Superspace expansion of the 11D linearized superfields in the pure spinor formalism, and the covariant vertex operator

Maor Ben-Shahar, Max Guillen

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of efficiently calculating scattering amplitudes in 11D supergravity using the pure spinor formalism. The authors derive systematic methods to expand the necessary superfields and construct a novel, fully covariant vertex operator for 11D supergravity, which reproduces known results in a specific gauge.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Calculating scattering amplitudes in quantum field theories is a cornerstone of theoretical physics. For supergravity theories, especially in higher dimensions like 11D, these calculations can become extremely complex. The "pure spinor formalism" offers a promising avenue for a manifestly supersymmetric and covariant description of 11D supergravity, which is crucial for these amplitude calculations. However, a significant hurdle has been the lack of efficient tools to manipulate the fundamental building blocks of this formalism: the linearized 11D supergravity superfields. Specifically, their full "superspace expansions" (how they behave as a function of the fermionic coordinates, denoted by $\theta$) were not well-understood, hindering practical applications like constructing vertex operators for amplitude computations. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing these expansions and using them to build a covariant vertex operator.

Methods

The core of the paper's methodology lies in two main parts:

  1. Superspace Expansions: The authors employ a technique using "Harnad-Shnider-like gauges." These are specific choices of gauge freedom that simplify the equations of motion for the linearized 11D supergravity superfields. By exploiting these simplified equations, they derive recursive relations. These relations allow them to systematically determine the coefficients of the $\theta$-expansion for all the relevant superfields, order by order in $\theta$. This is a novel approach to obtaining these expansions in a controlled and systematic manner.
  2. Covariant Vertex Operator Construction: Building upon the derived superspace expansions, the authors introduce an "11D analogue of the 10D ABC superparticle." This new object serves as a foundation for constructing a "fully covariant vertex operator." This operator is built using only supersymmetric quantities and the linearized superfields. A key achievement is demonstrating that this covariant operator, when subjected to specific "light-cone gauge" conditions, precisely matches the previously established Green-Gutperle-Kwon vertex operators.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. This paper focuses on theoretical developments and does not involve empirical datasets or benchmarks in the traditional sense.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Systematic $\theta$-Expansions: The derivation of recursive relations for the superspace expansions of linearized 11D supergravity superfields is a significant technical achievement. This provides a concrete and calculable framework for working with these fields.
  • Bridging Covariance and Gauge: The construction of a covariant vertex operator that can be shown to reproduce gauge-fixed operators is a crucial step. It demonstrates that the underlying covariant formulation is consistent with known results in specific, calculable gauges.
  • 11D ABC Superparticle Analogue: Introducing an 11D version of the ABC superparticle provides a new tool for exploring 11D supergravity within the pure spinor framework, potentially opening up new avenues for research.
  • Connection to Existing Results: The successful reproduction of the Green-Gutperle-Kwon operators is a strong validation of their methods and the covariant vertex operator construction.

Key Results

  • The paper provides the complete set of superspace expansions for the linearized 11D supergravity superfields, derived from recursive relations obtained in specific gauges.
  • A novel, fully covariant vertex operator for 11D supergravity is constructed using these superfields.
  • It is shown that this covariant vertex operator reduces to the Green-Gutperle-Kwon operators in the light-cone gauge, confirming its correctness and utility.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: While the paper provides a systematic method, the full $\theta$-expansions can become very lengthy and complex, as hinted by the extensive formulas for example expansions.
  • Future Applications: The authors explicitly state their intention to use these results for computing three-particle scattering amplitudes with manifest supersymmetry. They also plan to explore the construction of new pure spinor twistor transforms and extend their methods to handle an arbitrary number of external bosonic and fermionic states.
  • Further Investigation of ABC Superparticle: The paper suggests exploring the covariant quantization of the 11D ABC superparticle and its potential modifications to ensure it reproduces the correct physical degrees of freedom of 11D supergravity, drawing parallels with similar issues in 10D.
  • Ghost Sector: The paper highlights the importance of understanding the ghost sector of the pure spinor formalism, particularly for ghost number zero vertex operators, and suggests this as a future research direction.

Summary updated

Abstract

A bstract 11D pure spinors have been shown to successfully describe 11D supergravity in a manifestly super-Poincaré covariant manner. The feasibility of its actual usage for scattering amplitude computations requires an efficient manipulation of the superfields defining linearized 11D supergravity. In this paper, we directly address this problem by finding the superspace expansions of these superfields, at all orders in θ , from recursive relations their equations of motion obey in Harnad-Shnider-like gauges. After introducing the 11D analogue of the 10D $$ \mathcal{ABC} $$ <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML"> <mml:mi>ABC</mml:mi> </mml:math> superparticle, we construct, for the first time, a fully covariant vertex operator for 11D supergravity by making use of the linearized 11D superfields. Notably, we show that this vertex reproduces the Green-Gutperle-Kwon 11D operators in light-cone gauge.
BibTeX
@article{benshahar2023superspace,
  author = {Maor Ben-Shahar and Max Guillen},
  title = {{Superspace expansion of the 11D linearized superfields in the pure spinor formalism, and the covariant vertex operator}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep09(2023)018},
}
Figure