Abstract
Exploring new unconventional superconductors is of great value for both fundamental research and practical applications. It is a long-term challenge to develop and study more hole-doped superconductors in 1111 system of iron-based superconductors. Here we report the discovery of superconductivity with a critical transition temperature up to 30.7 K in the compound CaFeAsF by a post-annealing treatment in air atmosphere. The superconducting behaviors are verified in both the single-crystalline and polycrystalline samples by the resistance and magnetization measurements. The analysis by combining the depth-resolved time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (TOF-SIMS) and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) measurements shows that the introduction of oxygen elements and the consequent changing in Fe valence by the annealing treatment may lead to the hole-type doping, which is the origin for the occurrence of superconductivity. Our results pave the way for further in-depth investigations on the hole-doped 1111 system in iron-based superconductors.
Introduction
Iron-based superconductors (IBSs) have remained at the forefront of condensed matter physics since their discovery, primarily due to their high transition temperatures ($T_c$) and complex phase diagrams. Among the various families of IBSs, the "1111" system—characterized by a 1:1:1:1 stoichiometry such as $ReFeAsO$ ($Re$ = rare earth)—holds the record for the highest $T_c$ in bulk materials. However, a significant imbalance exists in the study of these materials: while electron-doped 1111 superconductors are well-documented, their hole-doped counterparts are notoriously difficult to synthesize. This rarity limits our understanding of the universal properties of iron-based superconductivity.
In this study, researchers address this gap by demonstrating a novel and relatively simple method to induce hole-doped superconductivity in CaFeAsF. By employing a post-annealing treatment in an air atmosphere, they achieved a $T_c$ of 30.7 K, marking a significant step forward for the 1111 family.
Experimental Methods and Synthesis
The research team synthesized high-quality single crystals of CaFeAsF using a self-flux method, alongside polycrystalline samples prepared via standard solid-state reactions. The pivotal innovation in this work is the post-annealing process. Samples were subjected to heat treatment at temperatures ranging from 300°C to 450°C in various gaseous environments, including air, pure $O_2$, $N_2+O_2$ mixtures, and $CO_2$.
To characterize the resulting states, the team utilized a suite of advanced techniques. Resistance and magnetization measurements were performed to confirm the onset of superconductivity and the Meissner effect. Structural integrity and changes were monitored via X-ray diffraction (XRD) and scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM). To probe the chemical changes driving the superconductivity, depth-resolved time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (TOF-SIMS) and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) were employed.
Structural Characterization and Lattice Expansion
A key finding of the structural analysis was the expansion of the crystal lattice following the annealing process. As shown in Figure 1, the XRD patterns for the annealed samples exhibit a clear shift in the diffraction peaks compared to the as-grown crystals. Specifically, the (006) peak shifts toward a lower angle ($2\theta$), which corresponds to an increase in the $c$-axis lattice constant.
This expansion is a direct consequence of the introduction of oxygen into the lattice. Because the $O^{2-}$ ion has a larger ionic radius than the $F^-$ ion it replaces, the crystal structure must expand to accommodate the substitution. The STEM imaging in Figure 1(a) further confirms the high crystallinity of the samples, with a measured lattice spacing of approximately 8.5 Å.
Superconducting Properties and Hole-Doping Mechanism
The annealed CaFeAsF samples exhibited a sharp drop in resistivity, with a superconducting transition onset at 30.7 K. This $T_c$ is notably higher than that of electron-doped variants, such as Cobalt-doped CaFeAsF, which typically peaks around 20 K. Magnetic susceptibility measurements confirmed the bulk nature of the superconductivity through the observation of the Meissner effect, with a diamagnetic signal appearing below 27.5 K.
The mechanism behind this transition is identified as hole-doping. The TOF-SIMS data revealed that oxygen penetrates the sample surface, creating a concentration gradient. XPS measurements showed a shift in the Iron (Fe) valence state toward a higher positive value after annealing. Since oxygen ($O^{2-}$) carries a higher negative charge than fluorine ($F^-$), its substitution into the lattice effectively removes electrons from the FeAs layers, thereby introducing holes. This hole-doping is the primary driver for the emergence of superconductivity in this system.
Interestingly, the choice of annealing atmosphere proved critical. While pure $O_2$ was tested, annealing in air or $N_2+O_2$ mixtures yielded superior results. The researchers suggest that pure oxygen may be too chemically aggressive, causing surface degradation that impedes the formation of a high-quality superconducting phase.
Discussion and Limitations
Despite the successful induction of superconductivity, several challenges remain. The TOF-SIMS analysis indicated that the oxygen diffusion is limited to a depth of approximately 150 nm. Consequently, the superconductivity is currently confined to a thin surface layer rather than the entire bulk of the crystal. This inhomogeneity explains the relatively low superconducting volume fraction (approximately 14-20%) observed in the samples.
Furthermore, while the Fe valence shift strongly supports the hole-doping hypothesis, definitive confirmation via Hall effect measurements is still pending. Such measurements are currently difficult due to the presence of the non-superconducting "parent" material in the core of the crystals.
Conclusion
The discovery of superconductivity at 30.7 K in air-annealed CaFeAsF provides a new and accessible route to studying hole-doped 1111 iron-based superconductors. By leveraging oxygen substitution as a doping mechanism, this work opens the door for further optimization of these materials. Future research will focus on achieving uniform oxygen distribution to create true bulk superconductors and exploring the full phase diagram of this promising system.
Summary updated