Supply chain management practices as a mediator of the relationship between operations capability and firm performance

Chin‐Chun Hsu, Kay Chen Tan, Vijay R. Kannan, G. Keong LeongInternational Journal of Production Research 2008 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how a firm's operational capabilities (new product design, just-in-time, and total quality management) influence its performance, with supply chain management practices acting as a potential bridge. The findings reveal that while new product design and just-in-time capabilities indirectly boost performance through supply chain management, total quality management has a more direct impact.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In today's competitive global market, firms strive for both low costs and high quality, a feat that increasingly relies on effective integration of operations across organizational boundaries. This integration is the core of supply chain management (SCM). However, many SCM initiatives fail to deliver expected results, suggesting a potential disconnect in understanding how a firm's internal "operations capabilities" (its ability to perform specific tasks efficiently and effectively) translate into overall business success. This paper aims to clarify this relationship by examining whether SCM practices act as a mediator, explaining how operations capabilities ultimately impact firm performance.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-phase statistical analysis:

  1. Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA): Used to validate the measurement models for each construct (operations capabilities, SCM practices, and firm performance).
  2. Three-Step Mediated Regression Analysis: This is the core of the analysis, following the established framework by Baron and Kenny (1986) to test for mediation.
  3. Step 1: Operations capabilities were regressed on SCM practices.
  4. Step 2: Operations capabilities were regressed on firm performance.
  5. Step 3: Firm performance was regressed simultaneously on both operations capabilities and SCM practices. Mediation is inferred if the relationship between operations capabilities and firm performance weakens when SCM practices are included in the model.

  6. Structural Equation Modeling (SEM): Used to simultaneously assess the psychometric properties of the scales and the relationships between all variables in the hypothesized model, providing a more holistic view.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized survey data collected from 4500 senior purchasing and operations managers.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • SCM as a Bridge, Not a Standalone Solution: The study highlights that SCM practices are not a magic bullet but rather a crucial mechanism through which certain operational capabilities can translate into better firm performance.
  • Differential Impact of Capabilities: Not all operational capabilities are equal in their influence. New product design and just-in-time capabilities seem to "work through" SCM, while total quality management appears to have a more direct line to performance.
  • The Importance of Internal Foundation: The findings suggest that firms need to develop strong internal operations capabilities before expecting them to effectively leverage SCM.
  • Why JIT Might Fail: The indirect effect of JIT through SCM helps explain why some JIT implementations don't yield expected results. Successful JIT often requires supplier collaboration, which is a core aspect of SCM.

Key Results

  • New Product Design & Development: Positively affects SCM practices (Hypothesis H1a supported) and has a direct positive effect on firm performance (Hypothesis H2a supported). It also has an indirect effect on firm performance through SCM.
  • Just-in-Time (JIT) Capability: Positively affects SCM practices (Hypothesis H1b supported). Crucially, it completely mediates the relationship between JIT capability and firm performance, meaning its impact on performance is entirely through SCM (Hypothesis H2b was not supported as a direct effect, but its indirect effect was confirmed).
  • Total Quality Management (TQM) Capability: Did not show a significant positive effect on SCM practices (Hypothesis H1c was not supported). However, TQM capability has a significant direct positive effect on firm performance (Hypothesis H2c supported).
  • SCM Practices: Positively affect firm performance (Hypothesis H3 supported).

The study found that SCM practices partially mediated the relationship between new product design and development capability and firm performance.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Single Performance Perspective: The model only considered one perspective of firm performance. Future research could incorporate multiple dimensions.
  • Cross-Sectional Data: The study used cross-sectional data, which limits the ability to establish definitive causation. Longitudinal data would be beneficial to track changes over time and better understand dynamic relationships.
  • Model Scope: The model did not account for variables from other disciplines like industrial organization (market structure), finance (ownership structure), or organizational behavior (corporate governance).
  • Limited Scope of TQM Measurement: The measures for TQM capability focused on internal initiatives and may not have fully captured boundary-spanning quality aspects (like supplier quality), which could explain its lack of mediation effect.

Future research directions include:

  • Exploring additional facets of operations capability, such as logistics and purchasing.
  • Using longitudinal data to establish clearer causal links.
  • Expanding the model to include a broader range of performance metrics and contextual variables.
  • Investigating the role of supplier-driven quality and customer focus in TQM.

Summary updated

Abstract

The current study uses mediated regression analysis and structural equation modeling to test the proposition that supply chain management practices mediate the relationship between operations capability and firm performance. Operations capability is defined in terms of a firm's new product design and development, total quality management and just-in-time capabilities. Results support the research model and also suggest the existence of a direct relationship between operations capability and performance.
BibTeX
@article{hsu2008supply,
  author = {Chin‐Chun Hsu and Kay Chen Tan and Vijay R. Kannan and G. Keong Leong},
  title = {{Supply chain management practices as a mediator of the relationship between operations capability and firm performance}},
  journal = {International Journal of Production Research},
  year = {2008},
  doi = {10.1080/00207540701452142},
}
Figure