Studies on the growth habit of wheat varieties. 4. Relation between temperature effect and photoperiodism and its effect on the growth habit of wheat

Kosaku Nishio, M. Nakagawa, Shinji Watanabe, H. GochoIkushugaku 1962 · DOI

Abstract This study investigates the genetic and environmental factors—specifically temperature and photoperiod—that govern the growth habits of wheat. By analyzing nine varieties under varying conditions of vernalization, day length, and temperature, the researchers identified four distinct behavioral types based on their requirements for transitioning from prostrate to erect growth. The results demonstrate that while some varieties are inherently erect, others require specific combinations of cold (vernalization), long days, or high temperatures to trigger upright growth and subsequent heading.

Introduction

In wheat cultivation, the transition from a ground-hugging (prostrate) state to an upright (erect) state is a critical developmental milestone that dictates heading dates and grain production. Historically, the relative roles of winter chill and spring day length in triggering this transition were poorly understood. This 1962 study by Nishio et al. aimed to untangle these variables to provide a clearer genetic roadmap for breeding varieties suited to specific regional climates.

Methodology

The researchers employed a 2x4 factorial design using nine wheat varieties, including Japanese (e.g., Shinchunaga, Norin 8) and international (e.g., Wichita, Ceres) cultivars.

  1. Vernalization Treatment: Seeds were either untreated (Standard, 'S') or subjected to low temperatures (0–2°C) for 60 days during germination (Low-temperature treated, 'Lt').
  2. Environmental Conditions: After germination, plants were grown in four distinct plots:
  3. Control (C): Natural outdoor conditions.
  4. Long Day (L): 24-hour photoperiod.
  5. Short Day (Sh): 10-hour photoperiod.
  6. Greenhouse (G): High-temperature environment with natural day length.

Growth habits were tracked on a scale from Erect to Prostrate, alongside plant height and heading dates.

Figure 1: Variation of growth across different environmental treatments and vernalization states for nine wheat varieties. *[Studies on the growth habit of wheat varieties.

  1. Relation between temperature effect and photoperiodism and its effect on the growth habit of wheat, page 3](/pdf/art_ee9ebb8319384de1b61ca7589d290123#page=3)*

Results: Environmental Triggers and Growth Habits

The study revealed that the "prostrate" growth habit is not a single trait but a complex response to environmental cues. The varieties were classified into four behavioral types:

  • Type A (Eager Erect): Varieties like Shinchunaga and Norin 20 do not require cold. They grow upright immediately, with heading accelerated by light or heat.
  • Type B (Light-Seekers): Ceres remains prostrate until exposed to long days, regardless of cold treatment.
  • Type C (Heat-Seekers): Wichita transitions to erect growth upon experiencing high temperatures, showing less dependence on day length.
  • Type D (Winter Types): Varieties like Pawnee and Norin 8 are the most demanding, requiring both vernalization and long days to transition.

The Role of Vernalization

Vernalization acted as a "reset button" for Type D varieties. The 60-day cold treatment eliminated the prostrate habit, causing these varieties to behave like naturally erect types. This is most visible when comparing untreated (S) and treated (Lt) plants under long-day conditions.

Figure 2: Comparison of growth habits under long-day conditions for untreated (S-L) and vernalized (Lt-L) seeds. Note how vernalization (Lt-L) induces upright growth in varieties 6-9 compared to the untreated (S-L) group. *[Studies on the growth habit of wheat varieties.

  1. Relation between temperature effect and photoperiodism and its effect on the growth habit of wheat, page 3](/pdf/art_ee9ebb8319384de1b61ca7589d290123#page=3)*

Discussion and Conclusion

A key finding was the irreversibility of the growth transition. Once a plant moved from a prostrate to an erect state due to favorable conditions, it would not revert, even if conditions became unfavorable again. While the study relied on phenotypic observations rather than modern DNA sequencing, it established a foundational understanding of how temperature and light interact to control wheat development. These insights remain relevant for understanding how different varieties will respond to shifting climatic conditions and for selecting parents in breeding programs targeting specific environmental niches.

Summary updated

Abstract

The authors determined 3 main genetic factors affecting the growth habit of wheat in report 1. Among these 3 factors, E factor determines erect type, and both P and T factors control prostrate type though they differ in their effects on prostrate t ype. We also clarified changes in growth habit, elongation of plant height, and variation in heading date in 4 experimental plots, i.e., control, Iong day, short day (10 hours) in field culture, and normal culture in greenhouse as described in report 2. In this paper, we studied changes in growth habit, elongation of plant height, and variation in heading dates in 4 experimental plots ; control, 10ng day, short day (10 hours) in field culture, and normal culture in greenhouse, using the plants subjected to low temperature (O-2°C) treatment for 60 days and those not treated with low temper ature at the germinating stage. The results obtained are summarized as follows : 1) Varieties of erect type and those showing the prostrate type were different in their low temperature requirements at the seedling stage and there were varieties which required high temperature at young stage. Based on their behavior, we attempted to subdivide these varieties as follows: a. Varieties of erect type did not require low temperature at the seedling stage and the heading date was accelerated by either greenhouse culture or long day treatment (Shinchunaga and Norin 20). b. Among the 3 prostrate types, a variety belonging to the first type did not require low temperature at the seedling stage, but demanded long day for the change from prostrate to erect type in spring (Ceres). c. A variety belonging to the second prostrate type did not require low temperature at the seedling stage but needed high temperature, and it did not depend on long day for the change from prostrate to erect type (Wichita): ' d. Varieties showing the third prostrate type required both low temperature and long day fcr the changes from prostrate to erect type, and the effect of high temperature on the growth habit changes was mainly affected by day-light length (Pawnee, Norin 8 and Oinoue). Differences among the erect, prostrate, and medium types in their requirements for temperature and long day are shown in the following table. 2) Three kinds of prostrate type wheats seem to, be characteristic of the growth habit and the prostrate type appeared not only by low temperature but also by unfavorable environmental conditions. However, once after the prostrate type was changed into the erect one, the latter type did not change back to the prostrate type by unfavorab e environ mental conditions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{nishio1962studies,
  author = {Kosaku NISHIO and M. Nakagawa and Shinji Watanabe and H. Gocho},
  title = {{Studies on the growth habit of wheat varieties. 4. Relation between temperature effect and photoperiodism and its effect on the growth habit of wheat}},
  booktitle = {Ikushugaku},
  year = {1962},
  doi = {10.1270/jsbbs1951.12.101},
}
Figure