Suppressing Coherent Two-Qubit Errors via Dynamical Decoupling

Jiawei Qiu, Yuxuan Zhou, Chang-Kang Hu, Jiahao Yuan, Libo Zhang, Ji Chu, Wenhui Huang, Weiyang Liu, Kai Luo, Zhongchu Ni, Xianchuang Pan, Zhixuan Yang, Yimeng Zhang, Yuanzhen Chen, Xiu–Hao Deng, Ling Hu, Jian Li, Jingjing Niu, Yuan Xu, Tongxing Yan, Youpeng Zhong, Song Liu, Fei Yan, Dapeng Yu

Abstract

Scalable quantum information processing requires the ability to tune multi-qubit interactions. This makes the precise manipulation of quantum states particularly difficult for multi-qubit interactions because tunability unavoidably introduces sensitivity to fluctuations in the tuned parameters, leading to erroneous multi-qubit gate operations. The performance of quantum algorithms may be severely compromised by coherent multi-qubit errors. It is therefore imperative to understand how these fluctuations affect multi-qubit interactions and, more importantly, to mitigate their influence. In this study, we demonstrate how to implement dynamical-decoupling techniques to suppress the two-qubit analogue of the dephasing on a superconducting quantum device featuring a compact tunable coupler, a trending technology that enables the fast manipulation of qubit--qubit interactions. The pure-dephasing time shows an up to ~14 times enhancement on average when using robust sequences. The results are in good agreement with the noise generated from room-temperature circuits. Our study further reveals the decohering processes associated with tunable couplers and establishes a framework to develop gates and sequences robust against two-qubit errors.

Introduction

To build a scalable quantum computer, interactions between qubits must be toggled with high precision. Superconducting circuits frequently employ "tunable couplers" to achieve this. However, tunability introduces a significant trade-off: sensitivity to environmental fluctuations. Specifically, these couplers are susceptible to "flux noise"—tiny magnetic fluctuations that cause interaction strengths to wobble. This leads to swap-dephasing, a coherent error where the quantum state drifts during two-qubit operations. While often overlooked by standard error-checking, these drifts accumulate in long algorithms, eventually compromising computational fidelity.

Methods

Hardware Architecture

The experimental setup consists of two Xmon qubits ($Q_1$ and $Q_2$) connected via a compact tunable coupler ($C$), which is essentially a split transmon. This architecture allows for continuous tuning of the qubit-qubit interaction strength ($g$).

Device architecture featuring two qubits and a tunable coupler.

The g-frame Qubit Concept

The core innovation of this work is the implementation of the "g-frame" qubit. The researchers focused on the "one-excitation subspace"—the state space where exactly one of the two qubits is excited. By mapping the $|01\rangle$ and $|10\rangle$ states to a virtual spin-1/2 system, they transformed a complex two-qubit interaction problem into a single-qubit control problem.

In this g-frame, the coupling strength ($g$) acts as a longitudinal magnetic field ($Z$), while the frequency detuning between the qubits acts as a transverse field ($X$). This mapping allows the application of well-established Dynamical Decoupling (DD) techniques from Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) to protect the two-qubit interaction.

Mapping of laboratory-frame qubit operations to the g-frame virtual qubit.

Dynamical Decoupling Sequences

With the interaction mapped to a virtual qubit, the team applied several DD sequences:

  • Ramsey and Spin-Echo: Basic refocusing techniques.
  • XY-4 and XY-8: Robust sequences using alternating pulses to cancel noise in multiple directions simultaneously.

Results

The application of robust DD sequences yielded significant improvements in coherence:

  • 14x Enhancement: The pure-dephasing time increased by an average factor of ~14 when using XY-8 sequences compared to free evolution.
  • Noise Source Identification: By testing different levels of attenuation (0 dB vs. 20 dB) at room temperature, the researchers identified that a major portion of decoherence originated from room-temperature electronics and ground loops rather than the quantum chip itself.
  • Model Validation: Experimental dephasing rates matched theoretical models based on measured noise power spectral density (PSD) from the control hardware, confirming the accuracy of the error mitigation framework.

Discussion and Future Work

While the results are promising, challenges remain for large-scale implementation. Residual low-frequency noise from ground loops persists even with high attenuation. Furthermore, scaling these sequences to processors with many tunable couplers will increase control complexity and potential crosstalk.

The next step in this research is to integrate these DD pulses directly into functional two-qubit logic gates, such as a "dynamically corrected" iSWAP gate, to enhance gate fidelity in practical quantum algorithms. This work establishes a vital framework for developing gates and sequences that are inherently robust against coherent two-qubit errors.

Summary updated

Abstract

Scalable quantum information processing requires the ability to tune multiqubit interactions. This makes the precise manipulation of quantum states particularly difficult for multiqubit interactions because tunability unavoidably introduces sensitivity to fluctuations in the tuning parameters, leading to erroneous multiqubit gate operations. The performance of quantum algorithms may be severely compromised by coherent multiqubit errors. It is therefore imperative to understand how these fluctuations affect multiqubit interactions and, more importantly, to mitigate their influence. In this study, we demonstrate how to implement dynamical-decoupling techniques to suppress the two-qubit analogue of the dephasing on a superconducting quantum device featuring a compact tunable coupler, a trending technology that enables the fast manipulation of qubit-qubit interactions. The pure-dephasing time shows up to an approximate 14 times enhancement on average when using robust sequences. The results are in good agreement with the noise generated from room-temperature circuits. Our study further reveals the decohering processes associated with tunable couplers and establishes a framework to develop gates and sequences robust against two-qubit errors.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{qiu2021suppressing,
  author = {Jiawei Qiu and Yuxuan Zhou and Chang-Kang Hu and Jiahao Yuan and Libo Zhang and Ji Chu and Wenhui Huang and Weiyang Liu and Kai Luo and Zhongchu Ni and Xianchuang Pan and Zhixuan Yang and Yimeng Zhang and Yuanzhen Chen and Xiu–Hao Deng and Ling Hu and Jian Li and Jingjing Niu and Yuan Xu and Tongxing Yan and Youpeng Zhong and Song Liu and Fei Yan and Dapeng Yu},
  title = {{Suppressing Coherent Two-Qubit Errors via Dynamical Decoupling}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevapplied.16.054047},
}
Figure