Study on the Psychological States of Olfactory Stimuli Using Electroencephalography and Heart Rate Variability

Tipporn Laohakangvalvit, Peeraya Sripian, Yuri Nakagawa, Chen Feng, Toshiaki Tazawa, Saaya Sakai, Midori SugayaSensors 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study proposes a novel method to objectively evaluate the psychological impact of olfactory stimuli, like aromas, by combining electroencephalography (EEG) and heart rate variability (HRV) data. By visualizing these biological signals on an "emotion map," the researchers offer a more nuanced understanding of how scents affect our arousal and valence states, with potential applications in neuromarketing and mental health.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In today's high-stress society, aromatherapy is gaining traction as a stress-relief method. However, quantifying its effectiveness has been a challenge. Traditional subjective methods like questionnaires can be unreliable for capturing immediate or unconscious responses. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a quantitative, objective method to assess the psychological states induced by olfactory stimuli, moving beyond simple "relaxation" claims to a more detailed understanding of arousal and valence.

Methods

The core of this research lies in the integration of two key biosignal measurement techniques:

  • Electroencephalography (EEG): A single-channel, low-invasive EEG sensor (Mindwave Mobile 2) was used to capture brain activity. Specific EEG indexes analyzed included "Attention-Meditation" (representing arousal/drowsiness), the ratio of high beta to high alpha waves (MA Hβ/Hα), and delta (δ) and theta (θ) waves, which are often associated with relaxation and sleep.
  • Heart Rate Variability (HRV): A pulse sensor (PPG) was used to measure heart rate variability. The study focused on two HRV indexes: pNN50 (related to valence/pleasantness) and RMSSD (related to stress/relaxation).

A novel aspect is the creation of an "emotion map." This visualization tool plots arousal (Y-axis) against valence (X-axis) using the extracted EEG and HRV indexes. This allows for a dynamic representation of how different olfactory stimuli shift a participant's psychological state. The data was normalized by subtracting baseline resting measurements to focus on the changes induced by the stimuli.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 62 participants (males and females, aged 20s-50s). Seven olfactory stimuli were used: six commercially available aromas (citrus, lavender, soap, woody, fruity, floral) and one unpleasant odor (isovaleric acid). The data was collected during a controlled experiment in a quiet room. No pre-existing datasets were used for training or evaluation; the study generated its own experimental data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Immediate and Adaptive Response: Olfactory stimuli elicit an immediate psychological response, but the human body gradually adapts to a more neutral state over time.
  • Gender and Generation Matter: The effects of olfactory stimuli are not uniform; they tend to differ significantly based on gender and age group, suggesting personalized approaches might be needed.
  • Unpleasant Odors vs. Aromas: Unpleasant odors can elicit a stronger arousal effect than pleasant aromas, particularly in younger males.
  • Delta Wave Potential: The delta wave (δ) shows promise as a generalizable EEG index for differentiating between aromas and unpleasant odors across genders and generations.
  • Emotion Mapping for Nuance: The "emotion map" provides a powerful visualization tool, offering a more detailed picture of psychological responses than isolated biosignal analysis.

Key Results

  • EEG Differences: Significant differences in Attention-Meditation and MA Hβ/Hα were observed between aromas and unpleasant odors, especially in male participants aged 20-30s. Delta wave responses also showed significant variations, particularly for unpleasant odors compared to aromas.
  • HRV Differences: Lavender was found to have a stronger influence on the parasympathetic nervous system (higher pNN50) for younger males, while citrus showed a stronger sympathetic influence. For older females, lavender also showed a stronger parasympathetic influence than soap and woody.
  • Emotion Map Findings:
    • Younger participants (both male and female) tended to exhibit low arousal and high valence (LAHV), suggesting relaxation.
  • Older participants (both male and female) tended to show low arousal and low valence (LALV), indicating a more nervous or less engaged state.
  • Time Course: The most pronounced effects of olfactory stimuli were observed in the first half of the stimulus exposure time (30 seconds for aromas).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Limited EEG Channel: The use of a single-channel EEG sensor (AF3) restricts the observation of brain activity to a specific frontal lobe region, limiting insights into hemispheric asymmetry.
  • Moving Average Smoothing: While effective for noise reduction, the moving average method might lead to information loss in high-frequency EEG bands (theta and delta).
  • Unpleasant Odor Strength: The concentration of the unpleasant odor might not have been strong enough to elicit a significant arousal response, and the shorter exposure time (30s vs. 60s for aromas) could have limited its impact.
  • Resting Condition Variability: Participants' potential excitement or nervousness during the initial resting period could have influenced baseline measurements.

Future work could involve:

  • Using more advanced EEG sensors to capture a wider range of brain activity.
  • Exploring alternative smoothing methods for EEG data.
  • Investigating the optimal concentration and duration for olfactory stimuli.
  • Further refining the emotion map by incorporating a broader range of arousal levels, especially the "low arousal area" associated with sleepiness and deep relaxation.
  • Expanding the analysis to include more biological indexes and exploring their combined predictive power.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the modern information society, people are constantly exposed to stress due to complex work environments and various interpersonal relationships. Aromatherapy is attracting attention as one of the methods for relieving stress using aroma. A method to quantitatively evaluate such an effect is necessary to clarify the effect of aroma on the human psychological state. In this study, we propose a method of using two biological indexes, electroencephalogram (EEG) and heart rate variability (HRV), to evaluate human psychological states during the inhalation of aroma. The purpose is to investigate the relationship between biological indexes and the psychological effect of aromas. First, we conducted an aroma presentation experiment using seven different olfactory stimuli while collecting data from EEG and pulse sensors. Next, we extracted the EEG and HRV indexes from the experimental data and analyzed them with respect to the olfactory stimuli. Our study found that olfactory stimuli have a strong effect on psychological states during aroma stimuli and that the human response to olfactory stimuli is immediate but gradually adapts to a more neutral state. The EEG and HRV indexes showed significant differences between aromas and unpleasant odors especially for male participants in their 20-30s, while the delta wave and RMSSD indexes showed potential for generalizing the method to evaluate psychological states influenced by olfactory stimuli across genders and generations. The results suggest the possibility of using EEG and HRV indexes to evaluate psychological states toward olfactory stimuli such as aroma. In addition, we visualized the psychological states affected by the olfactory stimuli on an emotion map, suggesting an appropriate range of EEG frequency bands for evaluating psychological states applied to the olfactory stimuli. The novelty of this research lies in our proposed method to provide a more detailed picture of the psychological responses to olfactory stimuli using the integration of biological indexes and emotion map, which contributes to the areas such as marketing and product design by providing insights into the emotional responses of consumers to different olfactory products.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{laohakangvalvit2023study,
  author = {Tipporn Laohakangvalvit and Peeraya Sripian and Yuri Nakagawa and Chen Feng and Toshiaki Tazawa and Saaya Sakai and Midori Sugaya},
  title = {{Study on the Psychological States of Olfactory Stimuli Using Electroencephalography and Heart Rate Variability}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/s23084026},
}
Figure