Swampland conjectures constraints on dark energy from a highly curved field space

Guillaume Payeur, Evan McDonough, Robert Brandenberger

TL;DR

This paper explores a novel multi-field dark energy model where accelerated expansion arises from non-geodesic motion in a highly curved field space. By combining the Trans-Planckian Censorship Conjecture (TCC) and the Swampland Distance Conjecture (SDC), the authors demonstrate that this model can reconcile eternal accelerated expansion with fundamental constraints from quantum gravity, aligning with current observational data.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The nature of dark energy, responsible for the accelerating expansion of the universe, remains one of the biggest mysteries in physics. While a cosmological constant is the simplest explanation, it faces theoretical challenges like extreme fine-tuning and potential inconsistencies with string theory. Alternative models, like quintessence (a scalar field slowly rolling down a potential), have been proposed. However, embedding these models in a UV-complete theory like string theory often leads to potentials that are too steep for the observed slow acceleration.

Furthermore, two key conjectures from the "Swampland" program – the idea that not all effective field theories (EFTs) can be consistently embedded in quantum gravity – pose significant constraints. The Trans-Planckian Censorship Conjecture (TCC) suggests that any epoch of cosmic acceleration must have a finite duration to prevent observable consequences of Planck-scale physics. The Swampland Distance Conjecture (SDC) posits that EFTs are only valid over a finite field range, beyond which an infinite tower of massive states appears, breaking down the EFT. This paper tackles the challenge of constructing a dark energy model that is both observationally viable and consistent with these fundamental Swampland constraints, particularly in the context of highly curved field spaces, which are common in string theory compactifications.

Methods

The authors investigate a two-field model with a non-trivial, curved field space metric and an exponential potential. The key innovation lies in how accelerated expansion is achieved: not through a flat potential (as in standard quintessence), but through non-geodesic motion in a highly curved field space. This "rapid turn" mechanism allows for accelerated expansion even with steep potentials.

They derive the equations of motion for the two scalar fields and identify a stable hyperbolic attractor solution. This attractor solution leads to a near-constant equation of state parameter ($w \approx -1$), consistent with observations. Crucially, they analyze the interplay between the TCC and SDC by translating the evolution of the scalar fields into a geodesic distance in field space. They then derive constraints on the model's parameters (specifically, the curvature of the field space, $L$, and the steepness of the potential, $\lambda$) that ensure consistency with both conjectures and observational data.

Datasets

The paper uses observational data from:

  • Planck 2018: For cosmological parameters and constraints on dark energy.
  • Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI): For constraints on the equation of state parameter ($w$).

The paper does not introduce new datasets or benchmarks.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Accelerated Expansion via Non-Geodesic Motion: The most striking insight is that cosmic acceleration can be driven by fields moving off the geodesic path in a highly curved field space, rather than slowly rolling down a flat potential. This offers a new paradigm for dark energy models.
  • Resolving TCC-SDC Tension: The paper elegantly shows how the SDC can resolve a potential conflict with the TCC. While the hyperbolic attractor predicts eternal acceleration (violating TCC), the SDC implies that the EFT breaks down before the TCC is violated, provided the fields traverse a Planckian distance.
  • Hyperbolic Attractor as a Dark Energy Solution: The identified hyperbolic attractor provides a stable, near-constant $w \approx -1$ solution, which is precisely what is needed for dark energy.
  • Curved Field Space as a String Theory Feature: The paper highlights that such curved field spaces are a natural consequence of string theory compactifications, making this model a promising candidate for a UV-complete dark energy theory.

Key Results

  • The model can achieve an equation of state parameter $w \approx -1$ with $\lambda \ge 1$, consistent with observational constraints from Planck and DESI.
  • The interplay between the TCC and SDC leads to specific constraints on the model parameters ($L$ and $\lambda$).
  • A significant region of the parameter space ($L$ and $\lambda$) is found to be consistent with both Swampland conjectures and observational data.
  • The paper provides an approximate constraint on the field space curvature: $L \lesssim 1/690$ for the model to be consistent with the TCC and SDC.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Coincidence Problem: The model, as presented, does not inherently solve the cosmological coincidence problem (why dark energy dominates today). Parameters and initial conditions must be fine-tuned to match the observed dark energy density.
  • Oscillatory Phase: While the hyperbolic attractor is stable, the transition to it involves a phase where the equation of state parameter ($w$) oscillates. The paper notes that these oscillations can be reduced by model extensions or specific initial conditions, but a detailed analysis of their phenomenological implications is left for future work.
  • Explicit String Constructions: While the model's structure is motivated by string theory, the paper does not present explicit string constructions that yield the required parameter values. This is suggested as a future research direction.
  • Isocurvature Perturbations: The negative curvature of the field space can lead to isocurvature perturbations. While some models can mitigate this, a detailed study for this specific dark energy model is left for future work.
  • Geodesic vs. Trajectory Distance: The paper notes a large mismatch between the geodesic distance used in the SDC and the actual field trajectory distance, suggesting this could have implications for other swampland studies.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the interplay of the trans-Planckian censorship conjecture (TCC) and the swampland distance conjecture (SDC) in the context of multifield dark energy in a curved field space. In this scenario, the phase of accelerated expansion is realized as nongeodesic motion in a highly curved field space, reminiscent of models developed in the context of inflation. The model features a stable attractor solution with near constant equation of state <a:math xmlns:a="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"> <a:mi>w</a:mi> <a:mo>≃</a:mo> <a:mo>−</a:mo> <a:mn>1</a:mn> </a:math> , and predicts that the current era of accelerated expansion is eternal. The latter implies an eventual conflict with the TCC, which holds that the duration of any epoch of cosmic acceleration is bounded by the requirement that the large-scale observable universe is blind to Planck-scale early universe physics. This tension can be resolved by an interplay with the distance conjecture: for suitable parameter values, the apparent violation of the TCC occurs well after the fields have traversed a Planckian distance. The SDC then predicts a breakdown of the effective field theory before the TCC can be violated. We derive the constraints on the model arising from the <c:math xmlns:c="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"> <c:mrow> <c:mi>SDC</c:mi> <c:mo>+</c:mo> <c:mi>TCC</c:mi> </c:mrow> </c:math> and the de Sitter conjecture. We demonstrate that the model can be consistent with both swampland conjectures and observational data from Planck 2018 and the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
BibTeX
@article{payeur2024swampland,
  author = {Guillaume Payeur and Evan McDonough and Robert Brandenberger},
  title = {{Swampland conjectures constraints on dark energy from a highly curved field space}},
  journal = {Physical review. D/Physical review. D.},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.110.106011},
}
Figure