Superconductivity and non-Fermi liquid behavior near a nematic quantum critical point

Samuel Lederer, Yoni Schattner, Erez Berg, Steven A. KivelsonProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses advanced quantum Monte Carlo simulations to study a model of electrons interacting with a nematic (crystal lattice distortion) instability. They discover that near this instability, superconductivity emerges in a broad dome, and the electrons exhibit unusual "non-Fermi liquid" behavior, including a "bad metal" state with a resistivity that scales linearly with temperature.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The study of quantum critical points (QCPs) in metals is challenging because superconductivity often preempts the observation of true quantum critical behavior. This paper investigates a model that exhibits a nematic QCP, a type of electronic instability that breaks the rotational symmetry of the crystal lattice. The authors aim to understand how the fluctuations associated with this nematic QCP influence the electronic properties, particularly superconductivity and the emergence of non-Fermi liquid behavior, which deviates from the standard understanding of metallic behavior. This is particularly relevant as nematic QCPs are suspected to play a role in the superconductivity of iron-based superconductors.

Methods

The researchers employed determinantal quantum Monte Carlo (DQMC) simulations, a powerful numerical technique for studying strongly correlated quantum systems. They simulated a 2D lattice model of itinerant electrons coupled to an Ising-like nematic order parameter. By tuning a parameter (h) in the Hamiltonian, they could drive the system through a quantum phase transition from a symmetric (disordered) phase to a nematic (ordered) phase. They analyzed various quantities, including the superconducting transition temperature ($T_c$), the electron spectral function, the fermion self-energy, and the current-current correlation function, to probe the system's behavior. For transport properties, they used analytic continuation of imaginary time data and resistivity proxies to estimate the DC resistivity.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on numerical simulations of a theoretical model, not experimental datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Superconductivity near a Nematic QCP: The nematic fluctuations in the model are found to induce superconductivity, forming a broad dome where $T_c$ is maximized at the nematic QCP. This suggests that nematicity can be a fertile ground for superconductivity.
  • "Nodal-Antinodal Dichotomy": Above the superconducting dome, the electron spectral function exhibits a striking "nodal-antinodal dichotomy." This means that some parts of the Fermi surface (nodal regions) retain well-defined quasiparticle-like features, while others (antinodal regions) become strongly incoherent, losing their clear dispersion. This is reminiscent of behavior seen in some high-temperature superconductors.
  • "Bad Metal" Phenomenology: The critical fluctuations associated with the nematic QCP lead to a breakdown of Fermi liquid theory. The optical conductivity and estimated DC resistivity show behavior consistent with "bad metal" phenomenology, characterized by a resistivity that is anomalously large and approximately linear in temperature near the QCP.
  • Robustness of Nematic Fluctuations: The nematic fluctuations are shown to significantly impact the electronic properties even away from the strict critical point, acting as an organizing principle for the material's behavior.

Key Results

  • A broad superconducting dome was found, with its maximum $T_c$ occurring at the nematic quantum critical point ($h=h_c$). The maximum $T_c$ was found to be around $0.03E_F$.
  • The fermion self-energy, particularly in the antinodal regions, shows a strong deviation from Fermi liquid behavior, with its imaginary part not vanishing as temperature approaches zero.
  • Resistivity proxies, derived from the current-current correlation function, show a roughly linear dependence on temperature near the nematic QCP, exceeding the Ioffe-Regel limit of $\hbar/e^2$ for stronger couplings.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Corrections to Scaling: The authors acknowledge that the regime accessed in their simulations might not be truly asymptotic to the QCP, meaning corrections to scaling could be significant.
  • Analytic Continuation Ambiguity: The analytic continuation of imaginary time data to real frequencies is a notoriously ill-posed problem. While they used multiple methods (fitting and maximum entropy) and found qualitative agreement, quantitative differences can arise, and the presence of additional spectral features (like a narrow peak) cannot be definitively ruled out.
  • Model Simplification: The model is a simplified representation of real materials. It ignores certain microscopic details and potential effects like strong electron-electron interactions beyond the nematic coupling.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring the behavior at lower fermionic densities and investigating the possibility of a weakly first-order nematic transition at low temperatures for certain coupling strengths. Further investigation into the emergence of approximate conserved momentum, which could lead to a sharp Fermi surface and affect resistivity proxies, is also suggested.

Summary updated

Abstract

Using determinantal quantum Monte Carlo, we compute the properties of a lattice model with spin [Formula: see text] itinerant electrons tuned through a quantum phase transition to an Ising nematic phase. The nematic fluctuations induce superconductivity with a broad dome in the superconducting [Formula: see text] enclosing the nematic quantum critical point. For temperatures above [Formula: see text], we see strikingly non-Fermi liquid behavior, including a "nodal-antinodal dichotomy" reminiscent of that seen in several transition metal oxides. In addition, the critical fluctuations have a strong effect on the low-frequency optical conductivity, resulting in behavior consistent with "bad metal" phenomenology.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lederer2017superconductivity,
  author = {Samuel Lederer and Yoni Schattner and Erez Berg and Steven A. Kivelson},
  title = {{Superconductivity and non-Fermi liquid behavior near a nematic quantum critical point}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.1620651114},
}
Figure