Genetical studies on ear-type affecting kernel shape in naked barley : I. Comparison of young ear developments among naked barley varieties

Shinji Watanabe, M. Nakagawa, H. Gocho, Kosaku NishioIkushugaku 1960 · DOI

Abstract

Ears and awns of barley vary significantly in length, leading to various classifications such as the Mm1 and Dm1 types. This study investigates the morphological development of young ears in four naked barley varieties to determine when and how these varietal differences emerge. Through microscopic analysis of ten developmental stages, researchers found that while early development is uniform, distinct differences in ear width and spikelet arrangement appear rapidly after late March. These findings link developmental timing and spikelet degeneration to final grain characteristics.

Introduction

In mid-20th-century agriculture, barley varieties were categorized primarily by the average length of their ears and awns. However, breeders observed that varieties within the same classification (e.g., the Mm1 type) often produced kernels with markedly different shapes and packing densities. This research addresses whether these final shapes are predetermined at the earliest stages of embryonic differentiation or if they result from varying growth rates and spikelet "attrition" (death) during later development. Understanding this timing is crucial for breeders looking to select for specific grain characteristics.

Methodology

The study examined four naked barley varieties from the Tokai-Kinki region: three Mm1 types (medium ear, long awn) and one Dm1 type (short ear, long awn). Researchers employed a longitudinal approach:

  • Microscopic Analysis: Young ears were observed across ten stages (I to X) using Inamura’s method.
  • Morphological Mapping: Ear width was measured at the upper, middle, and lower parts of the spike, distinguishing between main and lateral kernel rows.
  • Temporal Tracking: Growth was monitored from October sowing through May ripeness, recording stem length, rachis length, and spikelet counts.
Spatial mapping of barley spikelets showing main and lateral rows.

Results and Discussion

The most significant finding was the identification of a developmental "pivot point" around March 20th. Prior to this date, varietal differences in ear width were negligible.

Ear width development curves showing divergence after March 20th.

As shown in the growth curves, the characteristic widths of different varieties diverge sharply as they approach the heading stage. While all varieties begin with a similar potential (approximately 40 spikelets per ear by Stage X), the final yield is determined by the rate of spikelet degeneration at the top and bottom of the spike. By harvest, only 17 to 23 spikelets typically remain. Early-maturing varieties, such as Sagahadaka 1, reach milestones faster but suffer more severe spikelet loss.

Furthermore, the study revealed that in certain varieties like Kumashima 2, lateral rows eventually outgrow main rows in width, leading to the crowded kernel appearance typical of some six-rowed barleys. The length of the rachis (central axis) was confirmed as the primary determinant of the overall ear type (Mm1 vs. Dm1), with Dm1 types having significantly shorter, denser rachises.

Conclusion

This morphological study demonstrates that the final shape of barley ears is largely determined during a critical window in late spring. The divergence in ear width and the selective degeneration of spikelets are key factors in defining varietal kernel characteristics. Future breeding efforts should focus on the development of lateral kernel rows to improve grain uniformity and quality. This paper serves as the first part of a series linking developmental patterns to final commercial quality.

Summary updated

Abstract

Ears and awns of barley vary in length. TAKEZAKI(10) made an extensive study on the characteristics of awns and ears in relation to their lengths. Short awns were associated with short or medium ars ; medium-long and long awns with long ears. He classified cultivated barley into eight different types, Ds, Dm1, Ms, Mm2, Mm1, Ml, . Lm2 and Ll, based on average awn length (i. e. s-5cm, m-8cm, m-10cm and l-15cm) and on average ear length (i. e. D-5cm, M-8cm, and L-11cm). Main varieties cultivated in Tokai-Kinki district were restricted to Mm1 and Dm1 types. However, these varieties were different in width of the lateral kernel rows. The ear width varide in the upper, central and lower parts of a spike. In this study, morphological observations of the ear development were made at different stage I to X were made by microscopic tests following INAMURA's method(5) and the ears from the ear stage X to the heading stage by the use of magniging glass. The results of these observations which have been presented in tables and figures of the text are summerized as follows: 1)Using three varieties bilonging to the same ear type (Mm1) and one belonging to a different ear type (Dm1), measurements of the ear width of young ears were made at defferent locations on a spike (upper middle and lower parts) both in main and lateral kernel rows. Also the number of spikelets per ear and the internode length of spikelets were measured. Authors studied these characteristics of young ears in relation to the widths of young ears and other characters. 2)The developmental difference between Mm1 and Dm1 appeared during the period between March 20 and ripeness. The varietal difference sithin Mm1 also appeared during the same period.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{watanabe1960genetical,
  author = {Shinji Watanabe and M. Nakagawa and H. Gocho and Kosaku NISHIO},
  title = {{Genetical studies on ear-type affecting kernel shape in naked barley : I. Comparison of young ear developments among naked barley varieties}},
  booktitle = {Ikushugaku},
  year = {1960},
  doi = {10.1270/jsbbs1951.10.81},
}
Figure