Superconductivity in TlBi$_2$ with a large Kadowaki-Woods ratio

Zhihua Yang, Zhen Yang, Qi-Ping Su, Jianhua Du, Enda Fang, Chuxiang Wu, Jinhu Yang, Bin Chen, Hangdong Wang, Minghu Fang

TL;DR

Researchers have characterized the superconducting and normal states of $\text{TlBi}_2$, a structural analog to the famous high-$T_C$ superconductor $\text{MgB}_2$. While it is a conventional phonon-mediated superconductor ($T_C = 6.2\text{ K}$), it exhibits an unexpectedly large Kadowaki-Woods ratio—nearly ten times higher than typical heavy-fermion compounds—suggesting a complex interplay between electrons and phonons that challenges standard expectations for this class of materials.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The discovery of superconductivity in $\text{MgB}_2$ at $39\text{ K}$ sparked intense interest in materials with the $\text{AlB}_2$-type hexagonal structure. $\text{TlBi}_2$ shares this structure but replaces light boron with heavy bismuth and thallium. While it was identified as a superconductor decades ago, its detailed physical properties remained largely unexplored.

The authors sought to determine if $\text{TlBi}_2$ follows the standard Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) model of superconductivity and to investigate its "normal state" (the state above $T_C$). Specifically, they looked at the relationship between its electrical resistivity and its heat capacity—a relationship captured by the Kadowaki-Woods ratio (KWR), which typically serves as a signature of how strongly electrons interact with one another.

Methods

The team synthesized high-quality polycrystalline $\text{TlBi}_2$ samples using a vacuum-sealed quartz tube melting and annealing process. They then employed a suite of standard condensed matter characterization techniques:

  • X-ray Diffraction (XRD): To confirm the crystal structure and phase purity.
  • Resistivity and Hall Effect Measurements: Using a standard four-probe technique to study electron transport.
  • Magnetization Measurements: To determine critical magnetic fields and confirm Type-II superconductivity.
  • Specific Heat Measurements: Using the relaxation method to probe the electronic and lattice contributions to the material's energy.

Datasets

This is an experimental physics paper; it does not use external machine learning datasets. The primary data generated includes temperature-dependent resistivity curves, magnetic susceptibility loops, and specific heat capacity data, which are compared against theoretical models like the Ginzburg-Landau theory and the Bloch-Grüneisen formula.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Strong Coupling Superconductivity: $\text{TlBi}_2$ is not a "weak" superconductor. Its electron-phonon coupling constant ($\lambda_{ep} = 1.38$) and superconducting gap ratio ($\Delta_0/k_BT_C = 2.25$) are significantly higher than the standard BCS limits ($1.76$ for the gap ratio). This classifies it as a strong-coupling, $s$-wave superconductor.
  • The KWR Anomaly: The most striking finding is the Kadowaki-Woods ratio ($A/\gamma^2$). In many "heavy fermion" materials (where electrons act as if they have huge masses due to correlations), this ratio is roughly $1.0 \times 10^{-5} \mu\Omega \text{ cm(mol K}^2/\text{mJ})^2$. In $\text{TlBi}_2$, the ratio is $9.2 \times 10^{-5}$—nearly an order of magnitude larger—despite the material not having particularly strong electron-electron correlations.
  • Transport Transition: The material shows a transition from unusual $T$-linear resistivity (common in high-temperature superconductors) above $50\text{ K}$ to a $T^2$ "Fermi-liquid" behavior below $20\text{ K}$.

Key Results

  • Superconducting Transition: Bulk superconductivity emerges at $T_C = 6.2\text{ K}$.
  • Critical Fields: The upper critical field ($\mu_0H_{c2}$) is $1.4\text{ T}$, and the lower critical field ($\mu_0H_{c1}$) is $108\text{ Oe}$.
  • Classification: Confirmed as a Type-II superconductor with a Ginzburg-Landau parameter $\kappa_{GL} = 12.9$.
  • Specific Heat Jump: The normalized electronic specific heat jump $\Delta C_{es}/\gamma T_C$ is $2.32$, much larger than the BCS value of $1.43$, further proving strong coupling.
  • Carrier Type: Hall effect measurements indicate that the dominant charge carriers are electrons.

Limitations and Future Work

The study was performed on polycrystalline samples. While the results are robust, the authors note that single-crystal samples would allow for a better understanding of directional (anisotropic) properties, especially given the layered hexagonal structure.

The exact mechanism behind the "unexpectedly large" Kadowaki-Woods ratio remains a subject of debate. The authors suggest it might stem from strong dynamical coupling between conduction electrons and low-energy phonons, but they conclude that $\text{TlBi}_2$ provides a "novel material platform" for theorists to investigate why certain conventional superconductors mimic the transport signatures of much more exotic materials.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this article, the superconducting and normal state properties of TlBi$_2$ with the AlB$_2$-type structure were studied by the resistivity, magnetization and specific heat measurements. It was found that bulk superconductivity with $T_{C}$ = 6.2 K emerges in TlBi$_2$, which is a phonon-mediated $s$-wave superconductor with a strong electron-phonon coupling ($λ$$_{ep}$ = 1.38) and a large superconducting gap ($Δ_{0}$/$k_{B}T_{C}$ = 2.25). We found that the $ρ$($T$) exhibits an unusual $T$-linear dependence above 50 K, and can be well described by the Fermi-liquid theory below 20 K. Interestingly, its Kadowaki-Woods ratio $A/γ^{2}$ [9.2$\times$10$^{-5}$ $μΩ$ cm(mol K$^{2}$/mJ)$^{2}$] is unexpectedly one order of magnitude larger than that obtained in many heavy Fermi compounds, although the electron correlation is not so strong.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2022superconductivity,
  author = {Zhihua Yang and Zhen Yang and Qi-Ping Su and Jianhua Du and Enda Fang and Chuxiang Wu and Jinhu Yang and Bin Chen and Hangdong Wang and Minghu Fang},
  title = {{Superconductivity in TlBi$\_2$ with a large Kadowaki-Woods ratio}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.106.224501},
}
Figure