Stochastic Simulation Service: Bridging the Gap between the Computational Expert and the Biologist

Brian Drawert, Andreas Hellander, Benjamin B. Bales, Debjani Banerjee, Giovanni Bellesia, Bernie J. Daigle Jr., Geoffrey Douglas, Mengyuan Gu, Anand Gupta, Stefan Hellander, Christopher B. Horuk, Dibyendu Nath, Aviral Takkar, Sheng Wu, Per Lötstedt, Chandra Krintz, Linda R. Petzold

Abstract

Stochastic Simulation as a Service (StochSS) is an integrated, web-based platform designed to facilitate the transition from simple deterministic mathematical models to complex 3D spatial stochastic simulations. By providing a unified interface for model development, simulation, and cloud-based scaling, StochSS lowers the technical barriers that often prevent biologists from utilizing advanced stochastic modeling techniques. This paper describes the architecture of StochSS and demonstrates its utility through a comparative study of gene regulatory networks across different levels of modeling complexity.

Introduction

In systems biology, the role of stochasticity, or "noise," is increasingly recognized as a fundamental driver of cellular behavior. Processes such as gene expression, signal transduction, and chemotaxis often depend on the random interactions of individual molecules, particularly when species counts are low. While deterministic models based on Ordinary Differential Equations (ODEs) provide a useful starting point, they fail to capture the discrete and random nature of these biological systems.

However, the transition to stochastic modeling—especially spatial stochastic modeling—is fraught with technical challenges. Researchers must often navigate a fragmented landscape of specialized software, master complex mesh generation for cellular geometries, and manage high-performance computing resources. StochSS was developed to bridge this gap, offering an Integrated Development Environment (IDE) that abstracts these complexities and allows researchers to scale their models and computational resources seamlessly.

Methods and Platform Architecture

StochSS is built as a web-based IDE that wraps several high-performance simulation engines into a cohesive workflow.

Model Development and Conversion

The platform features a graphical Model Editor for defining species, reactions, and parameters. To assist researchers transitioning from traditional modeling, StochSS includes a conversion tool that automatically transforms deterministic models into discrete stochastic formulations.

Simulation Engines

StochSS integrates three primary levels of simulation:

  1. Deterministic: Utilizes CVODES (from the SUNDIALS package) for solving stiff ODEs.
  2. Well-mixed Stochastic: Employs StochKit2, which implements the Gillespie Stochastic Simulation Algorithm (SSA) and adaptive tau-leaping methods.
  3. Spatial Stochastic: Uses PyURDME for 3D simulations on unstructured meshes, employing the Next Subvolume Method (NSM).

Geometry and Mesh Generation

For spatial models, StochSS integrates Gmsh, allowing users to generate or import complex 3D geometries. This enables the simulation of molecular dynamics within realistic cellular environments, including distinct compartments like the nucleus and cytoplasm.

Cloud Infrastructure and Parameter Fitting

To handle the high computational demands of spatial simulations, StochSS provides a "Clusters On-Demand" feature. This allows users to launch and manage Amazon EC2 compute nodes directly from the web interface, removing the need for manual server configuration. Additionally, the StochOptim module provides parameter estimation capabilities using a Monte Carlo Expectation-Maximization (MCEM^2) algorithm.

Case Study: Gene Regulatory Networks

The platform's capabilities were evaluated using a Gene Regulatory Network (GRN) model characterized by negative feedback. Parameters were derived from the BioNumbers database to ensure biological relevance. The system was analyzed at three levels of complexity:

  1. Deterministic (ODE): The model predicted a stable steady state, failing to capture any oscillatory behavior.
  2. Well-mixed Stochastic: The introduction of molecular noise revealed "bursty" expression patterns and apparent oscillations, highlighting the importance of stochasticity in GRN dynamics.
  3. Spatial Stochastic: 3D simulations confirmed that these stochastic oscillations persist when accounting for the physical dimensions of the cell and the diffusion of molecules between the nucleus and cytoplasm.

Performance Analysis

The computational cost of increasing model complexity is significant. Benchmarks performed on the GRN model illustrate this trade-off:

Model Type Computational Cost
Single ODE Solve ~0.06 seconds
10,000 Stochastic Realizations ~84 seconds
Single Spatial Trajectory ~197 seconds

These results underscore the necessity of the cloud-scaling features provided by StochSS, particularly when performing ensemble simulations or parameter sweeps for spatial models.

Discussion and Future Work

StochSS represents a significant step toward making advanced computational tools accessible to the broader biological community. By abstracting the "DevOps" and numerical complexities, it allows researchers to focus on biological inquiry.

Future developments for StochSS include the implementation of hybrid solvers that can simultaneously handle deterministic and stochastic components to improve efficiency. The authors also aim to expand cloud support to private and alternative public providers and enhance data analysis capabilities through integration with interactive environments like Jupyter Notebooks. Furthermore, the community continues to work toward better standards for spatial model exchange to improve reproducibility and portability across platforms.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present StochSS: Stochastic Simulation as a Service, an integrated development environment for modeling and simulation of both deterministic and discrete stochastic biochemical systems in up to three dimensions. An easy to use graphical user interface enables researchers to quickly develop and simulate a biological model on a desktop or laptop, which can then be expanded to incorporate increasing levels of complexity. StochSS features state-of-the-art simulation engines. As the demand for computational power increases, StochSS can seamlessly scale computing resources in the cloud. In addition, StochSS can be deployed as a multi-user software environment where collaborators share computational resources and exchange models via a public model repository. We demonstrate the capabilities and ease of use of StochSS with an example of model development and simulation at increasing levels of complexity.
BibTeX
@article{drawert2016stochastic,
  author = {Brian Drawert and Andreas Hellander and Benjamin B. Bales and Debjani Banerjee and Giovanni Bellesia and Bernie J. Daigle Jr. and Geoffrey Douglas and Mengyuan Gu and Anand Gupta and Stefan Hellander and Christopher B. Horuk and Dibyendu Nath and Aviral Takkar and Sheng Wu and Per Lötstedt and Chandra Krintz and Linda R. Petzold},
  title = {{Stochastic Simulation Service: Bridging the Gap between the Computational Expert and the Biologist}},
  journal = {PLOS Computational Biology},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pcbi.1005220},
}
Figure