STUD ON THE VIBRATION RESPONSE TO WINDS AND WAVES OF OFFSHORE WIND TURBINES WITH A DIFFERENT SUBSEA BASE STRUCTURE

Kinji Sekita, Tatsuki Hayashi, Atsushi Yamashita, Takashi IguchiPROCEEDINGS 2001 · DOI

Abstract

This research explores the dynamic stability of offshore wind turbines (OWTs) by examining how the choice of subsea foundation affects structural response to environmental loads. Using time-domain structural analysis on a blades-nacelle-tower-foundation system, the study compares three levels of foundation rigidity—ranging from flexible mono-piles to rigid caissons—under fluctuating wind and wave loadings. The findings demonstrate that foundation stiffness significantly shifts the system's natural periods and dictates vibration characteristics during both normal operation and extreme typhoon conditions.

Introduction

Offshore wind turbines are inherently dynamic structures, simultaneously subjected to turbulent wind forces and rhythmic ocean wave impacts. These combined forces cause oscillations that can lead to significant fatigue damage over a typical 20-year design life. As Japan plans nearshore wind farms in increasingly diverse environments, understanding the interplay between structural rigidity and environmental loading is paramount. This paper identifies how different subsea base structures—specifically mono-piles, jackets, and caissons—influence these vibrations to ensure long-term structural integrity.

Methodology

The researchers employed a time-domain structural analysis using a four-mass lumped parameter model. This model represents the nacelle/blades, two discrete points on the tower, and the foundation interface as masses connected by springs representing structural stiffness.

The 4-mass lumped parameter model used for the analysis, representing the turbine as a series of discrete masses and springs.

Three foundation cases were defined to represent a range of flexural rigidities:

  • Small Rigidity: Low stiffness, typical of a mono-pile in soft soil.
  • Medium Rigidity: Intermediate stiffness, such as a jacket structure.
  • Large Rigidity: High stiffness, characteristic of a concrete caisson.
The three foundation models compared in the study: Small (low rigidity), Medium, and Large (high rigidity).

Fluctuating wind time series were generated using established power spectra (Kato et al. and Ochi & Shin), while wave forces were calculated via the Morison equation. The system was analyzed under both "Normal" (12 m/s wind, 6m waves) and "Typhoon" (50 m/s wind, 11m waves) conditions, using specifications based on the ENERCON E-40 (500kW) turbine model.

Results and Discussion

The analysis revealed that foundation rigidity is the primary factor governing the vibration of the entire wind turbine body. A "Small" rigidity foundation resulted in a first natural period of 0.53s, whereas a "Large" rigidity foundation shortened this to 0.39s. This shift is crucial for avoiding resonance with environmental frequencies.

Tower response was characterized by a complex superposition: long-period sways driven by waves are overlaid with short-period vibrations from wind turbulence. In typhoon conditions, displacements increased dramatically; for the low-rigidity model, displacements were approximately five times higher than during normal operation. While the high-rigidity caisson model showed smaller overall displacements (roughly half those of the mono-pile in typhoons), its larger surface area made it significantly more sensitive to wave impacts.

Conclusion

There is no "one-size-fits-all" foundation for offshore wind; the choice must balance structural stiffness against the specific wind and wave climate of the site. Flexible foundations like mono-piles exhibit larger sways and higher fatigue risks, while rigid foundations offer stability but face greater wave-induced loads. Future refinements should include irregular sea states, more accurate aerodynamic damping models, and detailed soil-structure interaction to improve design precision for varied offshore environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

The construction of the wind farms in Japan has been planed nearshore such as oncaissons of a harbor. However several offshore wind farms have already been constructed in European countries.Since oscillations of the offshore wind turbine have potential of fatigue damage to the wind turbine structures, itis necessary to appropriately select from various sub sea base structures such as a mono-pile, a caisson and a jacket, corresponding to the soil condition of the foundations, water depth and environmental condition so on. Here weconducted the time domain structural analyses for a blades-nacelle-tower-foundation system subjected to fluctuatingwind and wave loadings in order to examine the effect of the sub sea foundation to the vibration characteristics ofthe system. The foundation structures having the three (high, medium, low) level of flexural rigidity were analyzed. Asfor wind force calculations, two kinds of offshore wind spectra were used, while wave forces were obtained through Morison equation with the associated area and volume of a sub sea base structure. The paper describes theresults of dynamic analyses for the structural system in the operational and extreme conditions along with the naturalperiods of the structural system.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sekita2001stud,
  author = {Kinji Sekita and Tatsuki Hayashi and Atsushi Yamashita and Takashi IGUCHI},
  title = {{STUD ON THE VIBRATION RESPONSE TO WINDS AND WAVES OF OFFSHORE WIND TURBINES WITH A DIFFERENT SUBSEA BASE STRUCTURE}},
  booktitle = {PROCEEDINGS},
  year = {2001},
  doi = {10.2208/prooe.17.55},
}
Figure