Study on the Effect of Spoiler Columns on the Heat Dissipation Performance of S-Type Runner Water-Cooling Plates

Xiongfei Zheng, Xue Hu, Lixin Zhang, Xinwang Zhang, Chen Feng, Chunliang MaiEnergies 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how adding spoiler columns (rectangular and elliptical) to S-type runner water-cooling plates for IGBT modules in wind turbines can improve heat dissipation. Both spoiler designs significantly reduced peak temperatures compared to a no-spoiler design, with the elliptical design offering a better balance of heat dissipation and fluid dynamics, leading to superior overall performance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As wind turbines increase in power, the Insulated Gate Bipolar Transistor (IGBT) modules, crucial for power conversion, generate substantial heat. Inefficient heat dissipation directly impacts the reliability and lifespan of these modules. Conventional S-type runner water-cooling plates, while functional, suffer from low heat dissipation efficiency. This paper aims to address this by exploring novel internal structures within these cooling plates to enhance their thermal performance without compromising coolant flow excessively.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Design and Simulation: Two new water-cooling plate designs were created, incorporating either rectangular or elliptical spoiler columns within the S-shaped flow channel. A baseline design without spoiler columns served as the control group. Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) simulations using Fluent software were conducted to analyze heat dissipation performance, coolant flow, and pressure drop for all three designs.
  • Experimental Validation: A laboratory bench was set up to experimentally validate the simulation findings. This involved fabricating the three water-cooling plate designs and testing their performance under controlled conditions. Key parameters measured included maximum static temperature and water flow rate at various inlet flow velocities and pump powers.
  • Comprehensive Evaluation: A comprehensive evaluation index ($\eta$) was introduced to quantify the trade-off between heat dissipation and energy consumption, providing a holistic measure of performance.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulation data generated by Fluent and experimental measurements from their custom-built test rig.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Spoiler Columns are Effective: The introduction of spoiler columns, regardless of shape, significantly enhances heat dissipation by disrupting the coolant flow and promoting turbulence, leading to a lower maximum temperature.
  • Elliptical vs. Rectangular: While both spoiler shapes improve heat dissipation, the elliptical design offers a superior balance. It achieves comparable or slightly better heat dissipation than the rectangular design while causing less obstruction to the coolant flow.
  • Fluidity Matters: The elliptical spoiler's streamlined shape leads to better coolant fluidity, evidenced by a higher flow rate and lower pressure drop compared to the rectangular spoiler. This is crucial for maintaining efficient cooling over time.
  • Comprehensive Evaluation is Key: A simple comparison of temperature isn't enough. The $\eta$ index, which considers both heat dissipation and energy consumption (pump power), provides a more accurate picture of overall system efficiency, highlighting the elliptical design's advantage.

Key Results

  • Temperature Reduction: At an inlet velocity of 2 m/s, the rectangular spoiler design reduced the maximum internal temperature by approximately 10°C compared to the control group. The elliptical design showed a similar reduction.
  • Flow Rate Improvement: For the elliptical spoiler design, at an inlet velocity of 2 m/s, the cooling water flow was 282 L more than the rectangular design in half an hour, indicating significantly better fluidity.
  • Pressure Drop Reduction: The pressure drop for the elliptical spoiler design was 25,576.6 Pa, which is 15,411.7 Pa lower than the rectangular spoiler design (40,988.3 Pa), signifying less energy loss.
  • Comprehensive Performance: The comprehensive evaluation index ($\eta$) was 26.2 for the rectangular spoiler and 31.6 for the elliptical spoiler, indicating the elliptical design's superior overall performance.
  • Experimental Validation: Experimental results largely corroborated simulation findings, showing consistent trends in temperature reduction and flow rate improvements with the spoiler designs.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simulation vs. Experiment Discrepancy: The paper notes that experimental values were generally lower than simulation values, attributing this to factors like thermal resistance in the experimental setup (e.g., between the water-cooled plate and heat plate) and heat radiation to the environment. The difference was more pronounced for the control group.
  • Flow Rate Measurement Difficulty: Direct measurement of internal flow rate within the water-cooled plate was challenging. The study used indirect methods (measuring flow rate at the outlet under different pump powers) to infer flow characteristics.
  • Optimization Potential: While the elliptical spoiler design is presented as superior, further optimization of its shape and placement within the S-shaped runner could potentially yield even better results.
  • Broader Application: The study focuses on IGBT modules for wind turbines. Future work could explore the applicability of these spoiler column designs to other high-power electronic cooling applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

To solve the problem of low heat dissipation efficiency for the conventional S-type runner water-cooling plate of the fan converter IGBT module, two new water-cooling plates were designed with rectangular and elliptical column structures in the S-shaped runner of the water-cooling plate. The heat dissipation performance, the fluidity of cooling water, and pressure drop of different spoiler column structures were compared using Fluent software for the simulation and experiment. The comparative results show, compared with the water-cooling plate without a spoiler column in the flow channel of the control group, that the spoiler column structure in the flow channel significantly improved the heat dissipation performance of the water-cooling plate. When the inlet velocity of the water-cooling plate was 2 m/s, the highest temperature inside the water-cooling plate with a rectangular spoiler column structure was 12.25 °C, lower than the control water-cooling plate. The highest temperature inside the water-cooled plate with an elliptical structure was 12.40 °C, lower than the control water-cooled plate. The obstructive effect of the elliptical spoiler column structure on water flow was smaller than in the rectangular spoiler column structure. The fluidity of the cooling water inside the elliptical spoiler column structure water-cooling plate was better. When the inlet velocity of the water-cooling plate was 2 m/s, the cooling water flowing through the former was 282 L more than the latter in half an hour. Compared to the pressure drop, we found that in the design group, the pressure drop of the water-cooled plate with a rectangular spoiler column structure was 40,988.3 Pa. The pressure drop of the water-cooled plate with an elliptical spoiler column structure was 25,576.6 Pa. The difference between the two was 15,411.7 Pa, which proves that the energy loss inside the latter is smaller. To further explore the relationship between the heat dissipation and energy consumption of the two types of water-cooled plates, the comprehensive evaluation index η was calculated, ηb = 26.2, ηc = 31.6; therefore, ηb was significantly smaller than ηc. The overall performance of the water-cooled plate with an elliptical spoiler column structure was superior.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zheng2022study,
  author = {Xiongfei Zheng and Xue Hu and Lixin Zhang and Xinwang Zhang and Chen Feng and Chunliang Mai},
  title = {{Study on the Effect of Spoiler Columns on the Heat Dissipation Performance of S-Type Runner Water-Cooling Plates}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/en15093085},
}
Figure