Mixing layer height on the North China Plain and meteorological evidence of serious air pollution in southern Hebei

Xiaowan Zhu, Guiqian Tang, Jianping Guo, Bo Hu, Tao Song, Lili Wang, Xin Jin, Wenkang Gao, Christoph Münkel, Klaus Schäfer, Xin Li, Yuesi WangAtmospheric 2018 · DOI

Abstract: This study investigates the spatiotemporal variability of the mixing layer height (MLH) across the North China Plain (NCP) using long-term ceilometer observations from October 2013 to July 2015. By comparing three inland stations (Beijing, Shijiazhuang, and Tianjin) and one coastal site (Qinhuangdao), researchers identified that southern Hebei (represented by Shijiazhuang) suffers from a significantly lower MLH and weaker ventilation capacity than the northern NCP. These unfavorable meteorological conditions, characterized by higher atmospheric stability and lower wind shear, act as a "trap" that concentrates pollutants near the surface, explaining the region's disproportionately severe air pollution.

Introduction

The North China Plain (NCP) is one of the most densely populated and industrially active regions in the world, frequently experiencing severe haze episodes. While emission reduction strategies are central to air quality management, the role of the planetary boundary layer, specifically the mixing layer height (MLH), is a critical factor in determining ground-level pollutant concentrations. The MLH defines the volume of air available for the dispersion of surface-emitted pollutants. This study provides high-resolution, continuous observations to explain why southern Hebei consistently experiences worse air quality than neighboring regions.

Map of observation sites and annual mean PM2.5 concentrations across the North China Plain.

Methodology

A network of four observation sites was established: Beijing (BJ), Shijiazhuang (SJZ), and Tianjin (TJ) as inland representatives, and Qinhuangdao (QHD) as a coastal site. Vaisala CL31 and CL51 single-lens ceilometers were used to measure aerosol backscatter profiles. The MLH was retrieved using the gradient method, identifying the sharpest drop in aerosol concentration. To analyze atmospheric stability, the gradient Richardson number ($Ri$) was calculated from radiosonde data, and the ventilation coefficient ($V_c$)—the product of MLH and wind speed—was used to assess the atmosphere's dispersive capacity.

Spatiotemporal Variability of MLH

The study revealed distinct seasonal and regional patterns. Inland sites (BJ, SJZ, TJ) generally followed a pattern of highest MLH in summer and lowest in winter. However, the coastal site (QHD) showed a unique trend, with the lowest MLH occurring in summer due to the formation of a stable Thermal Internal Boundary Layer (TIBL) from cool sea breezes.

Crucially, Shijiazhuang (SJZ) exhibited the lowest annual mean MLH at 464 ± 183 m, which was 15.0% lower than Beijing (594 m) and 21.9% lower than Tianjin (546 m). This "squeezing" effect is most pronounced outside of the summer months, significantly reducing the volume for pollutant dilution in southern Hebei.

Monthly variations of MLH at the four stations, highlighting the consistently lower values in Shijiazhuang (SJZ).

Meteorological Drivers of Pollution

The disparity in air quality between the northern and southern NCP cannot be explained by emissions alone. While the total pollutant column (AOD) in the south was only 1.2 times higher than in the north, ground-level $PM_{2.5}$ was 1.5 times higher. Stability analysis showed that in winter, southern Hebei experiences wind shear 2.8 times lower and buoyancy 1.5 times higher than the northern NCP. This leads to a nearly twofold increase in the frequency of stable atmospheric conditions ($Ri > 1$), effectively capping the region and preventing vertical mixing. Furthermore, the ventilation coefficient at SJZ was consistently the lowest, often 1.5 times smaller than at BJ or QHD.

Conclusion

The severe air pollution in southern Hebei is driven by a combination of high emissions and inherently unfavorable meteorological conditions. The consistently lower MLH and stagnant air in this region act as a bottleneck for pollutant dispersion. Consequently, air quality targets in southern Hebei require more aggressive emission reductions than in the northern NCP. The study suggests that relocating heavily polluting industries to areas with better natural ventilation is a necessary step for long-term regional air quality improvement.

Summary updated

Abstract

To investigate the spatiotemporal variability of the mixing layer height (MLH) on the North China Plain (NCP), multi-site and long-term observations of the MLH with ceilometers at three inland stations (Beijing, BJ; Shijiazhuang, SJZ; Tianjin, TJ) and one coastal site (Qinhuangdao) were conducted from 16 October 2013 to 15 July 2015. The MLH of the inland stations in the NCP were highest in summer and lowest in winter, while the MLH on the coastal area of Bohai was lowest in summer and highest in spring. As a typical site in southern Hebei, the annual mean of the MLH at SJZ was 464 ± 183 m, which was 15.0 and 21.9 % lower than that at the BJ (594 ± 183 m) and TJ (546 ± 197 m) stations, respectively. Investigation of the shear term and buoyancy term in the NCP revealed that these two parameters in southern Hebei were 2.8 times lower and 1.5 times higher than that in northern NCP within 0–1200 m in winter, respectively, leading to a 1.9-fold higher frequency of the gradient Richardson number > 1 in southern Hebei compared to the northern NCP. Furthermore, combined with aerosol optical depth and PM2.5 observations, we found that the pollutant column concentration contrast (1.2 times) between these two areas was far less than the near-ground PM2.5 concentration contrast (1.5 times). Through analysis of the ventilation coefficient in the NCP, the near-ground heavy pollution in southern Hebei mainly resulted from the lower MLH and wind speed. Therefore, due to the importance of unfavorable weather conditions, heavily polluting enterprises should be relocated and strong emission reduction measures should be introduced to improve the air quality in southern Hebei.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhu2018mixing,
  author = {Xiaowan Zhu and Guiqian Tang and Jianping Guo and Bo Hu and Tao Song and Lili Wang and Xin Jin and Wenkang Gao and Christoph Münkel and Klaus Schäfer and Xin Li and Yuesi Wang},
  title = {{Mixing layer height on the North China Plain and meteorological evidence of serious air pollution in southern Hebei}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-18-4897-2018},
}
Figure