Supplementary material to "Mixing layer height on the North China Plain and meteorologicalevidence of serious air pollution in southern Hebei"

Xiaowan Zhu, Guiqian Tang, Jianping Guo, Bo Hu, Tao Song, Lili Wang, Xin Jin, Wenkang Gao, Christoph Münkel, Klaus Schäfer, Xin Li, Yuesi Wang2017 · DOI

Introduction

Air quality in the North China Plain (NCP) is not solely determined by emission levels; it is heavily influenced by the volume of air available for pollutant dispersion. This volume is defined by the Mixing Layer Height (MLH). When the MLH is low, it acts as an atmospheric "lid," trapping pollutants near the ground in high concentrations. This research characterizes the seasonal and spatial variations of the MLH across the NCP to provide meteorological evidence for the severe pollution observed in cities like Shijiazhuang.

Methodology

The study employed high-resolution profiling techniques across several key stations, including Beijing (BJ), Shijiazhuang (SJZ), Tianjin (TJ), and Qinhuangdao (QHD). MLH was measured using Vaisala ceilometers (models CL31 and CL51), with validation steps ensuring consistency between different models. To understand atmospheric stability, the researchers analyzed horizontal wind speed profiles from the surface up to 2000 meters. These measurements were used to calculate the Ventilation Coefficient ($V_c$), a metric representing the atmosphere's ability to disperse pollutants.

Topographical and Spatial Dynamics

Spatial mapping of PM10 concentrations across more than 20 observation sites reveals a distinct "harbor" effect. High concentrations are frequently clustered against the Taihang and Yanshan Mountains. These mountain ranges act as physical barriers, trapping polluted air masses particularly when winds blow from the south or east.

PM10 distribution and topography in the North China Plain

Comparative Analysis of Pollution Drivers

A primary insight of this research is the meteorological disadvantage faced by Southern Hebei. Data highlights that Shijiazhuang (SJZ) consistently experiences lower MLH and lower ventilation coefficients than Beijing (BJ), indicating a naturally lower capacity for the atmosphere to "self-clean."

Annual mean meteorological parameters and ventilation coefficients across key stations

As shown in the table above, the annual mean Ventilation Coefficient ($V_c$) for Beijing is 3054.5 $m^2/s$, whereas for Shijiazhuang, it is approximately 33% lower at 2045.4 $m^2/s$. Additionally, SJZ recorded higher annual relative humidity (65.7%) compared to Beijing (51.2%), which facilitates the secondary formation of aerosols, further worsening visibility and PM levels.

Seasonal and Diurnal Variations

There is a stark seasonal contrast in atmospheric capacity. In winter, the mixing layer is significantly shallower across all stations, creating a persistent "lid" that explains why even moderate emissions can lead to severe smog events. For example, while Beijing's MLH peaks in summer at $722 \pm 169$ m, Shijiazhuang's winter average drops to a mere $347 \pm 153$ m. Diurnal wind profiles also show that atmospheric stability varies significantly between morning (08:00 LT) and evening (20:00 LT), with lower surface wind speeds in the morning further inhibiting early-day dispersion.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that lower MLH and poor ventilation coefficients are primary drivers for the extreme pollution levels observed in Southern Hebei. Future work integrating these high-resolution MLH measurements into real-time air quality forecasting models could significantly improve the accuracy of pollution warnings and public health alerts.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{zhu2017supplementary,
  author = {Xiaowan Zhu and Guiqian Tang and Jianping Guo and Bo Hu and Tao Song and Lili Wang and Xin Jin and Wenkang Gao and Christoph Münkel and Klaus Schäfer and Xin Li and Yuesi Wang},
  title = {{Supplementary material to "Mixing layer height on the North China Plain and meteorologicalevidence of serious air pollution in southern Hebei"}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-2017-295-supplement},
}
Figure