Self-Determination of College Students With Learning and Attention Challenges

I‐Chen WuProceedings of the 2019 AERA Annual Meeting 2019 · DOI

Introduction

In the landscape of higher education, students with Specific Learning Disorders (SLD) and Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) often encounter significant barriers to academic success. Research consistently shows that these populations experience lower grade point averages and higher dropout rates compared to their neurotypical peers. A critical factor in navigating these challenges is "self-determination"—the ability to set goals, make choices, and take charge of one's life. While the importance of self-determination is well-established, there remains a gap in understanding how students with learning and attention challenges perceive their own abilities in this area. This study sought to bridge that gap by examining the self-perceptions and goal-setting behaviors of first-year college students.

Methodology

The researchers employed a mixed-methods approach to provide a comprehensive view of student self-determination, combining quantitative metrics with qualitative insights.

Quantitative Analysis

The quantitative component utilized the AIR Self-Determination Scale, a validated instrument that assesses two primary domains:

  1. Capacity: The student's internal skills, self-awareness, and knowledge required for self-determined behavior.
  2. Opportunity: The external support and chances provided by the school and home environments to practice these behaviors.

The scale further delineates the self-determination process into three distinct stages: Thinking (the conceptualization and setting of goals), Doing (taking the necessary actions to achieve those goals), and Adjusting (the ability to pivot and adapt when faced with obstacles).

Qualitative Analysis

To understand the nature of the goals students set, the researchers analyzed open-ended responses to the prompt: "Give an example of a goal you are working on now." Using a general inductive approach, they conducted a five-phase coding process to identify recurring themes in the students' aspirations.

Participant Profile

The study analyzed data from 641 first-year students enrolled in an alternative learning center at a large research university in the Southwest. The sample was 58.3% male and 40.6% female. In terms of disability profiles, 28.9% were diagnosed with ADHD, 17.6% with SLD, and 16.1% presented with comorbid conditions. The ethnic makeup was predominantly White (78%), followed by Hispanic (9%), Asian/Pacific Islander (4.5%), and African American (2.3%) students.

Key Findings: The "Thinking vs. Doing" Gap

The most significant finding from the quantitative data was a clear discrepancy between students' perceived abilities at different stages of the self-determination process. Students rated their capacity for "Thinking" (M=4.00) significantly higher than their capacity for "Doing" (M=3.76) or "Adjusting" (M=3.83).

This "Thinking vs. Doing" gap suggests that while these students are highly capable of conceptualizing their futures and setting ambitious goals, they struggle with the executive function required to execute those plans and navigate the inevitable setbacks of college life. Furthermore, students perceived their "Opportunity" (external support) as higher than their "Capacity" (internal skill), indicating that while support systems are in place, students have not yet fully internalized the skills needed for independent success.

Demographic and Diagnostic Variations

The study revealed important differences based on gender and diagnosis:

  • ADHD vs. SLD: Students with ADHD reported lower overall self-determination scores than those with SLD. This suggests that the specific executive function deficits associated with ADHD—such as impulsivity and difficulty with sustained attention—may pose unique hurdles to developing self-determination.
  • Gender Differences: Consistent with previous research, female students reported significantly higher levels of self-determination than their male counterparts. This finding highlights a potential need for more intensive, targeted interventions for male students with learning and attention challenges.

The Nature of Student Goals

The qualitative analysis of student goals directly challenged the "lazy" or "unambitious" stereotypes often unfairly applied to students with executive function challenges. The researchers identified three primary themes:

  1. Academic Goals (55%): The majority of students were focused on "Success in College," with specific aims like maintaining a high GPA or completing their degree.
  2. Health Goals (28%): These included both physical health (37%) and mental health (20%), showing a holistic approach to self-improvement.
  3. Employment and Finance Goals (17%): Students were also looking toward the future, focusing on career preparation (65%) and financial management (35%).

Implications and Future Directions

The findings suggest that educators and learning specialists should shift their focus from merely helping students set goals to supporting them through the "Doing" and "Adjusting" phases. Coaching that targets executive function—such as time management, task initiation, and resilience—is likely to be more effective than general academic advising.

While the study provides valuable insights, the authors noted limitations, including a potential socioeconomic bias due to the fee-based nature of the support program where the study was conducted. Future research should explore how students react to specific obstacles and identify which interventions, such as the frequency of meetings with specialists, most effectively bridge the gap between goal setting and goal attainment.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2019self,
  author = {I‐Chen Wu},
  title = {{Self-Determination of College Students With Learning and Attention Challenges}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the 2019 AERA Annual Meeting},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3102/1433236},
}
Figure