Sustainable Export Innovation Behavior of Firms Under Fiscal Incentive

Chen Feng, Beibei Shi, Hong Yan, Siying Yang, Caiquan BaiFrontiers in Psychology 2021 · DOI

Abstract

The fiscal imbalance between the central and local governments under fiscal centralization may motivate local governments to pass tax burdens on firms. This study uses China's 2002 income tax sharing policy to examine the impact of fiscal centralization on the sustainable export innovation behavior of firms. We find that this tax reform significantly inhibited the increase of the export domestic value-added rate (DVAR) of firms, a trend that intensified as the central government's share ratio increased. This effect primarily stems from a crowding-out effect where imported intermediate goods replaced domestic ones. Facing downward fiscal pressure, local governments forced firms to prioritize export quantity over quality to expand the tax base, hindering long-term sustainable innovation and global value chain progression.

Introduction: The Quality vs. Quantity Dilemma

For decades, China has served as the "world factory," yet it has struggled to transition from "Made in China" to "Created in China." A critical metric for this transition is the Domestic Value-Added Rate (DVAR)—the proportion of an export’s value produced domestically rather than imported as components.

This research investigates how macro-level fiscal policies, specifically fiscal centralization, impact firm-level sustainable innovation. When the central government claims a larger share of tax revenue, local governments face a "fiscal imbalance." This study asks whether such pressure leads local officials to implement short-sighted policies that encourage firms to expand export volume at the expense of producing higher-value, innovative goods.

Methodology and Data

The study utilizes China’s 2002 Income Tax Sharing Reform as a quasi-natural experiment. Prior to 2002, local governments retained most corporate income tax; post-reform, the central government’s share rose to 50% (and 60% in 2003). Using a Difference-in-Differences (DID) model, the authors compared private and local firms (treatment group) against central state-owned and foreign-funded firms (control group).

Table 1: Descriptive statistics and definitions of key variables used in the study.

The researchers merged several massive datasets from 2000 to 2006, including the China Industry Business Performance Database and the China Customs Trade Database. By combining customs data with industrial performance data, they tracked the exact ratio of foreign versus domestic materials in exports.

Key Results: The Impact of Fiscal Centralization

The empirical analysis reveals that the tax reform significantly inhibited firms' DVAR. The baseline DID coefficient was approximately -0.0187, indicating that the reform reduced the domestic value-added rate by nearly 2 percentage points compared to the control group.

Table 2: Baseline regression results showing the impact of the 2002 tax reform on DVAR across different specifications.

As shown in Table 2, the negative effect grew stronger as the central government’s share of tax revenue increased over time (see columns 7 and 8). These findings remained robust even when accounting for external shocks like China’s WTO accession and exchange rate reforms.

Mechanisms: The Crowding-Out Effect

The decline in DVAR was not driven by a loss of firm profitability. Instead, fiscal centralization created a "crowding-out" effect. To meet the fiscal demands of local governments, firms increased their reliance on imported intermediate goods, which are often easier to scale quickly for volume, rather than investing in the domestic supply chain. Regression analysis confirmed a positive correlation (0.0615) between the reform and the input of imported intermediate goods.

This "quantity for quality" trade-off suggests that local officials, facing budget crunches, pass the burden to firms. This leads to short-sighted behavior where sustainable, long-term innovation is sacrificed for immediate fiscal returns. This impact was particularly pronounced in larger firms that rely more heavily on complex international supply chains.

Policy Implications and Conclusion

The study highlights a critical unintended consequence of fiscal centralization: the stifling of export quality. While the 2002 reform achieved central fiscal goals, it inadvertently trapped many firms at the lower end of the global value chain.

Future policy should focus on designing "neutral" tax-sharing arrangements that provide fiscal incentives for quality and innovation rather than raw industrial output. Ensuring that tax collection does not distort healthy firm behavior is essential for fostering a truly sustainable and innovative export economy.

Summary updated

Abstract

The fiscal imbalance between the central and local governments under fiscal centralization may motivate local governments to pass tax burdens on firms. The causal identification of the tax system reform and the sustainable export innovation behavior of firms are of great significance. This study uses the income tax sharing policy of China to examine the impact of fiscal centralization on the sustainable export innovation behavior of firms. We find that this tax reform has significantly inhibited the increase of the export value-added rate of firms, and has an increasing trend with the share ratio between the Central Government and the local government. Moreover, this effect mainly comes from the crowding-out effect of imported intermediate goods on domestic intermediate goods. The tests show that the above conclusions are consistent with the general logic of local governments. When they face greater downward fiscal pressure, they will further pass the tax burden on local firms and force the firms to promote their export performance to expand the tax base. This short-sighted behavior of replacing "quality improvement" with "quantity increase" is an important factor that affects the sustainable export innovation behavior of firms and the climb in the global value chain.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{feng2021sustainable,
  author = {Chen Feng and Beibei Shi and Hong Yan and Siying Yang and Caiquan Bai},
  title = {{Sustainable Export Innovation Behavior of Firms Under Fiscal Incentive}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2021.769795},
}
Figure