Abstract
Language model pre-training and derived methods are incredibly impactful in machine learning. However, there remains considerable uncertainty on exactly why pre-training helps improve performance for fine-tuning tasks. This is especially true when attempting to adapt language-model pre-training to domains outside of natural language. Here, we analyze this problem by exploring how existing pre-training methods impose relational structure in their induced per-sample latent spaces -- i.e., what constraints do pre-training methods impose on the distance or geometry between the pre-trained embeddings of two samples $\vec x_i$ and $\vec x_j$. Through a comprehensive review of existing pre-training methods, we find that this question remains open. This is true despite theoretical analyses demonstrating the importance of understanding this form of induced structure. Based on this review, we introduce a descriptive framework for pre-training that allows for a granular, comprehensive understanding of how relational structure can be induced. We present a theoretical analysis of this framework from first principles and establish a connection between the relational inductive bias of pre-training and fine-tuning performance. We also show how to use the framework to define new pre-training methods. We build upon these findings with empirical studies on benchmarks spanning 3 data modalities and ten fine-tuning tasks. These experiments validate our theoretical analyses, inform the design of novel pre-training methods, and establish consistent improvements over a compelling suite of baseline methods.
Introduction
The "pre-train then fine-tune" paradigm has become the cornerstone of modern artificial intelligence. By first exposing models to vast amounts of unlabeled data, researchers can develop versatile encoders that are later specialized for specific tasks. However, a fundamental question remains: why does this process work so effectively, particularly when applied to non-textual data?
Most traditional pre-training objectives, such as Masked Language Modeling (MLM), focus primarily on intra-sample relationships—the internal dependencies between tokens within a single sentence or sequence. While effective for generating coherent text, these methods often neglect the per-sample latent space. In many scientific domains, such as proteomics or citation analysis, the most critical tasks involve understanding how one entire sample (a protein or a research paper) relates to another. Current methods either ignore this global geometry or rely on "shallow" constraints that fail to capture the complex, high-dimensional relationships inherent in real-world data.
The Structure Inducing Pre-Training (SIPT) Framework
To address this gap, we introduce Structure Inducing Pre-Training (SIPT). This framework explicitly shapes the geometry of a model's latent space by leveraging external relational data. We redefine the pre-training loss ($L_{PT}$) as a dual-component objective:
- $L_M$ (Traditional Loss): A standard intra-sample objective, such as masked language modeling, to capture local sequence features.
- $L_{SI}$ (Structure-Inducing Loss): A novel term that regularizes the latent space based on a user-provided Pre-Training Graph ($G_{PT}$).
The core mechanism of SIPT is to guide the encoder ($f_\theta$) to produce embeddings where samples connected in the graph $G_{PT}$ are positioned closely in the latent space. Unlike implicit contrastive learning methods—which often only ensure that augmented versions of the same sample are similar—SIPT is explicit and deep. It uses a known relational map to preserve intricate manifold structures, ensuring that the latent space reflects the real-world connectivity of the data.
Theoretical Motivation
Our framework is supported by a theoretical analysis establishing a connection between relational inductive bias and downstream performance. We prove that the accuracy of a fine-tuned model is lower-bounded by the "local consistency" of the task labels over the pre-training graph. Essentially, if the graph used during pre-training accurately reflects the relationships relevant to the downstream task, the SIPT framework is mathematically guaranteed to improve performance. This shifts the focus of pre-training from simple feature extraction to latent space alignment.
Experimental Evaluation
We validated SIPT across three distinct data modalities and ten fine-tuning tasks to test its versatility:
- Proteins: Utilizing the Tree-of-Life interaction network (~1.5M sequences), where edges represent known protein-protein interactions.
- Scientific Abstracts: Using the Microsoft Academic Graph (~650K biomedical abstracts), where edges represent citation links.
- Biological Networks: Analyzing protein-protein interaction (PPI) ego-networks (~70K samples), with edges defined by Gene Ontology label similarity.
- Semi-synthetic Benchmarks: We also utilized Wikipedia sentences and Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA) topic modeling to create controlled graphs (e.g., Mobius strips and spheres) to verify our theoretical predictions regarding manifold preservation.
Key Results and Insights
SIPT demonstrated consistent improvements over a suite of competitive baselines, outperforming them in 10 out of 15 experimental settings and matching them in the remainder. Notable highlights include:
- Significant Error Reduction: We observed a 17.7% relative reduction in error on the ACL-ARC citation intent task and a 7.0% reduction on Remote Homology detection for protein folding.
- Efficiency: SIPT models reached higher performance thresholds significantly faster during the fine-tuning stage compared to standard pre-trained models, suggesting that the structured latent space provides a superior starting point for optimization.
- Deep vs. Shallow Structure: Our results suggest that while simple classification tasks only require "shallow" separation, complex real-world data exists on "deep" manifolds. SIPT’s ability to preserve these many-dimensional relationships is key to its success in specialized domains.
Conclusion
SIPT demonstrates that pre-training is most effective when it explicitly accounts for the relational structure of the data. By moving beyond intra-sample token relationships and incorporating global graph structures, we can create models that are not only more accurate but also more aligned with the underlying geometry of the domains they serve. Future work will explore more sophisticated negative sampling strategies informed by graph topology and the impact of higher-order topological features on pre-training objectives.
Summary updated