group'' symmetries, applicable to materials where long-range magnetic order and itinerant electrons coexist. We provide a list of 218 classes of new quasiparticles that can only be realized in the spin-space groups. These quasiparticles have at least one of the following properties that are qualitatively distinct from those discovered in magnetic space group(MSG)s, and distinct from each other:(i) degree of degeneracy,(ii) dispersion as function of momentum, and(iii) rules of coupling to external probe fields. We rigorously prove this result as a theorem that directly relates these properties to the symmetry invariants, and then illustrate this theorem with a concrete example, by comparing three 12-fold fermions having different sets of symmetry invariants including one discovered in MSG. Our approach can be generalized to realize more quasiparticles whose little co-groups are beyond those considered in our work.
BibTeX
@misc{yang2021symmetry,
  author = {Jian Yang and Zheng-Xin Liu and Fang Chen},
  title = {{Symmetry invariants and classes of quasiparticles in magnetically ordered systems having weak spin-orbit coupling}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2105.12738},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2105.12738},
}
Figure