Study on Residual Stress Distribution in Thick Plate Welded Material Using Indentation Equipment

Sunchul Huh, Gwi-Nam Kim, Jong‐Seok Lee, Cheol-Hong Park, Joun-Sung Park, Wonjo ParkJournal of Ocean Engineering and Technology 2011 · DOI

Abstract

Recently, the production of shipbuilding and offshore plant industries, with a trend toward large structures, has led to an increased use of high-strength ultra-thick plates. The use of ultra-thick plates increases the welding tasks, and the welding process generates distortion and residual stress in the weldment because of the rapid heating and cooling. Welding distortion and residual stress in the welded structure result in many troubles such as deformation and life deterioration. In particular, the welding residual stress has an important effect on welding deformation, fatigue, buckling strength, and brittleness. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the residual stress at a multi-pass weldment using an experimental method for EH36 high-tension steel. In this experimental method, AIS3000 was used to measure the residual stress of a welded part, Heat Affected Zone (HAZ), and base metal; EPMA and XRD were used to study the material properties.

Introduction

In the shipbuilding and offshore industries, the shift toward massive structures requires high-strength, ultra-thick steel plates. Joining these plates necessitates multi-pass welding, a process involving rapid, repeated heating and cooling cycles. This thermal history creates residual stress—internal tension or compression that remains even after the metal cools. High residual stress is a significant threat to structural integrity, contributing to buckling, fatigue failure, and brittle fracture. While traditional methods like X-ray diffraction (XRD) or strain gauges are available, they often lack repeatability or are limited to surface-level measurements. This study aims to provide a more reliable, depth-sensitive profile of these stresses using instrumented indentation.

Experimental Methods

The researchers utilized 40mm-thick EH36 high-tension steel and performed a 5-pass V-butt weld, employing TIG for the initial pass and $CO_2$ welding for subsequent passes. The core analysis relied on Instrumented Indentation (AIS3000). Unlike traditional hardness tests, this system measures the continuous load-depth curve during indentation. By analyzing the deviation of these curves compared to a stress-free state, the system calculates local residual stress and flow properties.

Schematic of the weld zones and measurement points

To ensure the welding did not fundamentally alter the steel's phase or chemistry, XRD was used for crystal structure analysis and EPMA for chemical composition. Optical microscopy was also employed to observe grain size changes across the Base Metal, Heat Affected Zone (HAZ), and Weld Metal.

Results and Discussion

The study generated a primary experimental dataset including mechanical property tables and residual stress maps. Key findings include:

  • The HAZ Peak: The highest tensile residual stress consistently appears in the Heat Affected Zone (HAZ), rather than the weld metal itself. This is where the thermal gradient is most severe, leading to significant plastic constraint.
  • Depth-Dependent Relaxation: Residual stress is highest at the surface and decreases as one moves toward the center of the plate thickness. At depths of 15mm to 20mm, the measured residual stress approached zero.
  • Microstructure Correlation: The HAZ exhibited the finest, densest grain structure due to the specific thermal cycles of multi-pass welding, correlating with higher local hardness and yield strength.
Residual stress distribution at the top and side of the weldment

Quantitative results showed that the weld metal possesses higher strength than the base metal (Yield Strength: 344.9 MPa vs. 294.13 MPa). Hardness (HV) increased with depth in the weld zone, peaking at 393.9 HV at 20mm, likely due to cumulative heat effects. EPMA results confirmed that chemical levels remained within standard specifications for EH36 steel, indicating that stress variations were thermal/mechanical in origin.

Conclusion

This study confirms that instrumented indentation is a viable, highly repeatable alternative to traditional destructive testing for evaluating the "health" of thick-plate welds. While the cutting of specimens for internal measurements may cause some stress relaxation, the data provides a clear profile of stress distribution. Future work could involve coupling these empirical results with finite element method (FEM) simulations to predict stress states in even thicker plates and investigating the impact of environmental factors like sea-water corrosion.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recently, the production of shipbuilding and offshore plant industries, with a trend toward large structures, has led to an increased use of high strength ultra-thick plates. The use of ultra-thick plates increases the welding tasks, and the welding process generates distortion and residual stress in the weldment because of the rapid heating and cooling. Welding distortion and residual stress in the welded structure resulte in many troubles such as deformation and life deterioration. In particular, the welding residual stress has an important effect on welding deformation, fatigue, buckling strength, brittleness, etc. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the residual stress at a multi-pass weldment using an experimental method for EH36 high-tension steel. In this experimental method, AIS3000 was used to measure the residual stress of a welded part, HAZ, and base metal; EPMA and XRD were used to study the material properties.
BibTeX
@article{huh2011study,
  author = {Sunchul Huh and Gwi-Nam Kim and Jong‐Seok Lee and Cheol-Hong Park and Joun-Sung Park and Wonjo Park},
  title = {{Study on Residual Stress Distribution in Thick Plate Welded Material Using Indentation Equipment}},
  journal = {Journal of Ocean Engineering and Technology},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.5574/ksoe.2011.25.6.066},
}
Figure