Stochastic ℓp Load Balancing and Moment Problems via the L-Function Method

Marco Molinaro

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "L-function method" to tackle stochastic optimization problems involving powers of random variables, specifically focusing on the challenging Stochastic ℓp Load Balancing problem. They achieve a constant-factor approximation for this problem, improving upon previous results and offering a more general algorithmic framework.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles a class of stochastic optimization problems where the objective function involves powers of sums of random variables. A prime example is the Stochastic ℓp Load Balancing Problem (STOCHLOADBALp). In this problem, we have $m$ machines and $n$ jobs. Each job $j$ incurs a random load $Y_{ij}$ on machine $i$ if assigned to it. The goal is to assign each job to a machine to minimize the expected $ℓ_p$-norm of the total load on each machine. Mathematically, this is to minimize $E[ (\sum_{i \in [m]} (\sum_{j \in J_i} Y_{ij})^p)^{1/p} ]$, where $J_i$ is the set of jobs assigned to machine $i$.

A key challenge in these problems is that the objective function involves expectations of powers of sums of random variables, making it difficult to express in a way that depends only on individual random variables (i.e., separable). Traditional convex programming approaches struggle with this multi-dimensional integration. While some progress has been made using notions like "effective size" for $ℓ_\infty$ problems, extending these to general $ℓ_p$ power objectives has been elusive, with prior work achieving only a $O(m)$-approximation for STOCHLOADBALp.

Methods

The core contribution of this paper is the introduction and application of the L-function method. This method, originally developed by Latała, provides a way to sharply bound the moments of sums of random variables by considering their individual "effective sizes" (denoted $v_{\varepsilon,p}(X)$). The paper shows how this method can be used to:

  • Approximate $p$-power-type objectives: The L-function method allows for capturing $p$-power-type objectives in a separable manner, leading to constant-factor approximations for general subset selection problems with $p$-moment objectives.
  • Solve STOCHLOADBALp: For STOCHLOADBALp, the application is more intricate. It involves:
  • Proving a converse to Jensen's inequality: Establishing a bound that relates the expected $ℓ_p$-norm of a random vector to the $p$-moments of its coordinate-marginals, crucial for controlling machine loads.
  • Formulating a complex LP: A large-scale linear program (LP) is formulated with exponentially many constraints to capture the problem's structure and the L-function method's requirements.
  • Reducing the LP: The large LP is then reduced to a more manageable one by carefully selecting parameters based on the proof of Theorem 6.
  • Leveraging Generalized Assignment Problem (GAP) algorithms: The reduced LP is then solved using existing algorithms for the Generalized Assignment Problem to obtain an integral assignment.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The L-function method as a unifying tool: The paper demonstrates the power of the L-function method in providing sharp bounds on moments of sums of random variables, offering a new algorithmic paradigm for stochastic optimization.
  • Bridging the gap for $ℓ_p$ objectives: The work successfully extends the "effective size" concept to handle $p$-power objectives, which was a significant hurdle for previous approaches.
  • The importance of moment comparisons: The proof relies on a non-trivial converse to Jensen's inequality, highlighting the need for precise moment comparisons to control stochastic objectives.
  • Algorithmic elegance through LP reduction: The strategy of formulating a large LP and then reducing it to a solvable form by carefully selecting parameters is a key algorithmic insight.

Key Results

  • Constant-factor approximation for STOCHLOADBALp: The paper provides a constant-factor approximation for the Stochastic $ℓ_p$ Load Balancing problem for all $p \in [1, \infty]$. This improves upon the $O(m)$-approximation previously known.
  • Constant-factor approximation for general subset selection: The L-function method yields a constant-factor approximation for a general subset selection problem with $p$-moment objectives.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Complexity of the initial LP: The initial LP formulation has an exponential number of constraints, requiring a sophisticated reduction step.
  • Technical details in proofs: The proofs, particularly those involving moment comparisons and the L-function method's application, are technically involved.
  • Future work: The authors suggest that the L-function method could find many additional applications in stochastic optimization problems. The paper also hints at potential extensions and further refinements of the techniques presented.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{molinaro2019stochastic,
  author = {Marco Molinaro},
  title = {{Stochastic ℓp Load Balancing and Moment Problems via the L-Function Method}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1810.05245},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1810.05245},
}
Figure