Sustainable and Surfactant-Free Synthesis of Negatively Charged Acrylamide Nanogels for Biomedical Applications

Davide Mazzali, Gabriela Rath, Alexander Röntgen, Vaidehi Roy Chowdhury, Michele Vendruscolo, Marina Resmini

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a greener, surfactant-free method for synthesizing negatively charged acrylamide nanogels in water, a significant step towards sustainable and scalable production for biomedical applications like drug delivery. This water-based approach not only reduces environmental impact but also leads to nanogels with improved properties, including better control over size and charge, and importantly, demonstrated no significant toxicity in preliminary cell studies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The development of advanced drug delivery systems is crucial for improving therapeutic efficacy and patient outcomes. Nanogels (NGs) are a promising class of nanomaterials for this purpose due to their high surface-area-to-volume ratio, tunable properties, and ability to encapsulate and release drugs in a controlled manner. However, many existing methods for synthesizing NGs, particularly those requiring precise control over size and charge, rely on organic solvents and surfactants. This poses challenges for large-scale production, increases costs, and can introduce potential toxicity concerns, hindering their translation to clinical applications. The authors address the need for more sustainable, cost-effective, and environmentally friendly synthesis routes for NGs, specifically focusing on negatively charged variants for biomedical use.

Methods

The core of this work is the High-Dilution Radical Polymerization (HDRP) technique, adapted for a water-based synthesis. HDRP is a homogeneous polymerization method that avoids the need for surfactants by carefully controlling monomer concentration to prevent the formation of large, insoluble gels.

Key aspects of their methodology include:

  • Surfactant-Free Synthesis: This is a major departure from many conventional nanogel synthesis methods that rely on surfactants to stabilize particles.
  • Water as a Solvent: The study directly compares synthesis in water versus dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), a common organic solvent for such polymerizations, to evaluate the impact of solvent choice on nanogel properties.
  • Tunable Negative Charge: The researchers incorporated acryloyl-L-proline (A-Pro-OH), a functional monomer, in varying amounts (2.5-15 mol%) to introduce a negative charge and explore its effect on nanogel characteristics.
  • Characterization Techniques: A suite of analytical tools was employed:
  • ¹H NMR Spectroscopy: To quantify monomer conversion and chemical yield, ensuring consistency between formulation and the final polymer.
  • Dynamic Light Scattering (DLS): To measure hydrodynamic diameter (Dh) and polydispersity index (PDI), providing insights into particle size distribution and uniformity.
  • Zeta-Potential Analysis: To determine the surface charge of the nanogels, crucial for understanding their behavior in biological environments.
  • Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) and Cryo-TEM: To visualize the nanogels directly and confirm their morphology and size.
  • MTT Assay: To assess the acute cytotoxicity of the synthesized nanogels on a human neuroblastoma cell line (SH-SY5Y).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on the synthesis and characterization of novel materials rather than training or evaluating on existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Water is a Viable and Superior Solvent: The shift from DMSO to water significantly improved chemical yields, especially for negatively charged nanogels. This highlights water's potential as a "greener" and more efficient solvent for this type of polymerization.
  • Negative Charge Influences Morphology: The introduction of A-Pro-OH led to smaller particle sizes in water, attributed to electrostatic repulsion between the negatively charged polymer chains. This offers a way to tune nanogel size through chemical modification.
  • Improved Polydispersity in Water: Nanogels synthesized in water exhibited lower polydispersity indices (PDI) compared to those made in DMSO. This suggests a more uniform particle size distribution, which is beneficial for consistent performance and scalability.
  • Surfactant-Free HDRP is Scalable: The success of this surfactant-free HDRP in water points towards a more scalable and cost-effective manufacturing process for nanogels, reducing purification steps and potential waste.
  • Biocompatibility is Promising: The nanogels demonstrated no significant reduction in cell viability, even at high concentrations, indicating their potential safety for biomedical applications.

Key Results

  • High Monomer Conversions and Chemical Yields: All formulations achieved high monomer conversions (>80%). Water-based synthesis generally led to higher chemical yields, particularly with the inclusion of A-Pro-OH.
  • Particle Size Control:
    • In DMSO, nanogels consistently had a hydrodynamic diameter (Dh) of around 10 nm, regardless of A-Pro-OH content.
  • In water, the neutral nanogel was larger (~58 nm), but the negatively charged nanogels were significantly smaller (~20 nm), with this effect not being concentration-dependent.
  • Lower Polydispersity in Water: Water-synthesized nanogels showed significantly lower PDI values than DMSO-synthesized ones.
  • Surface Charge Tuning: Zeta-potential measurements showed that water-based NGs with 15 mol% A-Pro-OH had a more negative surface charge (~-30 mV) compared to DMSO-based ones (~-25 mV), and this charge showed a negative correlation with A-Pro-OH content in water.
  • No Significant Cytotoxicity: MTT assays indicated that the nanogels were non-toxic to SH-SY5Y cells at concentrations up to 1 mg/mL, regardless of the synthetic solvent or A-Pro-OH content.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited A-Pro-OH Concentration Range: While the study explored A-Pro-OH from 2.5 to 15 mol%, further investigation into higher concentrations might reveal more nuanced effects on properties and stability.
  • In Vitro Cytotoxicity Only: The current study focuses on acute cytotoxicity in a single cell line. Future work should include studies on other cell types and, crucially, in vivo studies to assess the overall biocompatibility and efficacy of these nanogels for drug delivery.
  • Mechanism of Solvent Effect: While the authors propose explanations for the solvent effects on reactivity and morphology, further detailed mechanistic studies could provide deeper insights.
  • Drug Loading and Release Studies: The paper demonstrates the synthesis of suitable nanogels, but direct studies on their drug loading capacity and controlled release profiles are the logical next step for validating their drug delivery potential.

The authors suggest that this greener, surfactant-free HDRP in water provides a robust platform for developing negatively charged nanogels for various applications, particularly in biomedicine, paving the way for more sustainable and scalable nanomaterial production.

Summary updated

Abstract

Nanogels offer unique advantages, like high surface-to-volume ratio, scalable synthetic methods, and easily tailored formulations, that allow us to control size and introduce stimuli-responsive properties. Their potential for drug delivery is significant due to their biocompatibility, high drug loading capacity, and controlled and sustained drug release. The development of greener and sustainable processes is essential for large-scale applications. We report the synthesis in water of covalently cross-linked acrylamide-based nanogels, both neutral and negatively charged, with varying amounts of acryloyl-l-proline, using high-dilution radical polymerization, without the need for surfactants. The use of a water-based synthesis resulted in nanogels with high monomer conversions and chemical yields, as well as lower polydispersity and smaller particle sizes for the negatively charged nanogels, leading to a more efficient synthetic methodology, with reduced loss of starting materials, higher potential for scalability, and reduction in costs. The suitability of these nanogels for biomedical applications was supported by cytotoxicity studies showing no significant reduction in viability on a human neuroblastoma cell line.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mazzali2025sustainable,
  author = {Davide Mazzali and Gabriela Rath and Alexander Röntgen and Vaidehi Roy Chowdhury and Michele Vendruscolo and Marina Resmini},
  title = {{Sustainable and Surfactant-Free Synthesis of Negatively Charged Acrylamide Nanogels for Biomedical Applications}},
  booktitle = {Macromolecules},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.macromol.4c02128},
}
Figure