Stochastic Online Linear Regression: the Forward Algorithm to Replace Ridge

Reda Ouhamma, Odalric Maillard, Vianney Perchet

TL;DR

This paper revisits online linear regression in a stochastic setting, deriving new high-probability regret bounds for the forward and ridge algorithms. The authors demonstrate that the forward algorithm offers superior performance and robustness, especially when dealing with potentially unbounded data, advocating for its use over ridge regression in many practical scenarios.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Online linear regression is a fundamental problem where a model learns to predict a target variable based on a sequence of feature vectors, updating its parameters after each prediction. A common goal is to minimize "regret," which measures how much worse the online learner performs compared to an ideal offline learner. Traditional analyses often assume bounded observations and predictions, which can be overly restrictive in real-world applications. This paper addresses the limitations of these assumptions by analyzing online linear regression in a stochastic setting with potentially unbounded data, aiming to provide more accurate comparisons between algorithms like ridge regression and the forward algorithm, and to understand their practical implications.

Methods

The authors derive new high-probability regret bounds for both the online ridge regression and the forward algorithm under a stochastic setting with sub-Gaussian noise. A key contribution is the development of a refined analysis that does not rely on bounded observations or predictions. This involves:

  • Novel Analysis: Revisiting the theoretical analysis of the forward algorithm to account for phenomena not captured by adversarial settings, particularly the concentration of parameter estimates.
  • High-Probability Bounds: Establishing bounds that hold with high probability uniformly over time horizons, rather than just for specific time steps.
  • Regret Equivalence: Demonstrating that a more practitioner-friendly regret definition (comparing to the true parameter) is equivalent in the first order to the standard online-to-batch conversion regret.
  • Algorithm Modification: Showing how to integrate the forward algorithm into linear function approximation settings to remove boundedness assumptions without sacrificing theoretical guarantees.
  • Application to Bandits: Extending the analysis to linear bandit settings, demonstrating improved regret bounds for a forward-variant of the OFUL algorithm.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments use synthetic data generated according to the described stochastic linear model and bandit settings.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Forward Algorithm's Superiority: The forward algorithm consistently outperforms ridge regression in the stochastic setting, particularly due to its robustness to the regularization parameter.
  • Limitations of Adversarial Analysis: Existing analyses for adversarial settings can be misleading when applied to stochastic scenarios, potentially overestimating the performance of ridge regression and underestimating the benefits of the forward algorithm.
  • Unboundedness is Key: The ability to handle unbounded observations and predictions without explicit clipping is crucial for practical applications and is a strength of the forward algorithm's analysis.
  • Robustness to Regularization: The forward algorithm's performance is less sensitive to the choice of the regularization parameter (λ) compared to ridge regression, making it more practical.
  • Theoretical Justification for Practical Choice: The paper provides theoretical backing for why the forward algorithm is often a better choice in practice, especially in bandit settings.

Key Results

  • High-Probability Regret Bounds: The paper derives novel high-probability regret bounds for online ridge regression and the forward algorithm in the stochastic setting.
  • Forward Algorithm's Advantage: The derived bounds show that the forward algorithm achieves better performance and is more robust to the regularization parameter than ridge regression.
  • Improved Bandit Performance: A modified OFUL algorithm using the forward regression approach achieves better regret bounds in linear bandit settings, particularly when rewards are unbounded.
  • Experimental Validation: Numerical experiments demonstrate the robustness of the forward algorithm to regularization and its competitive performance against other algorithms in both online regression and linear bandit settings.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: While the theoretical analysis is strong, the paper doesn't extensively discuss the computational complexity of the forward algorithm compared to ridge regression in practice, though it's generally comparable.
  • Open Questions: The paper mentions that double uniformity over features and observations for forward regression in the adversarial setting remains an open question.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest extending their analysis to other settings like non-stationary linear bandits (which they explore in an appendix), graph bandits, and meta-learning with linear bandits, highlighting the broad applicability of the forward algorithm. They also note that while their findings are theoretical, they have implications for areas like advertising and scientific research.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider the problem of online linear regression in the stochastic setting. We derive high probability regret bounds for online ridge regression and the forward algorithm. This enables us to compare online regression algorithms more accurately and eliminate assumptions of bounded observations and predictions. Our study advocates for the use of the forward algorithm in lieu of ridge due to its enhanced bounds and robustness to the regularization parameter. Moreover, we explain how to integrate it in algorithms involving linear function approximation to remove a boundedness assumption without deteriorating theoretical bounds. We showcase this modification in linear bandit settings where it yields improved regret bounds. Last, we provide numerical experiments to illustrate our results and endorse our intuitions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ouhamma2021stochastic,
  author = {Reda Ouhamma and Odalric Maillard and Vianney Perchet},
  title = {{Stochastic Online Linear Regression: the Forward Algorithm to Replace Ridge}},
  booktitle = {Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=Dj4F7xYOxXk},
}
Figure