Study progression and degree completion of autistic students in higher education: a longitudinal study

Theo Bakker, Lydia Krabbendam, Sandjai Bhulai, Martijn Meeter, Sander BegeerHigher 2022 · DOI

Abstract

As enrollment of autistic students in higher education increases, understanding their academic progression is crucial for providing effective support. This exploratory population study utilizes structural equation modeling (SEM) to examine the academic trajectories of bachelor’s students with autism spectrum disorder (AS, n = 101) compared to students with other recorded conditions (OC, n = 2,465) and those with no recorded conditions (NC, n = 25,077) at a major Dutch university. By applying propensity score weighting to balance group characteristics, the research reveals that while GPA and dropout rates are largely comparable across groups, autistic students face specific challenges in their second year, particularly regarding exam participation, which impacts timely degree completion.

Introduction

Historically, research on the academic success of autistic students has been limited by small sample sizes and a lack of longitudinal perspective. This study addresses these gaps by analyzing how the academic paths of autistic students diverge from their peers over a multi-year period. Identifying specific friction points—such as particular years or types of assessments—allows universities to transition from generic support to targeted interventions that help talented students navigate the complexities of higher education.

Methodology

The study analyzed an institutional dataset of 27,643 first-year, full-time students across seven cohorts (2010–2016). To ensure a rigorous comparison, the researchers employed a two-step statistical approach:

  1. Propensity Score Weighting (PSW): Given the significant differences in group sizes and backgrounds, PSW was used to balance the samples based on sex, age, and secondary school performance. This ensures that observed differences in outcomes are more likely attributable to the student's condition rather than confounding demographic factors.
Table 1: Propensity score weighting results showing the balancing of AS, OC, and NC groups across various measures.
  1. Structural Equation Modeling (SEM): SEM was utilized to map the "flow" of academic success over three years. This model tracks how early performance indicators, such as Year 1 GPA and exam participation (including "resits" and "no-shows"), influence subsequent credit accumulation, retention, and ultimately, degree completion.
Figure 1: The structural equation model used to analyze the relationships between academic behaviors and outcomes over a three-year period.

Key Results and Insights

The analysis yielded several critical insights into the academic journey of autistic students:

  • Academic Parity in Performance: When controlling for entry-level qualifications, autistic students achieved GPAs nearly identical to their peers (averaging 6.5–6.8 on a 10-point scale). This suggests that academic ability is not the primary barrier to success.
  • The "Year 2 Slump": While Year 1 performance was stable across groups, a decline in credit accumulation for autistic students became evident in Year 2. During this period, the AS group earned significantly fewer credits (41.84 EC) compared to the NC group (49.82 EC). This divergence often coincides with increased curriculum complexity, including more group work and self-management requirements.
  • "No-Shows" as a Critical Predictor: A significant finding was the higher rate of "no-shows" (missing exams without a recorded reason) among autistic students in their second year. The SEM indicated that these no-shows had a stronger negative correlation with degree completion for the AS group than for their peers, serving as a behavioral proxy for anxiety, procrastination, or disengagement.
  • The Graduation Gap: Although dropout rates were similar across all groups (e.g., ~22% for AS vs. ~29% for NC in Year 1), autistic students were less likely to complete their degrees within the nominal three-year window, often requiring more time to reach the finish line.

Discussion and Limitations

While the study provides valuable longitudinal data, several limitations exist. The sample only included students who formally disclosed their diagnosis, potentially representing a subset more likely to seek support. Additionally, the researchers lacked data on the specific use and effectiveness of academic accommodations. Finally, the impact of final graduation assignments could not be fully modeled due to statistical constraints.

Conclusion

The overall academic performance of autistic students is comparable to their peers, yet they face unique hurdles in participation and navigation during the middle stages of their degrees. Universities should focus on improving inclusivity and addressing the "no-show" phenomenon through proactive support. Moving toward "Universal Learning Design" can create environments that benefit all students, reducing the burden of self-disclosure and bureaucratic navigation for those with autism.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Individuals with autism increasingly enroll in universities, but researchers know little about how their study progresses over time towards degree completion. This exploratory population study uses structural equation modeling to examine patterns in study progression and degree completion of bachelor’s students with autism spectrum disorder ( n = 101) in comparison to students with other recorded conditions ( n = 2,465) and students with no recorded conditions ( n = 25,077) at a major Dutch university. Propensity score weighting is applied to balance outcomes. The research shows that most outcomes (grade point average, dropout rates, resits, credits, and degree completion) were similar across the three groups. Students with autism had more no-shows in the second year than their peers, which affected degree completion after 3 years. The overall performance of autistic students appeared to be adequate and comparable to their peers. However, addressing participation and inclusivity is vital to improve academic support for students with autism. These insights can enable universities to develop appropriate and timely support for all talented students to progress in their studies and complete their degrees.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bakker2022study,
  author = {Theo Bakker and Lydia Krabbendam and Sandjai Bhulai and Martijn Meeter and Sander Begeer},
  title = {{Study progression and degree completion of autistic students in higher education: a longitudinal study}},
  booktitle = {Higher},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1007/s10734-021-00809-1},
}
Figure