Study on the Present Situation and Optimization Path of Gamification Design in Chinese University Libraries

Yuchen Li, Jun-Yan Zhu, Yaxian Feng, Xingrui Yang, Yu ZhouJournal on big Data 2022 · DOI

Abstract

In this paper, 137 “First-class universities” and “First-class discipline” construction universities in China are selected as the objects of investigation to analyze the present situation and characteristics of the game design of University Library in China. Taking the university library in other countries as the reference object, this paper compares the differences of the game design of University Library in China and other countries, sums up the deficiency of the gamification service practice in Chinese university libraries. At last, this paper proposes an optimization path of the gamification design of Chinese University Library from six aspects: game type, game service object, game interactive mode, game application, game development, and game play-ability.

Introduction

As the global gaming market approaches a $200 billion valuation, traditional institutions like libraries are increasingly turning to "gamification"—the application of game design elements in non-game contexts—to enhance user engagement and information literacy. While elite "Double First-Class" universities in China have high adoption rates, their gamification efforts often suffer from "monotony." These services are frequently limited to one-time orientation experiences for freshmen, lack diverse interaction methods, and fail to engage a broader audience. This study maps the current landscape and proposes a strategic "optimization path" to transition these services into immersive, multi-user educational ecosystems.

Methodology

The researchers conducted a comprehensive status-quo analysis using three primary channels:

  1. Institutional Survey: A systematic review of official websites, WeChat public accounts, and mobile apps for 137 "Double First-Class" universities in China.
  2. User Interviews: Qualitative data collection from students to understand the "real-world" user experience.
  3. Comparative Literature Review: Benchmarking Chinese practices against international standards (specifically the US and Europe) using the CNKI database.

Current Landscape of Gamification in Chinese Libraries

The study found that out of 137 targeted universities, 133 had accessible digital platforms, and 120 (approximately 90%) provided some form of gamification. However, the quantitative breakdown reveals a heavy tilt toward simple mechanics and limited scope.

Distribution of game types in Chinese university libraries.

Quizzes are the dominant form (82.5%), followed by "Breakout" levels (41.67%) and "Treasure Hunts" (30.83%). Content-wise, 64.17% of games are designed for new student orientation, while 62.5% focus on general information skills development. Only 3.3% of libraries have implemented advanced "Scenario Simulation" games, which offer higher levels of immersion.

Comparative Analysis: China vs. International Standards

Comparing Chinese university libraries with international counterparts highlights several key gaps in game design, target audience, and development processes.

Comparison of library gamification between Chinese and international universities.

The "Orientation Trap" and Interaction Monotony

Chinese library games are overwhelmingly mobile-centric, relying on touchscreens and WeChat. In contrast, international libraries often utilize "maker spaces" with joysticks, VR/AR, and wearable tech. Furthermore, while Chinese libraries focus almost exclusively on students, international benchmarks show that games can build professional bonds among librarians and faculty.

The Developer Gap

Most Chinese library games are outsourced to third-party developers. International success often stems from involving students and faculty in the design process (e.g., through "GameJams"), which fosters community and aligns better with academic needs.

Optimization Path and Future Directions

To overcome current limitations, the authors propose a six-dimensional optimization framework:

  • Game Type & Application: Moving games out of the "orientation" silo and into professional courses like essay writing or information indexing.
  • Interactive Mode & Playability: Transitioning from simple 2D web interfaces to 3D, VR, and holographic projections to improve "playability" and reduce user fatigue.
  • Service Objects & Development: Engaging faculty and librarians as active participants and involving students in the development process to foster community and align with academic needs.
  • Incentive Alignment: Exploring how to link game participation with academic credits or performance points to sustain long-term engagement.

While this research focuses on the "Double First-Class" elite tier, it provides a roadmap for all institutions seeking to modernize library services through meaningful game design.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, 137 “First-class universities” and “First-class discipline” construction universities in China are selected as the objects of investigation to analyzes the present situation and characteristics of the game design of University Library in China. Taking the university library in other countries as the reference object, this paper compares the differences of the game design of University Library in China and other countries, sums up the deficiency of the gamification service practice in Chinese university libraries. At last, this paper proposes an optimization path of the gamification design of Chinese University Library from six aspects of game type, game service object, game interactive mode, game application, game development and game play-ability.
BibTeX
@article{li2022study,
  author = {Yuchen Li and Jun-Yan Zhu and Yaxian Feng and Xingrui Yang and Yu Zhou},
  title = {{Study on the Present Situation and Optimization Path of Gamification Design in Chinese University Libraries}},
  journal = {Journal on big Data},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.32604/jbd.2022.030660},
}
Figure