Judging from Support-set: A New Way to Utilize Few-Shot Segmentation for Segmentation Refinement Process

Seonghyeon Moon, Haein Kong, Muhammad Haris Khan, Kong, Haein, Khan, Muhammad Haris

Abstract

Segmentation refinement aims to enhance the initial coarse masks generated by segmentation algorithms. The refined masks are expected to capture more details and better contours of the target objects. Research on segmentation refinement has developed as a response to the need for high-quality image segmentations. However, to our knowledge, no method has been developed that can determine the success of segmentation refinement. Such a method could ensure the reliability of segmentation in applications where the outcome of the segmentation is important and fosters innovation in image processing technologies. To address this research gap, we propose Judging From Support-set (JFS), a method to judge the success of segmentation refinement leveraging an off-the-shelf few-shot segmentation (FSS) model. The traditional goal of the problem in FSS is to find a target object in a query image utilizing target information given by a support set. However, we propose a novel application of the FSS model in our evaluation pipeline for segmentation refinement methods. Given a coarse mask as input, segmentation refinement methods produce a refined mask; these two masks become new support masks for the FSS model. The existing support mask then serves as the test set for the FSS model to evaluate the quality of the refined segmentation by the segmentation refinement methods. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed JFS framework by evaluating the SAM Enhanced Pseudo-Labels (SEPL) using SegGPT as the choice of FSS model on the PASCAL dataset. The results showed that JFS has the potential to determine whether the segmentation refinement process is successful.

Introduction

Segmentation refinement is a critical post-processing step aimed at enhancing initial coarse masks to better capture object contours and fine details. While methods like the Segment Anything Model (SAM) have advanced this field, refinement is not always successful; it can sometimes introduce new errors or "hallucinate" boundaries, resulting in a mask that is objectively worse than the original. Currently, there is no reliable mechanism to detect these failures at inference time due to the absence of ground-truth labels for the target image. This paper introduces Judging From Support-set (JFS), a novel framework that repurposes Few-Shot Segmentation (FSS) models to automatically evaluate refinement success without needing ground-truth labels for the query image.

Methodology: The JFS Framework

The core innovation of JFS lies in "inverting" the standard Few-Shot Segmentation pipeline. In a conventional FSS setup, a model uses a labeled "Support Set" (image + perfect mask) to segment a "Query Image." JFS flips these roles to evaluate mask quality.

Comparison between the conventional FSS approach and the proposed JFS framework.

The JFS Logic

The JFS pipeline treats the target image and its candidate masks (the initial Coarse Mask and the Refined Mask) as the temporary Support Set. A separate, known labeled image (the original FSS support set) then serves as the Query.

The evaluation process follows these steps:

  1. An off-the-shelf FSS model (e.g., SegGPT) is prompted twice.
  2. In the first pass, the Coarse Mask is used as the support information to predict the mask of the known test image.
  3. In the second pass, the Refined Mask is used as the support information for the same test image.
  4. The quality of these two predictions is measured against the test image's ground truth using Intersection-over-Union (IoU).
  5. By comparing these scores, JFS decides which mask—coarse or refined—is superior. If the Refined Mask yields a higher IoU on the test image, the refinement is judged successful.
Detailed JFS pipeline illustrating the dual-prompting and error comparison process.

Experimental Evaluation

The authors validated JFS using the PASCAL VOC dataset and Wikimedia Commons images. They employed SAM Enhanced Pseudo-Labels (SEPL) as the refinement method and SegGPT as the FSS engine.

Key Results

  • Performance Gain: On a sample of 400 images, JFS-selected masks achieved a mean IoU (mIoU) of 65.2, surpassing both the coarse (59.8) and refined (64.5) masks.
  • Error Mitigation: In a "Low 20" subset where refinement significantly failed (dropping to 33.2 mIoU), JFS successfully identified these regressions and reverted to coarse masks, recovering the performance to 50.5 mIoU.
  • Reliability: JFS correctly identified the superior mask with a success rate between 52% and 68%, depending on the difficulty of the image subset.

Discussion and Future Work

JFS demonstrates that FSS models are highly sensitive to the quality of their support masks, making them effective diagnostic tools for segmentation quality. However, the framework faces challenges when coarse and refined masks are too similar or when background objects cause "false positive" correlations in the FSS model.

Future research could involve fine-tuning FSS models specifically for this "judging" task to improve decision accuracy. JFS represents a significant step toward making segmentation refinement more reliable in real-world applications where ground truth is unavailable.

Summary updated

Abstract

Segmentation refinement aims to enhance the initial coarse masks generated by segmentation algorithms. The refined masks are expected to capture more details and better contours of the target objects. Research on segmentation refinement has developed as a response to the need for high-quality image segmentations. However, to our knowledge, no method has been developed that can determine the success of segmentation refinement. Such a method could ensure the reliability of segmentation in applications where the outcome of the segmentation is important and fosters innovation in image processing technologies. To address this research gap, we propose Judging From Support-set (JFS), a method to judge the success of segmentation refinement leveraging an off-the-shelf few-shot segmentation (FSS) model. The traditional goal of the problem in FSS is to find a target object in a query image utilizing target information given by a support set. However, we propose a novel application of the FSS model in our evaluation pipeline for segmentation refinement methods. Given a coarse mask as input, segmentation refinement methods produce a refined mask; these two masks become new support masks for the FSS model. The existing support mask then serves as the test set for the FSS model to evaluate the quality of the refined segmentation by the segmentation refinement methods. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed JFS framework by evaluating the SAM Enhanced Pseudo-Labels (SEPL) using SegGPT as the choice of FSS model on the PASCAL dataset. The results showed that JFS has the potential to determine whether the segmentation refinement process is successful.
BibTeX
@misc{moon2024judging,
  author = {Seonghyeon Moon and Haein Kong and Muhammad Haris Khan and Kong, Haein and Khan, Muhammad Haris},
  title = {{Judging from Support-set: A New Way to Utilize Few-Shot Segmentation for Segmentation Refinement Process}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2407.04519},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.04519},
}
Figure