TL;DR
This paper presents a novel method for deploying symbolic regression (SR) models on FPGAs for high-speed machine learning inference. By generating compact, interpretable algebraic expressions and optimizing them for FPGAs, the authors achieve significant reductions in execution time and resource usage compared to traditional neural networks, while maintaining high accuracy.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The high-energy physics (HEP) community faces a critical challenge: processing massive amounts of data from experiments like the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) at extremely high rates (40 MHz) and with strict latency constraints (microseconds). Traditional deep learning models, while powerful, can be computationally expensive and difficult to optimize for the tight resource and latency budgets of real-time trigger systems. This necessitates lightweight, efficient inference solutions that can operate on custom hardware like Field-Programmable Gate Arrays (FPGAs). The paper addresses the gap in efficiently deploying machine learning models on FPGAs, particularly for tasks requiring ultra-low latency inference, by exploring an alternative to deep neural networks: symbolic regression.
Methods
The core of this work is the integration of Symbolic Regression (SR) with FPGA inference frameworks.
- Symbolic Regression (SR): The authors utilize PySR, an open-source tool that employs an evolutionary algorithm to discover algebraic expressions that best fit a given dataset. Unlike neural networks where architecture is hand-tuned or searched extensively, SR directly searches for mathematical equations. This approach naturally leads to interpretable models and allows for direct optimization of the performance-resource trade-off by selecting models from a Pareto front.
- FPGA Deployment: The hls4ml framework is extended to support expressions generated by PySR. hls4ml is a high-level synthesis (HLS) tool that translates machine learning models into hardware description languages suitable for FPGAs. The extension allows hls4ml to parse and implement the symbolic expressions, including approximating mathematical functions (like sine, tangent, exponential, logarithmic) using Lookup Tables (LUTs) for further optimization.
- Latency-Aware Training (LAT): To further tailor SR for FPGAs, the authors introduce a latency-aware training strategy. This involves assigning different "complexity" costs to operators based on their typical execution time on an FPGA (e.g., a tangent function is more costly than a sine function). This guides the SR search towards expressions that are not only accurate but also computationally efficient on the target hardware.
Datasets
The paper uses a simulated jet dataset from high-energy physics experiments at the LHC. This dataset is publicly available from Zenodo. The task is to classify jets originating from different particle types (quarks, gluons, W/Z bosons, top quarks) using 16 physics-motivated expert features.
Key Insights and Ideas
- SR as a Viable Alternative to DNNs for FPGAs: The study demonstrates that SR can generate models that are not only accurate but also dramatically more efficient in terms of computational resources and latency compared to traditional neural networks, making it a strong candidate for FPGA deployment.
- Direct Performance-Resource Trade-off Optimization: SR's ability to explore a "Pareto front" of models allows for direct selection of solutions that balance accuracy, latency, and resource usage, a more direct approach than the often indirect optimization of DNNs.
- LUTs for Function Approximation: Using LUTs to approximate complex mathematical functions within SR expressions significantly reduces hardware complexity and latency, proving to be a key optimization strategy for FPGA implementation.
- Latency-Awareness is Crucial for FPGAs: Simply optimizing for accuracy is insufficient for hardware deployment. Explicitly incorporating operator latency into the SR search (LAT) leads to demonstrably better FPGA performance.
- Interpretability and Efficiency Combined: The symbolic nature of SR models offers inherent interpretability, a valuable asset in scientific applications, while simultaneously achieving high performance on specialized hardware.
Key Results
- Significant Latency Reduction: The SR-based inference models achieved execution times as low as 5 ns, representing a 13-fold decrease compared to the baseline 3-layer neural network (which took 65 ns).
- High Approximation Accuracy: The SR models preserved over 90% of the approximation accuracy compared to the baseline neural network.
- Dramatic Resource Savings: SR models showed significant reductions in resource usage (DSPs and LUTs), sometimes by several orders of magnitude, especially when using LUT-based function approximation.
- Latency-Aware Training Benefits: Models trained with LAT consistently used fewer resources and had lower latency than those from plain implementation, while maintaining comparable accuracy.
Limitations and Future Work
- Scalability of SR: The authors acknowledge that SR, particularly with evolutionary algorithms, can be a complex combinatorial problem that doesn't scale well to very high-dimensional datasets. They mitigate this by using a random forest to pre-select input features.
- Further Optimization: The paper suggests that further optimization of the performance-resource trade-off is possible.
- Exploration of Other Domains: The authors propose exploring other application domains for SR on FPGAs beyond high-energy physics.
- Operator Complexity for LAT: The paper notes that the operator complexity assignment for LAT is not universally applicable, especially for LUT-based function approximations where indexing is the primary operation.
Summary updated