TL;DR
This paper introduces SURGE, a comprehensive benchmark designed to evaluate Large Language Models (LLMs) as general-purpose surrogate code executors. By systematically testing LLMs on a diverse set of 1160 problems across 8 key aspects of code execution, the authors reveal both the promising potential and current limitations of these models in this domain.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Predicting the outcome of code execution without actually running the code has significant implications across various fields. In scientific computing, it can save substantial computational resources. In security, it offers a way to assess untrusted code without risk. For complex software development, it can aid in debugging and understanding program behavior. While LLMs have shown remarkable capabilities in code-related tasks like understanding and generation, their potential as general-purpose surrogate code executors – models that can predict execution results – remains largely unexplored. Existing methods struggle with scalability and language generality, leaving a gap for a systematic evaluation of LLMs in this critical area.
Methods
The authors introduce SURGE, a novel benchmark comprising 1160 problems across 8 distinct categories: multi-language programming tasks, competition-level programming, repository-level code analysis, scientific computing, time-complexity-intensive algorithms, buggy code analysis, compiler/environment-dependent programs, and formal mathematical proof verification.
The benchmark construction involved four methodologies:
- Iterative Refactor: For multi-language (ML), competition-level (CL), and buggy code (BG) components, code was refined through LLM assistance and human verification.
- Repository Sampling: For repository-level (RL) code, test cases were extracted from public and custom code repositories.
- Manual Implementation: For scientific computing (SC), time-consuming algorithms (TC), and differential results (DR) components, code was handcrafted based on textbook materials and existing problem sets.
- Inference & Verification: For formal mathematics (FL), formal proof assistants were used to generate proofs and validate them.
To ensure data integrity, a two-fold sanitization strategy was employed: automated filtering of comments and manual inspection to remove any hints of expected outputs.
Datasets
The paper introduces SURGE, a new benchmark consisting of 1160 problems. It is divided into 8 subsets:
- Multi-lingual Code (ML): 150 problems across 7 languages (C, C++, Java, Rust, Python, Julia, C#).
- Competition-level Code (CL): Problems from platforms like LeetCode, categorized by difficulty.
- Repository-level Code (RL): Tasks from real-world code repositories.
- Scientific Computing (SC): Problems involving ODEs, optimization, and signal processing.
- Time-Consuming Algorithms (TC): Examples from linear algebra, sorting, searching, Monte Carlo simulations, and string matching.
- Buggy Code (BG): Adapted from DebugBench, with manually inserted errors.
- Code with Differential Results (DR): Code exhibiting different behaviors under varying compiler versions, standards, or optimization levels.
- Mathematics Formal Language (FL): Proof verification tasks in Lean4.
Key Insights and Ideas
- LLMs show promise but aren't perfect executors: While LLMs can approximate code execution, they are not exact executors. They often struggle with edge cases, intricate runtime behaviors, and execution-dependent state changes, highlighting that they are sophisticated reasoners rather than true compilers.
- Model size matters, but not always: Larger models generally perform better, but surprisingly, smaller models sometimes outperform larger ones on specific tasks (e.g., FL). This suggests that "overthinking" by larger models can lead to errors in complex reasoning.
- Prompting strategies significantly impact performance: Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting consistently improves performance, especially for code execution surrogacy. However, few-shot learning can sometimes degrade performance, particularly on tasks with high variability like buggy code.
- Language nuances affect LLM performance: LLMs perform better on languages with simpler syntax (like Python) and struggle with languages that have stricter rules or complex memory management (like Rust).
- Computational complexity is a major hurdle: As the actual execution time of a program increases, LLM prediction accuracy drops significantly, with state-of-the-art models failing to obtain correct answers for tasks exceeding 1 second of execution time.
Key Results
The paper evaluates 21 open-source and proprietary LLMs on SURGE. While the strongest models achieve only moderate performance, the benchmark demonstrates strong discriminative ability, highlighting significant performance differences across subsets and models. For instance, models that perform well on other tasks also show substantial results on SURGE, validating the benchmark's design. The study also found that increasing model size and training steps consistently improves performance, aligning with established scaling laws.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- LLMs are approximators, not exact executors, and struggle with edge cases and dynamic behaviors.
- The benchmark doesn't cover all specialized environments (e.g., hardware-dependent simulations).
- LLMs can generate plausible but incorrect outputs, especially with complex dependencies.
- Scaling studies were constrained by computational resources.
- Security risks remain, as LLMs might fail to recognize vulnerabilities.
- The controlled setting of the benchmark doesn't fully capture real-world dynamic development.
Future work should focus on improving LLMs' reasoning abilities, enhancing robustness in execution prediction, and integrating them with traditional program analysis techniques for practical deployment.
Summary updated