Study of the Spatio-Temporal Variation of Agricultural Sustainability at National and Provincial Levels in China

Xuesong Zhan, Shuqi Xin, Chaofeng Shao, Yang Feng, Yuhan LongSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study develops a novel evaluation framework for agricultural sustainability in China, integrating global Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) with national agricultural realities. Using a Constant Elasticity of Substitution (CES) model, it reveals a significant national improvement in agricultural sustainability from 2011-2021, but also highlights persistent regional disparities and uneven progress across different SDGs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Achieving global Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), particularly SDG2 (Zero Hunger), is crucial for human civilization and national security. However, current assessments of agricultural sustainability often lack tailored indicators that account for diverse national development stages and data availability. Furthermore, existing research has a limited depth in analyzing the spatial and temporal dynamics of agricultural sustainability, especially at sub-national levels. This gap makes it difficult to pinpoint specific challenges and implement targeted policies for sustainable agricultural development, which is a critical bottleneck for achieving the SDGs. This paper aims to address these limitations by creating a localized evaluation system for China and analyzing its agricultural sustainability at national, regional, and provincial scales.

Methods

The study employs a multi-stage approach to construct and apply an agricultural sustainability evaluation system.

  1. Indicator Framework Development: It begins by drawing from international SDG indicator libraries and national agricultural development plans to create a comprehensive "Basic Index Library" of 86 indicators.
  2. Indicator Optimization: This library is then refined to a more manageable set of 25 specific indicators, considering China's development stage, agricultural characteristics, and data availability. This process aims to create a localized and practical evaluation system.
  3. Normalization: Indicator values are normalized to a 0-100 scale using a min-max method. This step is crucial for comparing diverse indicators and is adapted to handle outliers by considering international best practices and provincial performance.
  4. Aggregation (CES Model): The core of the methodology is the application of a Constant Elasticity of Substitution (CES) model. This model allows for the aggregation of indicators into target scores and then into overall SDG scores and the final Agricultural Sustainable Development Index (ASDI). The CES model is particularly useful as it can capture different degrees of substitutability between indicators, allowing for the analysis of "weak sustainability" (high substitutability, scores can compensate for each other) and "strong sustainability" (low substitutability, balanced performance across indicators is crucial). The study specifically uses elasticity values of $\sigma = \infty$ (weak sustainability) and $\sigma = 0.5$ (strong sustainability) to explore these scenarios.

Datasets

The study utilizes publicly available statistical data from various official sources in China, including:

  • China Statistical Yearbook
  • China Environmental Statistical Yearbook
  • China Rural Statistics Yearbook
  • China Energy Statistical Yearbook
  • China Population and Employment Statistics Yearbook
  • China Emission Accounts and Datasets

These datasets cover the period from 2011 to 2021 and are used to derive the values for the 25 selected indicators across 31 provinces. The data is organized according to nine major agricultural zones in China, as defined by the "China Comprehensive Agricultural Regionalization."

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Localization is Key: A significant contribution is the development of a China-specific indicator system for agricultural sustainability, moving beyond generic global frameworks to address national realities and data constraints.
  • Sustainability is Improving, but Unevenly: While the overall trend for agricultural sustainability in China is positive, the analysis reveals substantial regional disparities and uneven progress across different SDGs. This suggests that a one-size-fits-all approach to policy is insufficient.
  • The "Weak" vs. "Strong" Sustainability Debate in Practice: The use of the CES model with varying elasticity coefficients provides a powerful tool to illustrate how different assumptions about indicator substitutability can lead to different assessments of sustainability. The "weak sustainability" scenario generally yields higher scores, highlighting how strong performance in some areas can mask weaknesses elsewhere.
  • SDG6 Shines, SDG2 Struggles: SDG6 (Clean Water and Sanitation) consistently performs best, while SDG2 (Zero Hunger) lags significantly. This points to critical challenges in food security and related agricultural practices that require focused attention.
  • Regional Bottlenecks: The study identifies specific regions and provinces facing unique challenges, such as the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau's limitations due to climate and the Arid and Semi-arid Zones' issues with extensive cultivation and low yields.

Key Results

  • National ASDI Growth: China's Agricultural Sustainable Development Index (ASDI) increased from 44.76 in 2011 to 59.22 in 2021, representing an approximate 32.39% growth.
  • Provincial Improvements: All 31 provinces showed an upward trend in their ASDI scores over the study period.
  • SDG Performance: Among the six assessed SDGs, SDG6 had the highest overall score (84.76 in 2021), while SDG2 had the lowest (43.05 in 2021). All six SDGs showed an upward trend nationally.
  • Regional Variations: The Yellow-Huaihai Plain generally scored better, while the Sichuan Basin and Neighboring areas and the Yunnan and Guizhou Plateau Region scored relatively poorly.
  • Sustainability Scenarios: The "weak sustainability" scenario consistently yielded higher scores than the "strong sustainability" scenario across agricultural regions, underscoring the impact of indicator substitutability on overall assessment.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Indicator Selection: Some representative indicators were excluded due to data limitations, which could impact the comprehensiveness of the index system. Future research could focus on improving data availability and incorporating more nuanced indicators.
  • Policy Impact: The study did not explicitly evaluate the impact of specific policies on agricultural sustainability. Future work could explore this relationship to formulate more effective policy recommendations.
  • Food vs. Energy Dilemma: Due to a lack of specific agricultural energy data, the study could not fully reflect the complex interplay between food and energy security. Further research is needed to integrate these aspects.

The authors suggest that future research should focus on refining the indicator system, evaluating policy impacts, and exploring the food-energy nexus to provide more targeted and effective guidance for sustainable agricultural development in China and potentially other regions.

Summary updated

Abstract

As an important pillar of human civilization, the development of agriculture has gradually become the focus of the international community to solve the development dilemma and promote the implementation of the global Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Agricultural sustainability issues are widely addressed in scientific literature and various reports by international organizations. However, there are some problems in the existing studies, such as the design of agricultural sustainable development evaluation indicators does not consider the differences in development stages and data statistical capacity of various countries, and the research depth of spatial and temporal change of agricultural sustainable development is insufficient. Agriculture has become a bottleneck for the world and China to achieve the SDGs. Based on the global indicator framework of the Sustainable Development Goals and comprehensive consideration of agricultural development common problems and regional characteristics, this work has established a basic index library consisting of 86 indicators to evaluate the agricultural sustainable development in China and provide the basis for the assessment in different regions. In the indicator optimization process, having considered the development stage of China, the basic characteristics of agriculture, data availability, and reliability, we determined an evaluation index system of China’s agricultural sustainable development that includes 25 specific indicators. The constant elasticity of substitution (CES) model was used to assess the temporal and spatial changes in agricultural sustainability in China at the national, regional, and provincial levels. The results showed that China’s Agricultural Sustainable Development Index (ASDI) score increased from 44.76 in 2011 to 59.22 in 2021, and the ASDI scores of all agricultural regions and provinces also increased to varying degrees. In terms of goal scores, SDG2, SDG6, SDG7, SDG8, SDG9, and SDG12 all exhibited an overall upward trend, in which SDG6 performed the best, and SDG2 performed the worst, scoring 84.76 and 43.05 in 2021, respectively. This paper will provide a basis for systematically evaluating the progress of agricultural sustainable development goals and accurately identifying unsustainable problems in agricultural development to help China implement the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhan2023study,
  author = {Xuesong Zhan and Shuqi Xin and Chaofeng Shao and Yang Feng and Yuhan Long},
  title = {{Study of the Spatio-Temporal Variation of Agricultural Sustainability at National and Provincial Levels in China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su152215959},
}

Loading related content...

Figure