Abstract
In traditional models, votes are an expression of preferences and beliefs. Psychological theories of cognitive dissonance suggest, however, that behavior may shape preferences. In this view, the very act of voting may influence political attitudes. A vote for a candidate may lead to more favorable interpretations of his actions in the future. We test the empirical relevance of cognitive dissonance in US Presidential elections. The key problem in such a test is the endogeneity of voter choice which leads to a mechanical relationship between voting and preferences. We use the voting age restrictions to help surmount this difficulty. We examine the Presidential opinion ratings of nineteen and twenty year olds two years after the President's election. Consistent with cognitive dissonance, we find that twenty year olds (who were eligible to vote in the election) show greater polarization of opinions than comparable nineteen year olds (who were ineligible to vote). We rule out that aging drives these results in two ways. First, we find no polarization differences in years in which twenty and nineteen year olds would not have differed in their eligibility to vote in the prior Presidential election. Second, we show a similar effect when we compare polarization (for all age groups) in opinions of Senators elected during high turnout Presidential campaign years with Senators elected during low turnout non-Presidential campaign years. Thus we find empirical support for the relevance of cognitive dissonance to voting behavior. This finding has at least three implications for the dynamics of voting behavior. First, it offers a new rationale for the incumbency advantage. Second, it suggests that there is an efficiency argument for term limits. And finally, our results demonstrate that efficiency may not be increasing in turnout level.
Introduction: The Psychological Basis of Voting
In standard economic models, a vote is a simple expression of pre-existing preferences. However, psychologists have long argued that the arrow of causality can also run in reverse: our actions can shape our beliefs. This phenomenon is known as cognitive dissonance. When an individual makes a public commitment—such as casting a ballot—they may experience internal discomfort if their subsequent beliefs do not align with that action. To resolve this dissonance, the brain may unconsciously filter new information to favor the chosen candidate, leading to a self-reinforcing cycle of support.
The primary challenge in proving this effect is endogeneity. If a voter approves of a President two years after an election, it is difficult to discern whether that approval stems from the act of voting itself or from the same underlying preferences that drove the initial vote. To isolate the effect of the act of voting, Sendhil Mullainathan and Ebonya Washington utilize exogenous factors that influence voting eligibility and turnout without being tied to the intensity of a person's political preferences.
Methodology
The authors employ two distinct identification strategies to bypass the endogeneity problem, utilizing the National Election Studies (NES) dataset (1948–2002):
- Age-Based Discontinuity: The study compares the attitudes of 18–21-year-olds during non-Presidential election years. Within this cohort, 20–21-year-olds were eligible to vote in the previous Presidential election, while 18–19-year-olds were not (having been 16–17 at the time). Because these groups are only two years apart, they are demographically similar, but only one group had the opportunity to "commit" via a vote.
- Senatorial Turnout Variation: Turnout for Senatorial elections is significantly higher during Presidential election years than during midterm "off-years." The authors compare the polarization of opinions toward Senators elected during these high-turnout years versus those elected during low-turnout years across a sample of over 14,000 observations.
- Falsification Tests: To ensure results were not merely a byproduct of aging, the authors compared 20–21-year-olds to 22–23-year-olds (both previously eligible). They found no significant difference in polarization between these groups, supporting the theory that the eligibility threshold is the driver of the effect.
Key Results
The Polarization Effect
The act of voting appears to function as a concrete act of commitment. In the age-eligibility test, eligible youth were nearly twice as polarized as their ineligible counterparts. On a 100-point "feeling thermometer," the party-based difference in ratings was approximately 10 points for the ineligible group but jumped by an additional 9.8 points for the eligible group.
Similarly, attitudes toward Senators elected in high-turnout Presidential years were roughly 22% more polarized than toward those elected in non-Presidential years. This suggests that the increased turnout "locks in" a larger portion of the electorate to their chosen candidates.
Information vs. Dissonance
A potential counter-argument is that voters simply "learn more" about candidates during an election. However, the authors found no significant difference in political knowledge or interest between the eligible and ineligible groups. This suggests the shift in attitude is indeed driven by psychological dissonance rather than an information advantage.
Discussion and Implications
These findings provide a psychological foundation for several political phenomena:
- Incumbency Advantage: Because more than half the electorate typically votes for the winner, a majority of the voting population becomes psychologically predisposed to view the incumbent's subsequent actions favorably. This makes incumbents significantly harder to unseat.
- The Turnout Paradox: While high turnout is often viewed as a hallmark of a healthy democracy, this research suggests a trade-off. Higher turnout may lead to a more biased and polarized electorate, as more citizens become "wedded" to their past choices regardless of performance.
- Efficiency and Term Limits: If voters are biased toward their past choices, they may fail to hold underperforming leaders accountable. This provides a new efficiency-based argument for term limits as a way to "reset" the electorate's psychological commitments.
While the study is limited by the sample size of the youth cohort and the specific timeframe of the NES data, it strongly suggests that the act of voting is not just a reflection of who we are, but a catalyst for who we become as political actors.
Summary updated