TL;DR
This paper introduces Sym2Real, a novel framework that enables robots to learn adaptive control policies with remarkably little data. By combining symbolic regression on low-fidelity simulations with lightweight residual learning on real-world data, Sym2Real achieves robust control for quadrotors and racecars, even in challenging out-of-distribution scenarios.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Developing robots that can not only perform tasks but also adapt to new or changing conditions is a major hurdle in robotics. Traditional data-driven control methods often require vast amounts of high-quality data, which is expensive and time-consuming to collect, both in the real world and in simulation. Simulators, while useful, often need extensive tuning to accurately reflect real-world physics, and even then, transferring models to the real world (sim2real) can be fraught with challenges. This paper tackles the problem of achieving data-efficient, adaptive control for robots without requiring extensive prior knowledge or laborious simulation engineering.
Methods
Sym2Real employs a two-stage approach:
- Symbolic Regression (SR) for Core Dynamics Extraction: The first stage leverages a simplified, low-fidelity simulation environment. This environment is intentionally kept basic, free from manual parameter tuning, noise, or external disturbances. The goal here is to extract the fundamental, shared physics of the robot's dynamics using symbolic regression. SR is chosen for its data efficiency and ability to produce compact, interpretable equations. The authors use PySR with specific configurations to ensure concise expressions. Crucially, they allow "risky" simulated behaviors (like flips or drifts) that would be unsafe in the real world, as these provide richer state-action coverage for learning the core dynamics.
- Residual Learning for Adaptation: Once the SR base model is learned from simulation, it's deployed in the target (real-world) environment. Since the low-fidelity simulation might not perfectly capture all nuances, a small amount of real-world data is collected. This data is used to train a lightweight residual neural network (NN) that learns to correct the discrepancies between the SR model's predictions and the actual system behavior. The final dynamics model is a combination of the SR model and the residual NN. This approach allows for few-shot adaptation, meaning it can learn from very few real-world trajectories.
Datasets
The paper does not introduce new datasets but utilizes data generated from:
- Low-fidelity simulation: Data collected from a simplified simulation environment for training the initial SR base model. This data is generated using default robot description files and a generic physics engine.
- Real-world data: Trajectories collected from physical quadrotor and racecar platforms for fine-tuning the SR model with the residual NN.
The paper evaluates performance across various out-of-distribution (OOD) scenarios, including:
- Sim2sim: Six OOD scenarios for quadrotors and racecars, involving changes in mass, center-of-mass, wind, and friction.
- Sim2real: Five real-world conditions for quadrotors and racecars, including plain sim2real transfer, added mass, center-of-mass offset, and steering offset.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Physics is Shared: The core insight is that underlying physical principles are often consistent across different operating conditions or embodiments. This allows for learning a generalizable base model from simplified simulations.
- SR for Data Efficiency: Symbolic regression excels at extracting compact, interpretable models from limited data, making it ideal for learning the fundamental dynamics.
- Residual NN for Adaptation: A lightweight NN is highly effective for learning the domain-specific deviations from the base SR model, enabling rapid adaptation with minimal real-world interaction.
- Safe Exploration in Simulation: Leveraging simulation's safety allows for collecting data from behaviors that would be dangerous in reality, leading to more robust base models.
- Decomposition is Key: Separating the learning problem into learning core physics (SR) and learning residuals (NN) is more effective than trying to learn everything end-to-end with a single model, especially for data efficiency.
Key Results
- Data Efficiency: Sym2Real achieves robust control with as few as 10 trajectories for adaptation. For base model learning, it requires around 20 trajectories for the racecar and 10 for the quadrotor, significantly outperforming NN baselines that need over 100 trajectories.
- Sim2sim Transfer: The method demonstrates consistent adaptation across six OOD simulation scenarios, showing improved performance over direct SR transfer and NN baselines.
- Sim2real Transfer: Successful adaptation is shown across five real-world conditions for both quadrotors and racecars, achieving robust control even with significant domain shifts.
- Computational Efficiency: SR models offer faster inference times (over 4x faster than NN models for quadrotor control), enabling more efficient MPC rollouts.
- Robustness: The SR-derived dynamics equations were found to be physically plausible, with key variables like thrust appearing in relevant equations, ensuring safe and effective control.
Limitations and Future Work
- Scalability of SR: The authors acknowledge that SR's scalability is a concern as the input dimension increases.
- Contact Dynamics: The current approach does not explicitly address systems with contact dynamics.
Future work suggested includes:
- Exploring data-driven models like sparse NNs to scale SR to higher-dimensional systems.
- Combining SR with techniques for discovering low-dimensional dynamics from high-dimensional data.
- Extending the approach to handle contact dynamics by decomposing dynamics into symbolically regressable and non-regressable components.
Summary updated